Bluemour Discussion Thread IV

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Go check out the D&T boards and their delusion in the Kelly and Martin threads.
What are you talking about!
It's afore gone conclusion.
Tigers are not going to match Norths bid for Dusty as North are the only club that has any money.
GWS will take pick 2 or nothing as North will get him in the PSD.
They will not be trading next years first pick for either player.

I think that is a summary of North's facts.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

I can't agree with that. North like every club is going to be looked after by the AFL. They will have to work harder but so what they have bugger all to gain by moving. I just hate how Carlton supporters for some reason think that a club who has been a hell of a lot more successful in the modern era then us are somehow inferior.
I think your definition of "successful' is very different to most people, just my opinion but I think you actually need some success to be "a hell of a lot more successful" than anyone. They haven't been as poor as us when we have been down (yet), but they haven't been in a grand final this century either, free agency helped them make a couple of prelim's but they have never been genuine contenders this century.

Personally, I don't give a crap about them and would prefer them winning over just about any other team, but their arrogant moron / reasonable person ratio on bigfooty is insane.
 
I think your definition of "successful' is very different to most people, just my opinion but I think you actually need some success to be "a hell of a lot more successful" than anyone. They haven't been as poor as us when we have been down (yet), but they haven't been in a grand final this century either, free agency helped them make a couple of prelim's but they have never been genuine contenders this century.

Personally, I don't give a crap about them and would prefer them winning over just about any other team, but their arrogant moron / reasonable person ratio on bigfooty is insane.
I was only comparing thier success to ours. I agree they have a hell of a lot of flogs on here but we as a club have certainty not been superior over the last quarter of a century.
 
What are you talking about!
It's afore gone conclusion.
Tigers are not going to match Norths bid for Dusty as North are the only club that has any money.
GWS will take pick 2 or nothing as North will get him in the PSD.
They will not be trading next years first pick for either player.

I think that is a summary of North's facts.
The thing is though Richmond won't match or they would have just offered him that money in the first place.
With Kelly if he actually wanted to get there it would be pick 2 and 19 imo. they wouldn't have any need to trade future picks.
What they are saying isn't actually far off the mark it's just how cocky they are about getting them. Crazy really.
 
The thing is though Richmond won't match or they would have just offered him that money in the first place.
With Kelly if he actually wanted to get there it would be pick 2 and 19 imo. they wouldn't have any need to trade future picks.
What they are saying isn't actually far off the mark it's just how cocky they are about getting them. Crazy really.
I think If Dusty does leave the Tigers it will be through a trade not through free agency unless there is an offer of 1.3 million or higher. And I'm not sure if a club would pay that much because of him not wanting to do press conference and be the face of a club.
 
I think If Dusty does leave the Tigers it will be through a trade not through free agency unless there is an offer of 1.3 million or higher. And I'm not sure if a club would pay that much because of him not wanting to do press conference and be the face of a club.
Why would he leave if it's not for money though?
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

I think your definition of "successful' is very different to most people, just my opinion but I think you actually need some success to be "a hell of a lot more successful" than anyone. They haven't been as poor as us when we have been down (yet), but they haven't been in a grand final this century either, free agency helped them make a couple of prelim's but they have never been genuine contenders this century.

Personally, I don't give a crap about them and would prefer them winning over just about any other team, but their arrogant moron / reasonable person ratio on bigfooty is insane.
You go to all that trouble whereas I would have just kicked up a fuss about yet another person spelling the word 'than' with an 'e'.
 
Jack "sniper" Ziebell as captain :rolleyes:
He is a bloody sniper you are spot on with that one!!! Also you can add a retiring ex captain at the haws to that list, and I sure hope he does not come to Carlton as a *specialist coach (* how to break jaws and get away with it).............:mad:
 
That's why I don't think he is leaving to go to another Melbourne team, if he does leave I think it's to go up to Sydney.
Likewise......because GWS are still in need of more experienced players for a better team balance, before they can make the cup theirs imo.
 
He is a bloody sniper you are spot on with that one!!! Also you can add a retiring ex captain at the haws to that list, and I sure hope he does not come to Carlton as a *specialist coach (* how to break jaws and get away with it).............:mad:
Both stars and certainly played on the edge. The game is a physical game that has been sterilised by the AFL. We'd be lucky to have Hodge as an assistant imo. Would be a brilliant get.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top