Remove this Banner Ad

Preview Changes and prematch discussion vs Adelaide

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
So do we keep playing Mahony because he's young? He really hasn't impacted in the last month.

JMac has to be dropped. Put Pittard back in defence.
Bonar should be back in after soreness for either

Marley is easily best 22 imo should be in next week also and would allow Hayden to play more aggressive instead of lockdown
 
Last edited:
Agree wasn't that a strange decision.... nullified Polec as much as anything although at the same time don't blame Shaw for giving it a go


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

It doesn't take a brain surgeon to realise your don't make your likely best metres gained player chase tail on a tag.

There's giving something a go, and doing something stupid. This is clearly in the later.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Bonar should be back in after soreness for either

Marley is easily best 22 imo should be in next week also and would allow Hayden to play more aggressive instead of lockdown
Williams may come in Ha for who won’t be McMillan someone will be made a scapegoat they will keep on playing him as they know no one will want him at seasons end
 
So do we keep playing Mahony because he's young? He really hasn't impacted in the last month.

JMac has to be dropped. Put Pittard back in defence.

In the normal course of events you would say he has had 5 or so games to understand the level of AFL football and understand where he needs to improve and send him back to the VFL knowing he will be better for the experience.
 
Whats with Durds?

He doesn’t seem to get a mention in selection talk. Is he any chance for the remaining rounds, or are his papers well and truly stamped?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

(Durdin)

He doesn’t seem to get a mention in selection talk. Is he any chance for the remaining rounds, or are his papers well and truly stamped?

Pretty sure you've answered your own question in same paragraph.
 
Considering this is the first of 3 games in 2 weeks it wouldn't necessarily be frowned upon to rest a couple of blokes.
I reckon we might as well bite the bullet and rest a couple of seniors. Taz looks a little down recently, maybe his ribs could do with a rest.

In the second match, rest some of the kids who have been playing consistently (maybe even LDU as well, depending on how he's pulling up after such a long layoff). Probably Polec as well considering his foot issues.

Then rest a few more of the senior blokes for the third game.

Will definitely be interesting to see how the league approaches these upcoming games, and if the club decides to rest a few key players and we end up losing to Adelaide... Not necessarily the worst result in all honesty.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

We need to pump games into Bonar

He was out with general soreness, should be fresh now and take Macmillan’s spot if Marley doesn’t

Agree - he needs to be given a solid block of games. They want to play him off HBF so without wanting to overindulge your fantasy too much- I think JMac probably makes way to create this opportunity for the longer term.

Ideally we see will walker as well. He really looked the goods - as good as any of our other recent youngsters.
 
Pittard ain't getting dropped. Apart from his dumb ******* brain fade he actually played a great game.

Thank **** someone said it. We don’t come close to winning without Pittard’s game.
 
It doesn't take a brain surgeon to realise your don't make your likely best metres gained player chase tail on a tag.

There's giving something a go, and doing something stupid. This is clearly in the later.

Actually he's only our 4th best meters gained player.... and 47th in the league (Taz is our best, and 21st in the league). Polec has been subpar most of the year. Been a bit bewildering really, some of his kicks each week have been shameful.
 
I reckon we'll go 2-2 over the next 4 rounds.
Goldstein needs to play out of his skin since all I’m hearing today that Nic Nat has moved ahead of him after hearing Bruce blowing his junket in his pants today then hearing how great Grundy is going this year then just hearing Gerald Healy -an original North hater from the 90s rambling on how that Deliverence wanna dumb boy Gawn is the best ruck in the game.
So with Goldstein and hopefully a few more players step up next week
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top