Can Port Power win a premiership under Josh Carr?

[SC_Power]

Random thought: Is this the team with the greatest number of hyphenated surname players?

Feels like they should be lining up for a Melbourne private school Old Boys club....

Yeah there’s a few.
Imagine if we got Nas as well!

 

[Cleric]

Port have #WealthBias, #VICBIAS and #Crowbias against them, so if he does win a flag with Port it will be glorious.

As a glorious Port Premier he will be forgiven one (1) floggish act eg personal payout on the club president on the podium.

Port have a beaut drive that borders on the insane,and that helped them do it once.

So while it is unlikely they can do it, they did it before, and I will sink a few in their honour if they do.

Bonus points if they beat the Crows, more likely it will be us because we are usually thereabouts and in Grand Finals vs the Pies the first ones free.

You forgot #SANFLBias as well.

 

[Cleric]

Would have to trade and draft excellent for the next 2 years to put us in a position to have a list capable.

Keeping Butters is critical

I think that's pretty accurate.
You guys have the holy trinity of Butters, Rozee and JHF, with a good forward in Georgie, but really need to source some quality small forwards and some key and medium defenders, which arnt the easiest to find.
If Whitlock kicks on, it might be worth moving Luko back to defence to try and fix one of those holes.

 

[Art Vandelay_]

Depends on whether Carr can elevate a shit squad to finals just like Daddy Ken managed regularly.
Carr needs to equally overachieve at Alberton.

 

[GoldbergsGold]

I believe Ken got the most out of that squad

How do you know that? Williams got Port further than Ken with a far weaker list than Ken mostly had in 2007. I've never understood this unproven assumption, that's like saying The Crows full potential was achieved under Robert Shaw in 1996.

 

[GoldbergsGold]

My question is how much of this season was influenced by josh carr?? Was he heavily involved in the tactical side of things?? If so, not a fantastic sign of what’s to come

I don't think he managed the team and its programs and some of the staff, that's clearly Hinkley since staff like Cornes and Davis have been let go.

 

[Mr Meow]

How do you know that? Williams got Port further than Ken with a far weaker list than Ken mostly had in 2007. I've never understood this unproven assumption, that's like saying The Crows full potential was achieved under Robert Shaw in 1996.

2007 Port was not a weak list. It's only in hindsight because of the GF performance that we call it that. Geelong at that level would beat most runner ups this century by 10+ goals.

 

[Cleric]

How do you know that? Williams got Port further than Ken with a far weaker list than Ken mostly had in 2007. I've never understood this unproven assumption, that's like saying The Crows full potential was achieved under Robert Shaw in 1996.

The Port squad in 2004 was stacked.
Kane and Chad Cornes
Shaun and Peter Burgoyne
Damien Hardwick
Warren Tredrea
Brenton Lade
Gavin Wanganeen
Josh Carr
Dean Brogan
Byron Pickett
Stewie Dew

That side would crush today's Port team.

 

[GoldbergsGold]

The Port squad in 2004 was stacked.
Kane and Chad Cornes
Shaun and Peter Burgoyne
Damien Hardwick
Warren Tredrea
Brenton Lade
Gavin Wanganeen
Josh Carr
Dean Brogan
Byron Pickett
Stewie Dew

That side would crush today's Port team.

I said 2007, which does not feature half of those players you mentioned. 2007 exceeded all of Hinkley's 13 seasons with a weaker list than most of the lists Ken had. 2020 was far more stacked than 2007 and he still managed to botch it. A better coach would have taken advantage of the lists he had.

 

[Cleric]

I said 2007, which does not feature half of those players you mentioned. 2007 exceeded all of Hinkley's 13 seasons with a weaker list than most of the lists Ken had. 2020 was far more stacked than 2007 and he still managed to botch it. A better coach would have taken advantage of the lists he had.

The 2004 team under Williams was a shit ton better than the 2007 team.
The 2007 team played their worst game of the year at the GF, against the greatest team of the modern era.

 

[vozzon]

How do you know that? Williams got Port further than Ken with a far weaker list than Ken mostly had in 2007. I've never understood this unproven assumption, that's like saying The Crows full potential was achieved under Robert Shaw in 1996.

Choco got lucky in an elimination final against West Coast in 2007, easily the 2nd best list that year but during the game cousins (who was going well) did his hammy full flight and judd's groin was shot but he still kicked a bag from the goal square. We also had a dream injury run that year, everything went right for us bad the GF.

The list still had some pieces from the 2000-2004 era with shaun burgoyne in his prime.

 

[vozzon]

I think the AFL's decision on the NGA and F/S picks will determine what happens with Carr and the club going forward.

Cochrane, Salopek, Rodan with another good nga (forgot his name). Getting cheap access to them can shape our list our list build.

 

[King_Tredrea]

I know this thread is a troll, but I'll answer anyway. If literally any other coach coaches Port from 2013-2023 we would have had at least a couple of GF appearances. Literally anyone. Obviously after a decade plus of topping up the list is now burnt out and in desperate need of a refresh, as well as all the star players on the list being mentally weak on account of being coached by Ken Hinkley. So yeah, Josh Carr

Josh Carr

Age

45

Ht

179cm

Wt

80kg

Pos.

