Remove this Banner Ad

2025 Rolling ALL-Australian Team

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Still think Thilthorpe ahead of Ben King on total output

1. Thilthorpe, 2. Treacey, 3. King

Hogan hasn't played enough games. Georgiades, Walker and Cameron next
PlayerTotal1AvgM.50S.INVC MArkGoal
Ben King
251.50​
41.92​
22​
39​
8​
23​
Josh Treacy
319.50​
45.64​
24​
51​
9​
20​
Riley Thilthorpe
343.00​
49.00​
21​
46​
10​
19​
Nick Larkey
253.50​
36.21​
17​
42​
7​
18​
Mitch Georgiades
297.50​
42.50​
27​
49​
13​
17​
Jeremy Cameron
333.00​
47.57​
17​
51​
9​
17​
Jesse Hogan
207.50​
51.88​
17​
28​
10​
17​
Darcy Fogarty
226.50​
37.75​
16​
35​
5​
16​
Eric Hipwood
267.00​
38.14​
16​
39​
4​
16​
Taylor Walker
313.50​
44.79​
12​
50​
9​
16​
 
Guthrie - Taylor - Sinclair
Whitfield - Andrews - NWM
Mcgluggage - Liberatore - Sidebottom
Rankine - Treacy - Dangerfield
Higgins - King - Keays
Gawn - Daicos - Brayshaw

TDK - Hewett - Neale - Rowell

Someone’s gonna have to make room for Butters and Bontempelli soon.
 
My AA Squad of 44 after Anzac round:

ADE: Izak Rankine - Riley Thilthorpe - J. Dawson

BRI: Dayne Zorko - Lachie Neale - Will Ashcroft - Zac Bailey

CAR: Jacob Weitering - George Hewett

COL: Steele Sidebottom - Nick Daicos - Josh Daicos - Darcy Cameron

ESS: Zach Merrett

FRE: Andrew Brayshaw - Caleb Serong - Josh Treacy

GEL: Bailey Smith - Max Holmes - Jeremy Cameron - Shaun Mannagh

GCS: Ben King - John Noble - Daniel Rioli - Jarrod Witts - Ben Long

GWS: Lachie Whitfield - Toby Greene - Lachie Ash - Finn Callaghan

HAW: Jai Newcombe - Jack Gunston

MEL: Max Gawn

NOR: Tristan Xerri - Paul Curtis

POR: Connor Rozee - Zak Butters - Jason Horne-Francis - Mitch Georgiades

RIC: N/A

STK: Jack Sinclair - Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera - Jack Higgins

SYD: N/A

WCE: N/A

WBD: Matthew Kennedy - Marcus Bontempelli
 
Progressive Aggresion said:
My AA Squad of 44 after Anzac round:

ADE: Izak Rankine - Riley Thilthorpe - J. Dawson

BRI: Dayne Zorko - Lachie Neale - Will Ashcroft - Zac Bailey

CAR: Jacob Weitering - George Hewett

COL: Steele Sidebottom - Nick Daicos - Josh Daicos - Darcy Cameron

ESS: Zach Merrett

FRE: Andrew Brayshaw - Caleb Serong - Josh Treacy

GEL: Bailey Smith - Max Holmes - Jeremy Cameron - Shaun Mannagh

GCS: Ben King - John Noble - Daniel Rioli - Jarrod Witts - Ben Long

GWS: Lachie Whitfield - Toby Greene - Lachie Ash - Finn Callaghan

HAW: Jai Newcombe - Jack Gunston

MEL: Max Gawn

NOR: Tristan Xerri - Paul Curtis

POR: Connor Rozee - Zak Butters - Jason Horne-Francis - Mitch Georgiades

RIC: N/A

STK: Jack Sinclair - Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera - Jack Higgins

SYD: N/A

WCE: N/A

WBD: Matthew Kennedy - Marcus Bontempelli
Click to expand...
Holmes has had too many poor games.

Cameron's numbers look good, but the amount of times he stuffs up plays is unbelievable. Mannagh probably needs a couple more games, since he started late.

