List Mgmt. 2025 Trade/FA Thread

[Dtennent94]

Guess it’s time to hit the self-destruct button.

Let Maynard walk. Sell De Goey and Moore for 2nd rounders. Hope we can rebuild to contend in the twilight of Nick’s career.

 

[Exambolor]

That's Rowell, LDU & Richards out as all look set to stay. Allen looks Hawks-bound.

I'm afraid the best we can do is Dev Robertson or try to poach Mitch Lewis and James Worpel.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Hawks have a midfield logjam, Ward is one I’d get in, very good player when he gets his opportunities but just simply doesn’t get enough games due to Day, Duke and the Worp being there

 

[danielnajdek]

I must be the only one on here who doesn’t want Butters. He vanishes in big games.

 

[Exambolor]

In more important news Cal said on Gettable, McGuane is projected currently as a late first rounder 20-25

Might not have to use a future first maybe?

 

[manicpie]

I must be the only one on here who doesn’t want Butters. He vanishes in big games.

I'm not fussed either way.

 

[cfc19902010]

McCartin over Tomlinson is a no brainer. Much younger.

Definitely and Tomlinson a donkey

 

[gouki88]

Bailey Humphrey come on down

 

[No SPIN]

So it's a big NO to Butters but a big yes to Fin Mccrae. You might have the two confused

Very simplistic argument - you are forgetting the cost to our salary Cap for each player.

 

[Kappa]

In more important news Cal said on Gettable, McGuane is projected currently as a late first rounder 20-25

Might not have to use a future first maybe?

who knows with the bidding process.

There have been some very dodgy bids or "non-bids" in previous drafts

 

[gouki88]

Very simplistic argument - you are forgetting the cost to our salary Cap for each player.

I think feasibility is more important than salary, because Butters is 100x the player Macrae is

 

[Horaceg]

I must be the only one on here who doesn’t want Butters. He vanishes in big games.

I don’t think you’re the only one, I like the way he goes about it but I don’t see as much value as others.

 

[sr36]

Very simplistic argument - you are forgetting the cost to our salary Cap for each player.

It's all relative to contribution to the senior team. What's the minimum for a 5th year player? Suspect it's a fair bit more than Macrae is worth, as his contribution is more like that of a first year draftee on first year wages.

 

[sr36]

I don’t think you’re the only one, I like the way he goes about it but I don’t see as much value as others.

I'd love him. Contest winner and dasher, who gets it from inside to outside really often. He and Nick together would be electric.

 

[SchuPie]

Bailey Humphrey come on down

I think when we tried to poach him at the end of last year was the time
I think his value is starting to soar

 

[sr36]

Dumb campaigner

The big names will re-sign where they're at.

It's the smaller fry who can get a jump into good money who are more likely to leave.

I'd be looking at Melican for us.

 

[JLC]

That's Rowell, LDU & Richards out as all look set to stay. Allen looks Hawks-bound.

I'm afraid the best we can do is Dev Robertson or try to poach Mitch Lewis and James Worpel.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

I have been a fan of Mitch Lewis in the past but recruiting him would almost do the Hawks a favour.

It's amazing how the Cats and Hawks can recruit players and no other club really bat and eyelid of compete.

Where the heck are the Kangaroos and Saints trying to inflate the contract?

 

[Go Woods]

In more important news Cal said on Gettable, McGuane is projected currently as a late first rounder 20-25

Might not have to use a future first maybe?

Quite a gap compared to Ralph predicting pick 6 or 7, barracking hard just another hater hoping we have to pony up heaps of points...

 

[manicpie]

The big names will re-sign where they're at.

It's the smaller fry who can get a jump into good money who are more likely to leave.

I'd be looking at Melican for us.

I don't mind Melican, very good defender and they make great corrugated iron sheets

 

[sr36]

I don't mind Melican, very good defender and they make great corrugated iron sheets

He's a good defender. Injured too much is the only issue.

 

[Pistol Night]

I don't mind Melican, very good defender and they make great corrugated iron sheets

Also handy if we ever need a player whose name rhymes with a large bird

 

[Jen2310]

In more important news Cal said on Gettable, McGuane is projected currently as a late first rounder 20-25

Might not have to use a future first maybe?

Maybe not - time will tell. But he’s the only one we could use it on. Can’t trade it otherwise. Unless it’s for a player that’s been in the system for 2-3 years. So like a Humphrey., but can’t see him moving.

 

[Apex36]

Gettable reporting Ed Richards wants to stay at the dogs and is looking to sign 5-6 year deal.

This is why nobody likes redheads.

 

[manicpie]

I have been a fan of Mitch Lewis in the past but recruiting him would almost do the Hawks a favour.

It's amazing how the Cats and Hawks can recruit players and no other club really bat and eyelid of compete.

Where the heck are the Kangaroos and Saints trying to inflate the contract?

Both Hawthorn and Geelong wouldn't have too many players on really big contracts unfortunately. Of course they each have a few but not the depth of most other established clubs. It's a no for Lewis, he'd just captain our rehab group

 

[Apex36]

IMO as much as I would love him at the club, I don't blame him for staying, Treloar and Libba will retire during that time and he'll become Bont's second in command and be locked in a role, and he could be the No 1 by the end of that contract anyway with Bont being 34-35 by the end of that deal and Ed hitting his prime

Yeah but he could be winning flags and continuing his families legacy at the pies.

 

[Pistol Night]

This is why nobody likes redheads.

Hes gone from "Lou's awesome great nephew" to "Stupid, fanta pants ranga" in my book now