Australian ODI Squad - 2014/15

[bird_man]

I honestly think Watson would do a better job in the middle order than Bailey, but I understand I have a lack of evidence/recent form to support that theory.

But Bailey will lose his spot to Clarke you would think? So the question really is which two do you pick out if Watson, Marsh and Faulkner?

 

[Carbine Chaos]

But Bailey will lose his spot to Clarke you would think? So the question really is which two do you pick out if Watson, Marsh and Faulkner?

Yeah if Clarke comes back it is for Bailey and I would definitely be playing Marsh/Faulkner ahead of Watson.

Still think the question marks hanging over Clarke are astronomical though.

 

[bird_man]

Compared to what goes Watson's way it seems tiny in comparison, and that is saying something.

I don't recall a cricketer who cops more from the home fans than Watson has.

Really? I beg to differ, the hate for the "no show" actually turned me right off big footy.

 

[Carbine Chaos]

Really? I beg to differ, the hate for the "no show" actually turned me right off big footy.

The hate for Watson is strong, my friend. Has been for years, even when he was contributing well.

 

[bird_man]

Let's just hope Watson finds some confidence, it wasn't that long ago he was the best one day cricketer in the world.

 

[Art Vandelay_]

Maybe you don't remember the vitriol thrown Maxwells way most of the summer?

Peaking after the UAE and SA ODI series

 

[Kram]

Watson is on a hiding to nothing for the next game, if he makes runs they 'wont count' and if he doesn't...

 

[Underdog]

Watson is on a hiding to nothing for the next game, if he makes runs they 'wont count' and if he doesn't...

You're right, but he's put himself in that position.

I actually don't mind players boosting their average against minnows. But when you're struggling overall, particularly against quality sides, you need to put it into context.

A player averaging 40 against good sides and 55 against minnows is fine IMO.

 

[CountryRace]

Why are recent stats being used against me when my original comment was regarding career statistics?

I have freely acknowledged on another thread that Watson being dropped would be justified. I just think somebody has a right to stand up for an Australian player when they get abused 24/7.

Cause the wc is now and not in three years ?

If Faulker and Clarke are fit when the going gets tough, and Watson is still in the 11. It's a dam joke.

Sick of this guy how many years ffs

Watson is on a hiding to nothing for the next game, if he makes runs they 'wont count' and if he doesn't...

If he makes a 90 against afganistan or UAE or the bangers lets build a statute outside the g

 

[Art Vandelay_]

If he makes a 90 against afganistan or UAE or the bangers lets build a statute outside the g

Who do we put his bronze statue next to? Leigh Matthews? Warne? Sir Don?

One thing's for sure he'd either have to be in his trademark falling over his front pad LBW pose or his dumbfounded I'll review that pose

 

[PaddyO]

Selection now becomes very interesting if Clarke is fit.

I was harsh on Finch, but I still feel his game is lacking. He should've been out early, but good on him for cashing in when he got a chance.

If Clarke is to come in next match, I still think we will drop Bailey. But Watson looks a shadow of what he once was in ODIs, with both bat and ball. Legit have no idea which way it'll play. I'd be inclined to go...

Warner
Finch
Clarke
Smith
Bailey
Maxwell
Marsh
Johnson
Starc
Haze/Cummins

 

[CountryRace]

Who do we put his bronze statue next to? Leigh Matthews? Warne? Sir Don?

One thing's for sure he'd either have to be in his trademark falling over his front pad LBW pose or his dumbfounded I'll review that pose

The famous; using the teams last review, on himself, regardless of it being plumb, pose

 

[damochandler]

If he goes out and just belts them around the park and scores a big ton without any hassles. He'll be alright

 

[CountryRace]

Selection now becomes very interesting if Clarke is fit.

I was harsh on Finch, but I still feel his game is lacking. He should've been out early, but good on him for cashing in when he got a chance.

If Clarke is to come in next match, I still think we will drop Bailey. But Watson looks a shadow of what he once was in ODIs, with both bat and ball. Legit have no idea which way it'll play. I'd be inclined to go...

Warner
Finch
Clarke
Smith
Bailey
Maxwell
Marsh
Johnson
Starc
Haze/Cummins

I don't like 20/20. Infact, I don't really think its cricket. However, given finch 20/20 stats. And his odi stats. Why would you not have him in the team? Its like have two sewags with finch and Warner. Australia has a long tail so the extra slogger doesn't hurt. Better than Watson ffs

 

[Art Vandelay_]

Selection now becomes very interesting if Clarke is fit.

I was harsh on Finch, but I still feel his game is lacking. He should've been out early, but good on him for cashing in when he got a chance.

If Clarke is to come in next match, I still think we will drop Bailey. But Watson looks a shadow of what he once was in ODIs, with both bat and ball. Legit have no idea which way it'll play. I'd be inclined to go...

Warner
Finch
Clarke
Smith
Bailey
Maxwell
Marsh
Haddin
Johnson
Starc
Haze/Cummins

Don't mind that side. Clarke and Smith are a flip of a coin for 3. Is that for the next match?

oh and EFA seeing as you must have missed Haddin.

 

[PaddyO]

I'd be very open to MMarsh becoming our ODI #3 (maybe post World Cup). The guys has a brilliant technique and he'd make some big scores at the top of the order. He hits the ball so ****ing hard.

 

[PaddyO]

Don't mind that side. Clarke and Smith are a flip of a coin for 3. Is that for the next match?

oh and EFA seeing as you must have missed Haddin.

Cheers, I was more counting bowlers in my head.

 

[PaddyO]

Don't mind that side. Clarke and Smith are a flip of a coin for 3. Is that for the next match?

oh and EFA seeing as you must have missed Haddin.

I think so for next match.

I just like Bailey a lot, want to see him remain.

 

[Art Vandelay_]

I think so for next match.

I just like Bailey a lot, want to see him remain.

Thought so because once fit I cannot see the selectors leaving out Faulkner tbh.

 

[Millky95]

Thought so because once fit I cannot see the selectors leaving out Faulkner tbh.

Faulkner is the first guy picked in the side imo

 

[Art Vandelay_]

Faulkner is the first guy picked in the side imo

I agree he's definitely in the best team and some of those who haven't got their spot cemented are fighting to not be the one replaced.

 

[CountryRace]

I'd be very open to MMarsh becoming our ODI #3 (maybe post World Cup). The guys has a brilliant technique and he'd make some big scores at the top of the order. He hits the ball so ******* hard.

Marsh
Smith
Clarke

All good options

Just send w
Shane to the glue factory

 

[PaddyO]

If Clarke replaces Watson (or Bailey) from the current line up, who does Faulkner replace when fit?

Not Marsh imo.

 

[ROOTA#6]

I wouldn't change the side to be honest

 

[bird_man]

Selection now becomes very interesting if Clarke is fit.

I was harsh on Finch, but I still feel his game is lacking. He should've been out early, but good on him for cashing in when he got a chance.

If Clarke is to come in next match, I still think we will drop Bailey. But Watson looks a shadow of what he once was in ODIs, with both bat and ball. Legit have no idea which way it'll play. I'd be inclined to go...

Warner
Finch
Clarke
Smith
Bailey
Maxwell
Marsh
Johnson
Starc
Haze/Cummins

Unless Smith or Clarke roll there arm over that means we must get 10 overs out of both of Maxwell and Marsh. I'd prefer we play Faulkner over Bailey and push the batting order up.

Good to see you coming around re Finch, there is only so long you can ignore good stats, hope a few of your mates come around soon too.