List Mgmt. 2023 Trade & List Management Thread III

[Colby Cheer Squad]

Room for him at the Dawks with Breust leaving soon. He'll see out that contract, courtesy of the LT school of Conning The Umps

Don't know if you've noticed but he stopped getting free kicks over a year ago which is why he struggled to find a place in the team.

 

[The Filth Wizard]

Will be for Reid, Eagles want 2 and another top 10 pick. Have that from a good source. Those teens pick of ours wont do it with WCE.

Be looking at Geelongs/Essendons etc. May look to get WCE 22 involved in the deal.

Then these are future swaps. I reckon it gets done.

Big price to pay though. Basically giving up Caddy to go from McArch to Reid.

For sure it's what the Eagles want but don't be surprised if we've set our own parameters on any potential trade now it's clearer they have McKercher in the frame.

 

[koshari]

Depends on his preseason. He and X both need massive ones.

so he is going to learn to ruck and mark , all in the one preseason???

i get the opinion that some people didnt even watch the games he played last year, either that or we are talking about different players???

 

[GoRoos2023]

Is Reid that far ahead of McKercher to make this a sensible deal?

I really wouldn't know, I think looking at historic drafts it is highly UNLIKELY you would go back in time and win if you traded 1 for 2/7 etc.

 

[zoomba23]

Don't know if you've noticed but he stopped getting free kicks over a year ago which is why he struggled to find a place in the team.

He stopped, then Collingwood fans kicked up a stink and now he gets them again

 

[speedy]

I think I'm gonna hate Ginnivan even more in a piss and shit jumper.

 

[Colby Cheer Squad]

Yeah I really hope we aren't moving up to give that pic to WC. As mentioned we are giving up Mckercher and a Caddy type for it....silly IMO

It might also be O'Sullivan rather than Caddy.

 

[Sillygit]

Will be for Reid, Eagles want 2 and another top 10 pick. Have that from a good source. Those teens pick of ours wont do it with WCE.

Be looking at Geelongs/Essendons etc. May look to get WCE 22 involved in the deal.

Then these are future swaps. I reckon it gets done.

Big price to pay though. Basically giving up Caddy to go from McArch to Reid.

REALLY not a fan of this

 

[Farthers]

 

[koshari]

Don't know if you've noticed but he stopped getting free kicks over a year ago which is why he struggled to find a place in the team.

still knows where the goals are...

 

[North Viking]

Really not a fan of this unless we're actively looking for someone to fill the last senior list spot. North in the position to fix a lot of its list issues in a single year. Don't throw it away.

Quality over quantity for me.
We aint going to fix the list in one draft

 

[apollo_creed]

Ginnivan would be in our best side right now but in 2 or 3 years he probably wouldn't be. He has obvious limitations and while his skillset would improve our side in the current I don't think there is any value in pursuing him. Glad that the club (seemingly) stayed out of it.

 

[Footywizard]

I'd be reasonably content talking Reid Mckercher and pick 15

Also as content talking 2 3 (10) 15 if that's how it went.

Either way we're getting some elite talent we can't really lose.

 

[GoRoos2023]

I'd be reasonably content talking Reid Mckercher and pick 15

Also as content talking 2 3 (10) 15 if that's how it went.

Either way we're getting some elite talent we can't really lose.

Think they will trade 2 to Eagles they will take McKercher.

 

[LB2Snake]

It might also be O'Sullivan rather than Caddy.

yeah then def don't do the deal IMO

 

[JimmyRoo]

Can someone fill me in on where the talk that Eagles are more keen on McKercher than Reid is coming from?

 

[Skarrz]

Would love if we could nab pick 1 without trading 2, **** them, give them 3 + 15 + 17 and dont answer the call until draft night

 

[Passmore]

Quality over quantity for me.
We aint going to fix the list in one draft

The odds on us fixing much with picks that will end up about 20, 22 and 23 are not that great. You might get one good long term player.

We'd probably stick with attempting to move up.

Sent from my SM-A908B using Tapatalk

 

[Colby Cheer Squad]

He stopped, then Collingwood fans kicked up a stink and now he gets them again

32 free kicks in 2022 and 5 in 2023. Not as many games this year but it was still a significant turn around.

 

[LB2Snake]

Can someone fill me in on where the talk that Eagles are more keen on McKercher than Reid is coming from?

 

[Heaps of fun]

You've got to be a NASA astronaut to figure out these sort of trades. I think it means he's shit and worth **** all but I can hardly tell these days.

 

[PokerRoo]

Its obvious what they would like for 1. And we would be after the same thing if the situation was reversed. They want to be able to get one of the top picks (Mckercher/sanders/duursma) as well as Curtin.

Melbourne/Hawthorn or anyone else cannot offer them this. Only we could, if we wanted to. If we don't, then the question they need to answer is simple. Are they better off with Reid, or one of the above and whoever is available at 15 (or possibly another of our late picks)

 

[LB2Snake]

Can someone fill me in on where the talk that Eagles are more keen on McKercher than Reid is coming from?

Personally, I'm of the opinion it's who they really want, with some sweeteners. We can just call their bluff too.

 

[Farthers]

You've got to be a NASA astronaut to figure out these sort of trades. I think it means he's s**t and worth * all but I can hardly tell these days.

Pick 21 in draft points but you would expect Hawks to improve and Pies not guaranteed to win the premiership next year.

 

[KickItAnywhere34]

High praise.

Edwards was pretty much crud - so not a lot to beat. Anything is probably an upgrade on him.