Changes for the "Edwards" game

[jackster83]

IN: Edwards, Johncock, Symes

OUT: Petrenko, Stevens, Schmidt

 

[Riggy1]

IN: Edwards, Johncock, Symes

OUT: Petrenko, Stevens, Schmidt

I agree on all 3 ins
and 2 of the outs

Just not impressed of Sloane's game besides a 30 seconds period after Gwildt's goal wher had 2 tackles before St Kilda finally got the center break
but Petrenko has had enough time and hasn't demanded his spot

 

[jenny61_99]

IN: Edwards, Johncock, Symes

OUT: Petrenko, Stevens, Schmidt

Sounds good to me.

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

IN: Edwards, Johncock, Symes

OUT: Petrenko, Stevens, Schmidt

Can't argue with that.

 

[Blue Red and Gold]

pretty much agree with that, Pets a bit unlucky but could probably do with a rest.

Wouldnt mind seeing Sellar getting a gig though.

 

[Damp Squarie]

Not sure why Petrenko needs to go but I agree on the other two.
Stevo looked asleep tonite and Shmidty was Shidtty - probably his worst game.

One change I would like to see for Tysons Farewell Party is to put him in a forward pocket and leave him there all game - he could five such would be his magnetism as a go2 player and crumber at Tippets feet

 

[Alex99]

Bock might be out with a groin or hernia strain. Came off in the last quarter and iced up.

 

[thephenom]

Sloane didnt look up to it. Stevens needs to be dropped.

 

[Pariah]

Outs:Stevens, Schmidt, Armstrong, *Bock(groin), *Dangerfield (was limping quite a bit when he came off)

Inns: Edwards, Johncock, Symes
Emergencies for Bock and Dangerfield: Sellar, Jaensch

*Only out if injured.

 

[The Sloane Ranger]

IN: Edwards, Johncock, Symes

OUT: Petrenko, Stevens, Schmidt

looks about right to me however Bock's injury will likely save Stevens

 

[Sando Pets]

Out: Schmidt, Petrenko, Doughty (Stevens won me over last week).

In: Symes, Edwards, Johncock.

Have a horrible feeling the Edwards backflip has turned into a self-fulfilling prophecy: season's over and so there is no problem giving Tyson a farewell game. How might we have played in that forth quarter if we really still believed we were an outiside chance in 2010, we will never know . . . I liked that Neil Craig was being ruthless and it might have followed us on-field, but the backdown was a victory for the past and a snub to the present and future.

Freo will steamroll us with that last quarter form.

Tyson would have been better served with a nice lap around the oval and seeing his team really fight it out. Got a feeling now, Tyson will be sheepish and we will be brilliant but mainly average.

 

[Thylacinus]

Stevens needs to be dropped.[/quote]

Agreed! Time for Stevens to go!

 

[Allbetsroff]

In Symes Johncock Gunston

Out Stevens Bock Doughty

Stuff Edwards. Too good to play for Westies, too good to play for the Crows.

 

[Macjoe]

IN: Johncock, Edwards, Symes
OUT: Bock if injured (if not, Stevens - not because of one bad game this week, but because we need to persevere with the Maric/Griffin combo for a while), Sloane, Schmidt (unlucky - came up against opposition that was just too good today, but wasn't disgraceful).

 

[WALL-e]

Symes Edwards and Johncock are monty's for me. With Sellar and Gunna to push as well.

Stevens and Schmidt are definate outs in my eyes, with Armstong, Pets, Sloane and I guess Dogga and Davis behind them.

 

[Alex99]

Just saying but would the Edwards retirement spooked Neil Craig regarding dropping another senior player. I doubt Scott Steven will be dropped yet.

 

[macca23]

Symes Edwards and Johncock are monty's for me. With Sellar and Gunna to push as well.

Stevens and Schmidt are definate outs in my eyes, with Armstong, Pets, Sloane and I guess Dogga and Davis behind them.

Are you serious??

Davis was one of our better players tonight and has been going well overall.

He won't be omitted.

 

[Vader]

OUT: Bock (inj), Stevens, Petrenko, Schmidt, Armstrong, Porplyzia, Sloane
IN: Johncock, Edwards, Symes, Gunston

Stuff it, I'd rather we went into the game 3 players short rather than rewarding those who don't deserve to play.

 

[Chief Crow]

Out : Stevens, Bock(inj), Schmidt, Dogga, Pets

In : Symes, Stiffy, Zooma, Talia (play him at CHB), Gunna

 

[Alex99]

Out : Stevens, Bock(inj), Schmidt, Dogga, Pets

In : Symes, Stiffy, Zooma, Talia (play him at CHB), Gunna

Do you go for Fremantle in disguise?

Yeah, let’s play Daniel Talia at CHB on Pavlich who is the number one player in football at the moment?

If they play him (and they won’t), give him a back pocket or a half back flank, but CHB...are you ****ing insane.

 

[Chief Crow]

Do you go for Fremantle in disguise?

Yeah, let’s play Daniel Talia at CHB on Pavlich who is the number one player in football at the moment?

If they play him (and they won’t), give him a back pocket or a half back flank, but CHB...are you ****ing insane.

OUR SEASON IS SHOT!!!!!! Play the kids and get them used to this level. Why not give him a challenge? Would you prefer to see Stevens play instead?

 

[Alex99]

OUR SEASON IS SHOT!!!!!! Play the kids and get them used to this level. Why not give him a challenge? Would you prefer to see Stevens play instead?

You’re not converting me, I subscribe to that newsletter but playing him on Mathew Pavlich is just ridiculous.

Play him on a Kepler Bradley or an Anthony Morabito or their 3rd or 4th forward but not the number one player in the game. I doubt he will get a game until round 17 or 18.

 

[Chief Crow]

You’re not converting me, I subscribe to that newsletter but playing him on Mathew Pavlich is just ridiculous.

Play him on a Kepler Bradley or an Anthony Morabito or their 3rd or 4th forward but not the number one player in the game. I doubt he will get a game until round 17 or 18.

I understand it will be very difficult for the kid on Pav but it would come down to Steven , Davis or Talia. Truck wont play that high up, would take Pav if he is deep forward. If Bock plays then you could play Talia else where. My thinking is Davis will have the smarts but not the strength, Stevens I want dropped, Talia has a good size and speed.
I do doubt he will play but thats what I would like to see .

 

[WALL-e]

Are you serious??

Davis was one of our better players tonight and has been going well overall.

He won't be omitted.

I'm one of his biggest fans, just stating the depth order as it appears to me. I do have 6 players in front of him to be dropped, and we don't have 6 players banging the door down.

 

[WALL-e]

Talia's a few weeks off. YEs he had his best SANFL game today, but why throw him in the Deep end against Pavlich and his big ass nose.

Lets let him get some form up in the SANFL first before sacrificing him to our backline.