It'd likely be Smith and Dangerfield in a rolling 44 as far as Cats players.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Progressive Aggresion said:
My AA Squad of 44 after Anzac round:

ADE: Izak Rankine - Riley Thilthorpe - J. Dawson

BRI: Dayne Zorko - Lachie Neale - Will Ashcroft - Zac Bailey

CAR: Jacob Weitering - George Hewett

COL: Steele Sidebottom - Nick Daicos - Josh Daicos - Darcy Cameron

ESS: Zach Merrett

FRE: Andrew Brayshaw - Caleb Serong - Josh Treacy

GEL: Bailey Smith - Max Holmes - Jeremy Cameron - Shaun Mannagh

GCS: Ben King - John Noble - Daniel Rioli - Jarrod Witts - Ben Long

GWS: Lachie Whitfield - Toby Greene - Lachie Ash - Finn Callaghan

HAW: Jai Newcombe - Jack Gunston

MEL: Max Gawn

NOR: Tristan Xerri - Paul Curtis

POR: Connor Rozee - Zak Butters - Jason Horne-Francis - Mitch Georgiades

RIC: N/A

STK: Jack Sinclair - Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera - Jack Higgins

SYD: N/A

WCE: N/A

WBD: Matthew Kennedy - Marcus Bontempelli
Click to expand...
De Koning not in the squad is... Interesting... 21 coaches votes from the ruck and every chance to get another handful tomorrow.
 
WalshistheGOAT said:
De Koning not in the squad is... Interesting... 21 coaches votes from the ruck and every chance to get another handful tomorrow.
Click to expand...
Tough year for rucks - he needs a scalp if he wants to get in, instead of flat tracking C Grade ruckman whilst getting beaten by the AA contenders.
 
Mr Meow said:
Holmes has had too many poor games.

Cameron's numbers look good, but the amount of times he stuffs up plays is unbelievable. Mannagh probably needs a couple more games, since he started late.

It'd likely be Smith and Dangerfield in a rolling 44 as far as Cats players.
Click to expand...

Guthrie would be in the squad. Holmes isn’t. Agreed there.
 
Progressive Aggresion said:
My AA Squad of 44 after Anzac round:

ADE: Izak Rankine - Riley Thilthorpe - J. Dawson

BRI: Dayne Zorko - Lachie Neale - Will Ashcroft - Zac Bailey

CAR: Jacob Weitering - George Hewett

COL: Steele Sidebottom - Nick Daicos - Josh Daicos - Darcy Cameron

ESS: Zach Merrett

FRE: Andrew Brayshaw - Caleb Serong - Josh Treacy

GEL: Bailey Smith - Max Holmes - Jeremy Cameron - Shaun Mannagh

GCS: Ben King - John Noble - Daniel Rioli - Jarrod Witts - Ben Long

GWS: Lachie Whitfield - Toby Greene - Lachie Ash - Finn Callaghan

HAW: Jai Newcombe - Jack Gunston

MEL: Max Gawn

NOR: Tristan Xerri - Paul Curtis

POR: Connor Rozee - Zak Butters - Jason Horne-Francis - Mitch Georgiades

RIC: N/A

STK: Jack Sinclair - Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera - Jack Higgins

SYD: N/A

WCE: N/A

WBD: Matthew Kennedy - Marcus Bontempelli
Click to expand...

Agreed with the Pies in the squad, though Jamie Elliott is closing fast and in consideration for the squad.
 
Progressive Aggresion said:
My AA Squad of 44 after Anzac round:

ADE: Izak Rankine - Riley Thilthorpe - J. Dawson

BRI: Dayne Zorko - Lachie Neale - Will Ashcroft - Zac Bailey

CAR: Jacob Weitering - George Hewett

COL: Steele Sidebottom - Nick Daicos - Josh Daicos - Darcy Cameron

ESS: Zach Merrett

FRE: Andrew Brayshaw - Caleb Serong - Josh Treacy

GEL: Bailey Smith - Max Holmes - Jeremy Cameron - Shaun Mannagh

GCS: Ben King - John Noble - Daniel Rioli - Jarrod Witts - Ben Long

GWS: Lachie Whitfield - Toby Greene - Lachie Ash - Finn Callaghan

HAW: Jai Newcombe - Jack Gunston

MEL: Max Gawn

NOR: Tristan Xerri - Paul Curtis

POR: Connor Rozee - Zak Butters - Jason Horne-Francis - Mitch Georgiades

RIC: N/A

STK: Jack Sinclair - Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera - Jack Higgins

SYD: N/A

WCE: N/A

WBD: Matthew Kennedy - Marcus Bontempelli
Click to expand...
I'd be gobsmacked if there was only one KPD in the squad at this point. And only 8 out of 44 defenders.
 
