List Mgmt. 2023 Trade Thread - Part I

[George]

 

[Mowman]

You’ll cop grief over this but I don’t mind it.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Would rather be putting games into young kids

 

[_Maximus_12]

When did Jack Hayes become the second coming of Christ? Blokes played one good game, coming off 2 very serious injuries and we’re talking about making a spot for him in our best 22.
Until he does enough to take the spot in the 22, I’d be leaving caminitti with king to develop

 

[DougalHoward]

Would rather be putting games into young kids

We also have Mitchito who is a better version of Fyfe

 

[Jade Buddha]

When did Jack Hayes become the second coming of Christ? Blokes played one good game, coming off 2 very serious injuries and we’re talking about making a spot for him in our best 22.
Until he does enough to take the spot in the 22, I’d be leaving caminitti with king to develop

Hayes would be replacing Cordy.

 

[_Maximus_12]

Hayes would be replacing Cordy.

King, Hayes, Caminitti and Membrey don’t fit in the same forward line & we won’t waste a spot on the bench for a tall fwd.

Our game plan is all about running. I’d be very surprised if Hayes makes it back into our 22 this year if Caminitti continues to play the way he does.

 

[gringo2011]

Would rather be putting games into young kids

We really need to see where the season takes us to find the holes. At the moment we look like a gun side but losses will probably tell us more than wins this year.

 

[Dard Ball Get]

We really need to see where the season takes us to find the holes. At the moment we look like a gun side but losses will probably tell us more than wins this year.

Yep. And, not advocating for Fyfe, but it’s not a case of one and not the other with Player X and The Kids

 

[Jade Buddha]

King, Hayes, Caminitti and Membrey don’t fit in the same forward line & we won’t waste a spot on the bench for a tall fwd.

Our game plan is all about running. I’d be very surprised if Hayes makes it back into our 22 this year if Caminitti continues to play the way he does.

Will largely depend on when they each return and who stays fit and in form. Can’t see them all staying up and if they do we are in a very good place.

 

[Mowman]

We really need to see where the season takes us to find the holes. At the moment we look like a gun side but losses will probably tell us more than wins this year.

Don’t care where we finish don’t won’t Fyfe taking a list spot

 

[Mowman]

Yep. And, not advocating for Fyfe, but it’s not a case of one and not the other with Player X and The Kids

I’m talking Fyfe
Don’t think he helps us at all

 

[triggering bro]

I’m talking Fyfe
Don’t think he helps us at all

He looked completely cooked verse us. I reckon he’s body is stuffed

 

[Dard Ball Get]

I’m talking Fyfe
Don’t think he helps us at all

I know mate I just wanted to see your name in my notifications x

 

[Mowman]

He looked completely cooked verse us. I reckon he’s body is stuffed

Hasn’t been able to get on the park consistently for a while now

 

[triggering bro]

Hasn’t been able to get on the park consistently for a while now

Yup may as well bring back Hanners if we are considering Fyfe.

 

[bird_man]

When is plugger66 back?

 

[Mowman]

When is plugger66 back?

He’s not
It was permanent

 

[bird_man]

He’s not
It was permanent

What for??

 

[sammm]

He tends to look a bit awkward with arms and legs flaying everywhere that can draw free kicks against. A bit like Dustin Fletcher he has a look of clumsiness eg the knees to old mate on the ground last week, which I loved. Despite his high disposal efficiency I’m loving the fact he doesn’t take many kick outs which looks to be a deliberate change in tact since RTB has come in.

Corey would have done that.

 

[CaptainRisky]

So I been doing the gardening for 3 days and I've been stewing on this.

I think we should make a play for Nat fyfe.

2 year deal. Where we expect to get 12 months from him.

Next year Steele is 28. Crouch 30. Ross 31. Wood is 31.

Nat fyfe right now looks an ageing shell of himself with recurring injury issues.

But here's the thing. Freo have an appalling injury history especially in treating them. Colin Young has been very vocal of this, where basic things have been missed.

I think we can get his body right and manage him. He gives us another big body mid to go with Steele. Someone who can chop in and out of the fwd line. Perhaps with owens, poo and or wood. Even Gresham.

He's a very good trainer and knows Ross. He'd be another excellent example for the younger guys. He has damage factor fwd of center. Has aerial presence around the ground.

We won't get fyfe in his prime but we will get a very serious footballer who will take the focus off guys like owens.

Also don't get seduced by the broken down fyfe who looks in survival mode who has a big difference of opinion with his senior coach.

He'd cost similar to Sam Mitchell to wce. Or hodge to Brisbane. Aka * all.

Given the mature nature of our midfield and the green shoots we've seen from the kids. I don't think we need a huge signing here we just need to support what we've got and try bring knowledge in. Keep rising the training standards.

We also take a piece off the table at freo who make no mistake will be back to finals next year with another soft draw.

Did you say been doing the gardening or smoking the gardening . you cant be serious

 

[hangdog]

Would rather be putting games into young kids

Thank god you said games

 

[hangdog]

King, Hayes, Caminitti and Membrey don’t fit in the same forward line & we won’t waste a spot on the bench for a tall fwd.

Our game plan is all about running. I’d be very surprised if Hayes makes it back into our 22 this year if Caminitti continues to play the way he does.

That's exactly why he would. Hayes probably is one of the best gut runners on the list. Keeps going even when he's absolutely buggered. I think Lyon would be a fan.

And "One good game"? More accurate to say one extraordinary debut game and 3 good games.

 

[gringo2011]

Hasn’t been able to get on the park consistently for a while now

I heard someone on SEN saying that Freo were mishandling Fyfe and that the coach is paying him no respect by playing him where he makes minimal impact.

To me it's worth waiting until the end of the season and seeing where we finish. If we fall short by 5% or something it might be worth going after a few top ups to bridge the gap. You don't get long up the top to make hay. Doesn't have to be Fyfe but like what the Pies have done.

If we fall a long way short we should keep going for youth development and bringing in and playing kids and hope to peak in 2or 3 years.

 

[Mowman]

I heard someone on SEN saying that Freo were mishandling Fyfe and that the coach is paying him no respect by playing him where he makes minimal impact.

To me it's worth waiting until the end of the season and seeing where we finish. If we fall short by 5% or something it might be worth going after a few top ups to bridge the gap. You don't get long up the top to make hay. Doesn't have to be Fyfe but like what the Pies have done.

If we fall a long way short we should keep going for youth development and bringing in and playing kids and hope to peak in 2or 3 years.

I’m purely talking Fyfe
He is 33 this year and his body stuffed

 

[CaptainRisky]

I heard someone on SEN saying that Freo were mishandling Fyfe and that the coach is paying him no respect by playing him where he makes minimal impact.

To me it's worth waiting until the end of the season and seeing where we finish. If we fall short by 5% or something it might be worth going after a few top ups to bridge the gap. You don't get long up the top to make hay. Doesn't have to be Fyfe but like what the Pies have done.

If we fall a long way short we should keep going for youth development and bringing in and playing kids and hope to peak in 2or 3 years.

Well its confirmed if its on SEN , the bloke is cooked surely you can see that ?

 

[CaptainRisky]

That's exactly why he would. Hayes probably is one of the best gut runners on the list. Keeps going even when he's absolutely buggered. I think Lyon would be a fan.

And "One good game"? More accurate to say one extraordinary debut game and 3 good games.

How about one good game and 3 serviceable,