Mid

Career

Season

Last 5

D

17.8

4star

K

10.6

4star

HB

7.2

4star

M

4.0

4star

T

3.3

5star

CL

2.0

4star

No current season stats available

D

12.2

3star

K

7.2

3star

HB

5.0

4star

M

2.6

3star

T

0.8

3star

has a difficult job ahead that will probably take a bit of time.

 

[GoldbergsGold]

The 2004 team under Williams was a shit ton better than the 2007 team.

That has nothing to do with what I'm talking about.

The 2007 team played their worst game of the year at the GF, against the greatest team of the modern era.

But that's objectively better getting to a grand final than what Ken did in 13 seasons, because Ken couldn't do it and he had superior line ups than that 2007 inferior squad. My point being Williams was able to manage better than Ken, contrasting your unproven assumption you made that Ken is the best coach ever, when there's far superior coaches out there, who could have taken advantage of those 13 seasons.

 

[The Terrible Thinker]

Depends on whether Carr can elevate a shit squad to finals just like Daddy Ken managed regularly.
Carr needs to equally overachieve at Alberton.

From a Port member perspective, my expectations are low for Carr in his first three years as the club needs to evolve radically from top to bottom. Its a question on how well our players will adapt to the changes and what new players are introduced to shape Carr's coaching style.

The cleanout so far has been positive as a lot of administrators, assistant coaches and low level players that have been at the club too long needed to move on. It would be nice if our president and CEO also moved on as the club severly lacked strong leadership from the top that enabled Ken to endure for so long.

The Kenny fan boy players are in for a rude shock come preseason. They better be ready!

 

[Capital]

Now that we know the Power won't win one under Kenny, what's the chances they can win one under Carr?

I think Carr's reign will be a continuance of what was happening under Ken, as I dont think he was the reason the Power wernt winning like some expected them to. I believe Ken got the most out of that squad, and the long term outlook for the squad is not as good as what they had.

We have Boak and Rioli retired, Wines on the way out, and some large list holes, that arnt easy to fix.

Port over the next five years will swing between 8th and 14th place, and I dont think he will get past five years without making a prelim at least.

Boo

 

[PrancingPony]

Might win one before Adelaide after how they performed last night.

 

[longdonkey]

Now that we know the Power won't win one under Kenny, what's the chances they can win one under Carr?

I think Carr's reign will be a continuance of what was happening under Ken, as I dont think he was the reason the Power wernt winning like some expected them to. I believe Ken got the most out of that squad, and the long term outlook for the squad is not as good as what they had.

We have Boak and Rioli retired, Wines on the way out, and some large list holes, that arnt easy to fix.

Port over the next five years will swing between 8th and 14th place, and I dont think he will get past five years without making a prelim at least.

Port Adelaide living rent free in Cleric's head forever.

 

[Altum Volantes]

Josh Carr

Josh Carr

Age

45

Ht

179cm

Wt

80kg

Pos.

Mid

Career

Season

Last 5

D

17.8

4star

K

10.6

4star

HB

7.2

4star

M

4.0

4star

T

3.3

5star

CL

2.0

4star

No current season stats available

D

12.2

3star

K

7.2

3star

HB

5.0

4star

M

2.6

3star

T

0.8

3star

?

Gross.

His only redeeming feature is bailing out on Fremantle twice but he really softened that by going back to Port Adelaide both times.

 

[Art Vandelay_]

Think he has a point. You even see it with fans.
The 'We exist to win premierships' moniker means SFA in the big boys league.

Time to move on from backwater league flags.

Give Carr the mindset to help the club succeed.

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

Think he has a point. You even see it with fans.
The 'We exist to win premierships' moniker means SFA in the big boys league.

Time to move on from backwater league flags.

Give Carr the mindset to help the club succeed.

So every Victorian club can celebrate their past but we can’t, right

 

[Art Vandelay_]

So every Victorian club can celebrate their past but we can’t, right

Celebrate internally. Sure.
But it's your club motto, and largely not fit for purpose in the AFL.

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

Celebrate internally. Sure.
But it's your club motto, and largely not fit for purpose in the AFL.

Striving to win the premiership each year is wrong, got it

 

[Art Vandelay_]

Striving to win the premiership each year is wrong, got it

That's twice you've arrived at an inaccurate conclusion.
Who said don't strive for success?

But marketing yourself in such an arrogant manner in a very difficult competition is precisely the clinging to the past Kane is referring to.

The statement 'we exist to win premierships' if taken at its literal meaning is 100% accurate. But we all know there's a sub-text here, a hidden actual meaning.

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

That's twice you've arrived at an inaccurate conclusion.
Who said don't strive for success?

But marketing yourself in such an arrogant manner in a very difficult competition is precisely the clinging to the past Kane is referring to.

The statement 'we exist to win premierships' if taken at its literal meaning is 100% accurate. But we all know there's a sub-text here, a hidden actual meaning.

Ahhhh subtext and hidden meanings, wonderful insight.

This club (like all clubs) exist to win premierships, don’t like it, really doesn’t matter what you think. Ports gunna continue honouring its past, even despite a bitter Cornes opinion