List Mgmt. 2025 List Management discussion - part 2

[Mat Mann]

just remember that if you quote the trolls, your posts will be deleted as well


He won’t be coming back

 

[austinnn]

I doubt that LOC gets delisted, he's shown enough. Hope not. Hope Carroll stays too.

I'm imagining Webster will probably retire.

 

[Train12]

Don’t leave, sweet prince

Do you have any idea what he will do wolfpac13?

 

[Dr Spaceman]

I doubt that LOC gets delisted, he's shown enough. Hope not.

1. Shown enough
2. Coming from long way back
3. Crucial support for Eamonn Armstrong

LOC stays

 

[Ads734]

who thinks LOC will be delisted, no way. He's shown heaps.

 

[OxSaint]

I'd think to think Nas has kept a small watch on Dan Houston this year. Moving to a new club, new coach, new hierarchy, new system, isn't always as smooth and easy as one might think.

He will also get his halfback role.

 

[austinnn]

who thinks LOC will be delisted, no way. He's shown heaps.

McLennan
Schoenmaker (just not an afl standard athlete)
Boyd
Carroll
O'Connell
Cordy
Jones

Allows us to bring in TDK, Aleer, potentially tex wanganeen, and then 4 draftees. And would probably have to rookie Webster and dougal if they were happy to do that.

It might get pretty savage.
Doogs
Jones
Carroll?
Dow?
Cordy
Boyd
Gus
Marshall?
Steele?
LOC
Jimmy

Add in TDK and Aleer and who from the above will we truly miss next year?

Sorry forgot to attach quotes to last post

 

[Joffaboy]

If North got picks No.2, 3, 40, 43 and a future first round pick for JHF then I’d accept nothing less but 3x top 5 picks for Nas

3 top 5 pick and Whitlock plus our own frdp would be lot of flexibility in the trading/draft period.

Could use a top 5 pick on a star who is after moving, or keep them and cause havoc with bidding on NGA's, would be a monumental shitshow.

 

[BrutThough]

This is what I keep coming back too when Port fans thinking their crappy will be easily accepted.

But consider everything you know about the street-fighting instincts of Ross Lyon, Stephen Silvagni and Graeme Allen then realise how hard they would fight for fair compensation.

Put simply, there is barely a player on the Port Adelaide list that would soften the deal for St Kilda given the unique structure of the Power list.

 

[Saints4ever]

Nas better not be leaving but if he is give me Butters.

Butters is an elite A grade mid who would make a huge immediate impact to our midfield.

 

[Diehard Saint]

I dont think anyone is suggesting wed dump him, the suggestion is we are playing cute with his financial terms on contract.

Might be true, might not, it does seem there is alot of noise about us ****ing about with dollars on currently contracted players while opening the cheque book with players were recruiting.

I get why, i get thats what happens at all clubs but not many other clubs have it become such a point of discussion...

I believe it’s happening at Collingwood right now.

 

[SainterinSydney]

Nas better not be leaving but if he is give me Butters.

Butters is an elite A grade mid who would make a huge immediate impact to our midfield.

Getting Butters would certainly lessen the blow to our hearts and the team performance.

 

[Saints4ever]

Getting Butters would certainly lessen the blow to our hearts and the team performance.

Sadly I don’t think Butters wants to play for the saints.

Wish he did.

1 of my favourite non saints players.

So hard at it. Love how he goes about it.

 

[jwikked]

Getting Butters would certainly lessen the blow to our hearts and the team performance.

Out of all the possibilities, getting him hurts the least. Even if we get 3 top 5 picks from Port, it then takes 3-4 years to develop that talent - provided they actually are capable of being stars.

I don’t want to lose Nas this year, and have a void for 5 years

 

[SainterinSydney]

 

[bergholt]

This TDK thing has turned into such an unexpectedly terrible cluster****.

• His form has fallen off completely this year thanks to being played out of position.
• We have two young rucks on the list who now look promising.
• Our senior ruck is still going great.
• We offered TDK more than we should have and now have another guy who needs even more money.

We were all pretty happy earlier in the year when we were getting him but now it feels like "cut your losses" territory.

 

[Saints4ever]

Guarantee if we get draft picks for Nas they won’t turn out to his level.

We need proven A grade talent

 

[phantom13]

I believe it’s happening at Collingwood right now.

With Darcy Cameron?

 

[jwikked]

This TDK thing has turned into such an unexpectedly terrible cluster****.

• His form has fallen off completely this year thanks to being played out of position.
• We have two young rucks on the list who now look promising.
• Our senior ruck is still going great.
• We offered TDK more than we should have and now have another guy who needs even more money.

We were all pretty happy earlier in the year when we were getting him but now it feels like "cut your losses" territory.

We could pay Nas $4 million per year. It’s not about the money

TDK has nothing to do with Nasiahs choice

 

[MOLTEN GANGLANDS]

This TDK thing has turned into such an unexpectedly terrible cluster****.

• His form has fallen off completely this year thanks to being played out of position.
• We have two young rucks on the list who now look promising.
• Our senior ruck is still going great.
• We offered TDK more than we should have and now have another guy who needs even more money.

We were all pretty happy earlier in the year when we were getting him but now it feels like "cut your losses" territory.

yeah I think our list management department were so keen to land a big fish after getting continually knocked back that they lost the ball a little with TDK. Unless you're max gawn, rucks are never worth top dollar

 

[OxSaint]

Gone:
Cordy
Boyd
Jones
McClennan
Carroll

Maybe gone:
Schoenmaker
Howard

 

[stfan]

who thinks LOC will be delisted, no way. He's shown heaps.

LOC will not be going. Is playing well given his background and being given different roles to develop him.

Plus we have just brought Eamonn to the Club. So having two Irish lads together at the Club will be beneficial, especially in helping Eamonn settle in and get up to speed on playing AFL.

Connor Nash last week took Eamonn out to dinner.

 

[MOLTEN GANGLANDS]

We could pay Nas $4 million per year. It’s not about the money

How would windhager feel about TDK getting 1.7 while he's on like 500k or whatever it is? maybe he's cool with it cos it makes us better, but maybe some players think it's bullshit

 

[BrutThough]

Getting Butters would certainly lessen the blow to our hearts and the team performance.

If I'm SOS, I'm saying Day 1 that it's Butter or they can f off then not answer the phone again until they are willing to seriously discuss someone of that value.

 

[SainterinSydney]

If I'm SOS, I'm saying Day 1 that it's Butter or they can f off then not answer the phone again until they are willing to seriously discuss someone of that value.

RTB, is that you?