My team at this point:

FB: Nick Vlaustin - Jacob Weitering - Callum Wilkie
HB: Bailey Dale - Sam Taylor - Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera
MF: Hugh McCluggage - Nick Daicos - Jordan Dawson
HF: Toby Greene - Riley Thilthorpe - Jack Higgins
FF: Paul Curtis - Ben King - Josh Treacy
OB: Tristan Xerri - Connor Rozee - Bailey Smith
IC: Noah Anderson - Matt Rowell - Steele Sidebottom - Caleb Serong
 
Progressive Aggresion said:
My AA Squad of 44 after Anzac round:

ADE: Izak Rankine - Riley Thilthorpe - J. Dawson

BRI: Dayne Zorko - Lachie Neale - Will Ashcroft - Zac Bailey

CAR: Jacob Weitering - George Hewett

COL: Steele Sidebottom - Nick Daicos - Josh Daicos - Darcy Cameron

ESS: Zach Merrett

FRE: Andrew Brayshaw - Caleb Serong - Josh Treacy

GEL: Bailey Smith - Max Holmes - Jeremy Cameron - Shaun Mannagh

GCS: Ben King - John Noble - Daniel Rioli - Jarrod Witts - Ben Long

GWS: Lachie Whitfield - Toby Greene - Lachie Ash - Finn Callaghan

HAW: Jai Newcombe - Jack Gunston

MEL: Max Gawn

NOR: Tristan Xerri - Paul Curtis

POR: Connor Rozee - Zak Butters - Jason Horne-Francis - Mitch Georgiades

RIC: N/A

STK: Jack Sinclair - Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera - Jack Higgins

SYD: N/A

WCE: N/A

WBD: Matthew Kennedy - Marcus Bontempelli
Click to expand...
For Brisbane McCluggage over Ashcroft. Actually probably Andrews over him too. Ashcroft has had a couple of down games and would be our 3rd or 4th mid in terms of performance this year
 
Michalanney Weitering Humphries
Rozee Andrews NWM
Sidebottom Rowell Dawson
B Long Thilthorpe Bolton
Higgins King Curtis

Cameron Daicos Serong

Merrett Richards Treacy Newcombe

Em: Brayshaw Greene Danger Gawn
 
eth-dog said:
My team at this point:

FB: Nick Vlaustin - Jacob Weitering - Callum Wilkie
HB: Bailey Dale - Sam Taylor - Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera
MF: Hugh McCluggage - Nick Daicos - Jordan Dawson
HF: Toby Greene - Riley Thilthorpe - Jack Higgins
FF: Paul Curtis - Ben King - Josh Treacy
OB: Tristan Xerri - Connor Rozee - Bailey Smith
IC: Noah Anderson - Matt Rowell - Steele Sidebottom - Caleb Serong
Click to expand...
FB: Zorko, Weitering, Vlastuin
HB: Rozee, Taylor, Wanganeen-Milera
C: Smith, Daicos, Brayshaw
HF: Greene, Treacy, Richards
FF: Curtis, Thilthorpe, Higgins
R: Cameron, Rowell, Butters
IC: Sidebottom, Hewett, Liberatore, Amon

Richards is likely a placeholder for Bontempelli. Rankine and Dawson are other contenders for that spot. Butters line ball based on games played, but just barely qualifies for rolling team status now IMO. King and Anderson could be considered unlucky, but Gold Coast have mostly played witches hats so far. McCluggage has dropped off a bit. Josh Daicos and Amon are difficult to split. Newcombe, Serong and Merrett thereabouts. JHF probably one good game away despite having a couple of absolute stinkers.
 
Last edited:

Remove this Banner Ad

Dawson shouldn't be in consideration. His form since round 2 vs Essendon has deteriorated rapidly and has become a turnover merchant.

McCluggage, Sidebottom, N. Daicos, Brayshaw, Serong, Holmes, Hewett, Newcombe Merrett, Smith, Anderson, Rowell and Butters should all be ahead of him as mids.
 
Mr Meow said:
FB: Zorko, Weitering, Vlastuin
HB: Rozee, Taylor, Wanganeen-Milera
C: Smith, Daicos, Brayshaw
HF: Greene, Treacy, Richards
FF: Curtis, Thilthorpe, Higgins
R: Cameron, Rowell, Butters
IC: Sidebottom, Hewett, Liberatore, Amon

Richards is likely a placeholder for Bontempelli. Rankine and Dawson are other contenders for that spot. Butters line ball based on games played, but just barely qualifies for rolling team status now IMO. King and Anderson could be considered unlucky, but Gold Coast have mostly played witches hats so far. McCluggage has dropped off a bit. Josh Daicos and Amon are difficult to split. Newcombe, Serong and Merrett thereabouts. JHF probably one good game away despite having a couple of absolute stinkers.
Click to expand...
It’s quite hard giving some of the top sides enough credit because they have had such an even contribution. I found it hard to fit in enough of the dogs, hawks and pies I sort of had to force it a bit as they deserve to have at least a couple.
 
