Past #3: Jed Anderson - delisted end '22 - 89 NMFC games - go well Jed

[Wells Now Williams Fan]

Personally I think Anderson has improved as the year has gone on.

Don't be too harsh on him guys as you tear your hammy & then try and come from that far behind fitness wise.

Needs to do a massive summer in the gym and work on core strength but I am more than happy to have him at the club.

Full proper preseason & he will improve dramatically.

 

[Mr Reliable]

Let's hope they can all find the upside together and grow together.

A Kleenex moment. Thanks Blackshadow.

 

[LuvtheKangas]

Ha. Rubbish.

Anderson cost us 15.

Bastinac cost lions 2 second rounders (helped from Anderson picks in our favour) and himself.

That's why we got 17 back.

The end.

You don't actually know what the trade was, do you?

Even if you don't want to acknowledge related trades, the deal wasn't straight 15 for Anderson. So, you're wrong on the specific facts level at least.

Plus the trades were related, whether you choose to believe that or not. But again, even if you choose not to believe it, what you keep asserting is factually incorrect.

Why did you edit out the bit about you being so good at interpreting basic facts due to your line of work, I wonder?

 

[kangaspurs]

It was Jed, 38 and 40 for 15 and 55.

So the fact is that Jed alone did not cost us 15. It's just not true.

If you want to say that Jed cost us 15 then you also have to say that pick 55 cost hawthorn picks 38 and 40 which is just complete ****ing nonsense.

 

[LuvtheKangas]

It was Jed, 38 and 40 for 15 and 55.

So the fact is that Jed alone did not cost us 15. It's just not true.

If you want to say that Jed cost us 15 then you also have to say that pick 55 cost hawthorn picks 38 and 40 which is just complete ******* nonsense.

Basic fact ...

 

[Only Forwards]

F*** there is some meaningless splitting of hairs in this thread.

Kids under done. Had ??? On his body prior to this year and we've played him of f*** all preparation and no VFL form.

Like many needs this year to just end, get clear air and go again.

If you are inclined to judge him I'd suggest do so after next year.

 

[Viper2Jester]

Basic fact ...

We still have pick 15?

Basic fact we don't

 

[Mcarcherey]

We still have pick 15?

Basic fact we don't

Basic fact, we got a very early 2nd round pick instead of 15. Alswell as the fact he was a first round pick anyway so there's no difference.

 

[shniko11]

Are we still ahh never mind..

At the end of the day 15/17 same difference.

 

[tiltraise]

Because it's total bullshit that's why KC.

I've tried to understand every (stupid) analogy presented to me and I still find we have pick 17 - not pick 15? What am I missing that we still have pick 15 somehow? Apparently though we still have pick 15 as Anderson but didn't "cost" us that? WTF? But yep bring on the beer analogies which are irrelevant....

Until someone shows me that we do still have pick 15 I will refuse to accept Anderson didn't cost us number 15 regardless of "use or cost", or any other Politician type spin about what we received in return didn't mean the original event didn't happen.....all because of later events we've managed to use picks from Anderson trade we made ground back by giving up a (quality) player in Bastinac and swapped picks to get a different first round pick in 17.

To say Anderson didn't "cost" us pick 15 is just a plain lie, regardless of what else we received in later deals.

Lots of posters here must use Ashley Madison

IIRC Jed cost us equiv pick 41 which imo is the value the trade should be assessed at regardless of the individual picks involved.

 

[LuvtheKangas]

We still have pick 15?

Basic fact we don't

Not what I argued against, as you well know.

Do we have any draft picks at all? No, the draft finished. Duh

 

[Gasometer]

<insert Homer bushes gif >

 

[kangaspurs]

We still have pick 15?

Basic fact we don't

So you must accept then that Hawthorn traded 38 and 40 to get pick 55 as you seem to think that the different parts of that trade have to be looked at in isolation.

In that case, for Hawthorn's sake, I hope whoever sanctioned that trade is out of his job.

 

[Zondor]

I have read a lot of shit that Anderson is underdone. He looks as ordinary now as he did preseason. Anyways how many weeks will it take for him to look at least half reasonable? He would want to pull his finger out. Give us something Jed! :stern look

 

[Only Forwards]

I have read a lot of shit that Anderson is underdone. He looks as ordinary now as he did preseason. Anyways how many weeks will it take for him to look at least half reasonable? He would want to pull his finger out. Give us something Jed! :stern look

I think with him like with many we've made things overly complicated.

He is Jacobs mrkii, hopefully we simplify it quicker.

 

[Gasometer]

I will say it again.

Needs to kick goals fast.

 

[The Other Dean]

Good to see the 'What did Anderson cost us?' debate still raging.

Maybe we need to settle this with a poll.

A big, metal one that we could use to beat anyone who still thinks he cost us pick 15.

 

[tazaa]

Well Pick 15 ended up being Daniel Rioli. Reckon Jed has a higher ceiling due to his toughness. FYI he's strung together nearly 10 games together for the first time in his career. He'll come good.

 

[Only Forwards]

Well Pick 15 ended up being Daniel Rioli. Reckon Jed has a higher ceiling due to his toughness. FYI he's strung together nearly 10 games together for the first time in his career. He'll come good.

No pick 12 slid due to the Academy bullshit and became pick 15.

Pick 15 slid and became pick 19 and was Ryan Burton.

Had we kept 15 we'd never have had access to Rioli.

There are some major disconnects over how last year's draft worked with the Academy picks and the points system. What's more is people are splitting hairs over f*** all.

Sure we let 15 (which became 19) go to Hawthorn, we did however get in 17 (21) which was due in part to the other picks we collected from Hawthorn.

My question is what the f*** does any of that matter?

 

[roos_fanatic08]

No pick 12 slid due to the Academy bullshit and became pick 15.

Pick 15 slid and became pick 19 and was Ryan Burton.

Had we kept 15 we'd never have had access to Rioli.

There are some major disconnects over how last year's draft worked with the Academy picks and the points system. What's more is people are splitting hairs over f*** all.

Sure we let 15 (which became 19) go to Hawthorn, we did however get in 17 (21) which was due in part to the other picks we collected from Hawthorn.

My question is what the f*** does any of that matter?

If we had of had pick 15 we still would have taken McKay. So it's a moot
Point.

 

[LuvtheKangas]

But, but ... basic facts.

 

[Gasometer]

Good to see the 'What did Anderson cost us?' debate still raging.

Maybe we need to settle this with a poll.

A big, metal one that we could use to beat anyone who still thinks he cost us pick 15.

I lold.

 

[GarnerSmash]

Gonna start calling this bloke abacus.

 

[Gasometer]

Gonna start calling this bloke abacus.

Preferable to 'ffs' which is wat he gets from me.

 

[scooby1279]

when he plays good in the final next week you will all say he was worth the pick 15 (for those that think that)...