List Mgmt. 2025 List Management discussion

[Yawkey way]

Do you really think Dodson would be an appropriate replacement for Butler or Hugo (given he's under a cloud)?

Byrnes and Wilson have the running power we’ll need down at Geelong.

I’m not sure what the hate for Byrnes is about he’s improved every year and given where he was picked has proved value for money. I expect he’ll be at the club next year and will probably end up playing 100 games plus for us, that’s a pretty fair effort imo.

 

[Holy Hunter Clark]

View attachment 2370228

We ain't getting him though

 

[aidansbonor]

View attachment 2370228

Bring him home.

Starting midfield of Tdk, Phillipou, Garcia, Mackenzie in a couple years

 

[MightySaintas]

Byrnes and Wilson have the running power we’ll need down at Geelong.

I’m not sure what the hate for Byrnes is about he’s improved every year and given where he was picked has proved value for money. I expect he’ll be at the club next year and will probably end up playing 100 games plus for us, that’s a pretty fair effort imo.

He's no good

 

[Minga]

Bring him home.

Starting midfield of Tdk, Phillipou, Garcia, Mackenzie in a couple years

His lil bro is coming through our NGA soon too

 

[Jayman15]

 

[billings2paddy]

Do you really think Dodson would be an appropriate replacement for Butler or Hugo (given he's under a cloud)?

Id have in in the team over Heath
Only a matter of time

 

[aidansbonor]

Saints offer to TDK is $1.8mil per season, not $1.7 lol

That should get it done

Getting *****ng ridiculous, 1.3 take it or leave tdk.

Let him decide if playing in front of "big crowds" is worth 300k,

Also it's funny how carlton playing in front of big crowds is meant to be this massive draw card when it's those same people abusing the players down the race after the game

 

[Yawkey way]

He's no good

He’s ok and has improved which is all you can ask, he’s slipping down the order though that’s for sure. I think his running power will be handy on the weekend.

 

[Yawkey way]

We ain't getting him though

I always pay special attention to him when I watch hawthorn games given he was ripped from our grasp. I think he’d have been very handy but honestly he’s not getting the midfield time he wants because he really hasn’t been that good.

 

[SainterinSydney]

Some guy called Arsene Wagner on Port board said he is confident Nas is coming. They are all praising him as a Tony like figure. Have no clue what this guys ITK status is.

 

[puntking]

Some guy called Arsene Wagner on Port board said he is confident Nas is coming. They are all praising him as a Tony like figure. Have no clue what this guys ITK status is.

And what is he coming for? Butters?

 

[Broski]

I just can’t believe a world where we are actually offering $1.8m per season for TDK. Surely they are taking the urine a bit. We will know it time I guess. Hope the club have planned this all out long term.

 

[jumperfan]

And what is he coming for? Butters?

Bergman for Nas + future first according to many Port fans

 

[g_TRAIN]

This chat around Wilson, Garcia and Hastie being potential AA picks is delusional. I pray I'm wrong but what have we seen yet that shows they will get anywhere near that level? There are about five blokes from Wilsons draft class that would already be way ahead of him if you were picking an AA midfield from that draft alone!

Go back to 2016 and see if we weren't saying the exact same things about Billings, Dunstan, Gresham and McCartin. I'll believe we are turning a corner when I see it, but right now we are absolutely nowhere.

They've shown enough to say they will be handy.

Way to early to say more than that. Way to early to predict they make or don't make AA teams

 

[jwikked]

Bergman for Nas + future first according to many Port fans

They’re delusional and have no idea.

 

[g_TRAIN]

I just can’t believe we are actually offering $1.8m per season for TDK. Surely they are taking the urine a bit. We will know it time I guess. Hope the club have planned this all out long term.

Who said we were offering 1.8?

 

[BrutThough]

Id have in in the team over Heath
Only a matter of time

That fair. But in terms of the squad, that would be a straight swap instead of one of Jones/Brynes not being named with the other outs.

 

[BrutThough]

I just can’t believe a world where we are actually offering $1.8m per season for TDK. Surely they are taking the urine a bit. We will know it time I guess. Hope the club have planned this all out long term.

Don't take any number the media throws out seriously.

 

[Holy Hunter Clark]

Bergman for Nas + future first according to many Port fans

Yeah Port Adelaide supporters don't do themselves any favors do they

 

[MOLTEN GANGLANDS]

Getting *****ng ridiculous, 1.3 take it or leave tdk.

Let him decide if playing in front of "big crowds" is worth 300k,

Also it's funny how carlton playing in front of big crowds is meant to be this massive draw card when it's those same people abusing the players down the race after the game

don't kink shame, he wants to be humiliated in front of the most amount of people possible at one time, at saints we can guarantee the humiliation a la carlton but can't match the numbers

 

[gringo2011]

Yep... lost 0/1 in 2023, 5/10 in 2024 and 13/33 in 2025 = 18/44 or 41%. for players 196cm+ with 40+ def 1v1 contests it is the highest on record. It's all there in the AFL app or Wheelo or wherever if anyone wants to go through every other player and add them all up


you have the filter on last 5 games only, so much variance. I am talking about over the course of a career. I don't think Jimmy would have lasted 14 years in the system with a 100% 1v1 loss rate

Yeah, true.

His career as a back is less that a season as a 21 year old. Not sure he's the finished article.

 

[Veer Right]

Don't care if Wanganeen-Milera, our best player, leaves but need 1 gamer Max Heath to be signed or you'll storm Moorabbin?

You are mistaken with this take.

Yea that's right i don't care when he leaves.

Club has bent over backwards for him and he still hasn't signed.

I'd rather focus my support on loyal players like Marshall for example who bends over backwards for the jumper and club.

 

[gringo2011]

Imagine being so pathetically boring

Okay Ned Flanders. Gothic drama is always more entertaining than your cheery saccharine soap opera. I might sleep in a coffin but I imagine you jumping out of bed like a Wham era George Michael, full of pastel coloured enthusiasm and good cheer and want to spew. I still love you though you cheeky little monkey.

 

[MOLTEN GANGLANDS]

Yea that's right i don't care when he leaves.

Club has bent over backwards for him and he still hasn't signed.

I'd rather focus my support on loyal players like Marshall for example who bends over backwards for the jumper and club.

true, we should try marshall off the HBF