Lingsface said:
It’s quite hard giving some of the top sides enough credit because they have had such an even contribution. I found it hard to fit in enough of the dogs, hawks and pies I sort of had to force it a bit as they deserve to have at least a couple.
Click to expand...
Correct. The 7th-13th type teams at the moment are being carried by a few stars, relative to the top 4 sides. My side rewarded a few 50/50 options based on standing up against quality opposition.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

It's interesting that Hawthorn are top 4 (a win clear of 5th) and I don't think anyone would be in contention for a rolling AA 22 at this point.

Very even contribution and having a better bottom 6-10 than most rather than star players being the main reason.

I've long argued that as recognition of individual performance, AA teams should pay little to no attention to ladder position (including when Hawthorn were poor) and it would be hypocritical for me to suggest otherwise now that we are we are going well. None of this "team A is top 2/4/8, so deserve X spots in the AA team" - just pick who the best individual players have been for their position, rather than penalising them for having inferior team mates.
 
Yeah this year has been more of an even contribution, more of the bottom half of our 22 are in really good form guys like Gunston, Morrison while our top end guys whilst still contributing are mostly out of form or not playing at the AA level currently.

Gunston strangely enough would be our closest, he has also left alot of goals on the table if he had converted would generally be in the discussion but I don't expect this form to last the season, would love it if it did though. Amon is another who's first few weeks were elite but been a bit quieter over the last few and is about to miss some games with concussion.

Day obviously was the one that looked like he was shaping to potentially be in this discussion as the year progresses. Newcombe though has lifted over the past few weeks and if this form continues is our best shot at making the squad imo.
 
Progressive Aggresion said:
My AA Squad of 44 after Anzac round:

ADE: Izak Rankine - Riley Thilthorpe - J. Dawson

BRI: Dayne Zorko - Lachie Neale - Will Ashcroft - Zac Bailey

CAR: Jacob Weitering - George Hewett

COL: Steele Sidebottom - Nick Daicos - Josh Daicos - Darcy Cameron

ESS: Zach Merrett

FRE: Andrew Brayshaw - Caleb Serong - Josh Treacy

GEL: Bailey Smith - Max Holmes - Jeremy Cameron - Shaun Mannagh

GCS: Ben King - John Noble - Daniel Rioli - Jarrod Witts - Ben Long

GWS: Lachie Whitfield - Toby Greene - Lachie Ash - Finn Callaghan

HAW: Jai Newcombe - Jack Gunston

MEL: Max Gawn

NOR: Tristan Xerri - Paul Curtis

POR: Connor Rozee - Zak Butters - Jason Horne-Francis - Mitch Georgiades

RIC: N/A

STK: Jack Sinclair - Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera - Jack Higgins

SYD: N/A

WCE: N/A

WBD: Matthew Kennedy - Marcus Bontempelli
Click to expand...
No Liberatore is a massive miss.
 
TubbsFarquhar said:
Dawson shouldn't be in consideration. His form since round 2 vs Essendon has deteriorated rapidly and has become a turnover merchant.

McCluggage, Sidebottom, N. Daicos, Brayshaw, Serong, Holmes, Hewett, Newcombe Merrett, Smith, Anderson, Rowell and Butters should all be ahead of him as mids.
Click to expand...
It’s amazing how someone who looks like such a beautiful kick turns it over a shitload this year.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

2025 Rolling ALL-Australian Team

Similar threads

B
Rolling 2025 All Australian Team
Replies
5
Views
1K
JHF1870
JHF1870
PerthBoy86
All Australian Team vs Premiers Exhibition Game
Replies
14
Views
422
Mr Meow
M
T
ROLLING 2025 CONTENDERS
Replies
6
Views
591
twhowler
T
BigVic
Toast Can Geelong's 2025 team be the GOAT (Greatest Team of All Time)
2 3
Replies
63
Views
3K
PetterdHoisted
P
Fadge
The Greatest VFL/AFL Team Of All Time
Replies
16
Views
686
Percel
Percel
Jascave
Opinion Select an All Australian team of the past 50 years
2 3 4 5
Replies
108
Views
5K
Seeds
Seeds
GC2015
  • Poll
Prediction Which team finishes 9th in 2025?
2
Replies
47
Views
2K
Freomaniac
Freomaniac

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top