Ablett vs Black vs Bartel Vs Judd

[Roos34]

whos the best in that order as these are the best mids in the comp imo. on any given day they are the best in but if i was to choose in order i would go

Black
Ablett
Judd
Bartel

 

[bluesforever]

Judd
Ablett
Black
Bartel

This is assuming all are at their best.

 

[Quinz]

At their best

Judd
Ablett
Bartel
Black

 

[Big Nasty]

At thier best:

Ablett
Judd
Bartel
Black

 

[CENTERMAN]

At their best

Ablett
Black
Judd
Bartel

ATM

Ablett
Black
Bartel
Judd

 

[parrot]

1. Judd
2. 14 Light years
3. Ablett
4. Black
5. 6 light years
6. Bartel

 

[Lynch takes a mark]

Judd
Black
Ablett
Bartel

 

[boncer34]

Isn't the point of a poll board to have threads with polls?

 

[cats2rise]

I'd love to see if GAJ can improve in the midfield.... I think he has the capacity to pass Judd.

But atm
Judd
Ablett
Black
Bartel

Judd and Ablett close together, and then Black and Bartel close together. Could easily swap Bartel around with Black, but that might be my bias showing

 

[jonoman89]

Judd
Ablett
Black
Bartel

 

[Big Nasty]

I'd love to see if GAJ can improve in the midfield.... I think he has the capacity to pass Judd.

But atm
Judd
Ablett
Black
Bartel

Judd and Ablett close together, and then Black and Bartel close together. Could easily swap Bartel around with Black, but that might be my bias showing

HAHAHAHA your saying Judd's had a better '07-'08 than Ablett. C'mon mate, you do watch your team play don't you?

 

[parrot]

HAHAHAHA your saying Judd's had a better '07-'08 than Ablett. C'mon mate, you do watch your team play don't you?

You seem to be so insecure about the quality of your list. Have you ever asked yourself why?

 

[hellfire]

You seem to be so insecure about the quality of your list. Have you ever asked yourself why?

...If a Geelong fan is insecure about their list, what in ****'s name are you?

At their best:
1. Judd
2. Ablett
3. Black
4. Bartel

Right now - Ablett > Judd.

 

[CrazyQ]

Judd of course.

Then Ablett.

Then Black.

Bartel.

 

[Big Tezza]

I can't believe how quickly everyone's forgotten about Daniel Kerr. A couple of quiet games and a suspension and BANG, he's off the radar completely.

Back on topic, from the four players listed, my order is:
1. Ablett
2. Judd
3. Black
4. Bartel

 

[bigburger]

At their best

Judd
Ablett
Bartel
Black

I think your spot on Quinzy. Black is bottom as he has the lowest quality of disposal. Bartel though very very very good is below Judd and Ablett as he just doesn't have the mind/game blowing X factor the other two have.

 

[Lynch takes a mark]

I think your spot on Quinzy. Black is bottom as he has the lowest quality of disposal. Bartel though very very very good is below Judd and Ablett as he just doesn't have the mind/game blowing X factor the other two have.

Black lowest quality disposal

 

[Quinz]

I wouldn't go that far BB, Black is a superb handballer, as good as Kerr and West in dishing it out from the pack, I just think that Judd and Ablett are a class above the rest, with Judd at his best still clearly in front of Ablett.

Bartel and Black are close though, could switch them maybe.

 

[El_Scorcho]

At their best:

Judd
Ablett
Black
Bartel

But 4 amazing players.

 

[Mike_blues]

fully fit

1. Judd
2. Ablett
3. Black
4. Bartel
atm
1.ablett
2.black
3. judd
4.bartel

 

[cat_fanatic]

Bartel is a fair way from his brownlow winning form of last year. Black has been super so far this year and it wouldn't surprise me if he is leading the Brownlow at this point of time. Ablett is doing better than last year and Judd is way down on his usual form atm.

ATM

Black
Ablett
Bartel
Judd

Fully Fit

Ablett
Judd
Black
Bartel