Preview Changes: R10 vs Melbourne - Crows drop Hamill but keep Mackay

[RoweyThePainter]

Hamill has not been in good form. He's had good patches but he's had some woeful moments too, much like Moose.

Wouldn't have dropped him instead of DMac mind you.

Thought he was good last week. Didnt seem to be hampered

 

[Brett Cummings]

Almost none of which you picked until after the fact.

what? that doesnt even make sense.

 

[hey shorty]

Thought he was good last week. Didnt seem to be hampered

Again, he had some good moments in amongst some bad.

That's fine, he's a kid.

 

[GROTTO]

Thursday night footy will be on every week next year. AFL majorly stuffed up cutting it back. Fox is missing an opportunity not having a decent footy show either Wednesday or Thursday nights.

It was the AFL Clubs that wanted to release teams the day before.

AFL relented from media and fans.

Im happy with this.

 

[1970crow]

Ahh, you seem to be assuming that Murray will play defence. Only need one KPD; he'll play forward.

did look ok up there.

 

[GreyCrow]

Mines at the dump after 2017.

Hi Jake

 

[hey shorty]

what? that doesnt even make sense.

It does actually, I'd ask you to engage your brain but you're using most of it typing dud replies.

 

[MatthewB]

I would have kept O'Connor and left Ned out for 1 more week

Does 2 things - gives RoC another game to show his wares and gives Ned 1 more game to get over any concerns - it was a terrible concussion

thats called common sense, it doesn't make its way into the selection committee room

 

[DJ75]

Ahh, you seem to be assuming that Murray will play defence. Only need one KPD; he'll play forward.

 

[Brett Cummings]

It does actually, I'd ask you to engage your brain but you're using most of it typing dud replies.

no it doesnt buddy.

 

[Scorpus]

Hamill has not been in good form. He's had good patches but he's had some woeful moments too, much like Moose.

Wouldn't have dropped him instead of DMac mind you.

I cannot believe you are defending this

 

[WeeBlake]

it has taken us 9 years but we finally got there - literally all of us agree that Mackay can’t get picked

 

[hey shorty]

no it doesnt buddy.

Have a lay down mick

 

[spenze]

If he's carrying an injury or just needs a rest, then just say that, why have him listed as omitted?

To be honest though, omitted may mean he isn't following instruction ( which of course leads to Mackay is, so FTS) and he needs to work on something, unfortunately, with our giant boner for having "some experience" if Murray comes in, then a small experience player must come out. The only joy I get out of this is at least Doedee isn't playing second tall...that's it though

 

[Kezza86]

should of debut worrell or played mcasey. murray is garbo.

Welcome back Brett. Any comment re your prediction of Thilthorpe?

 

[Brett Cummings]

Have a lay down mick

when have I ever said they didnt have talent? people bash fog on this board and Ive never lost faith in him. he's the walker replacement.

 

[hey shorty]

I cannot believe you are defending this

I'm NOT you pill.

I've read how good Hamill's form has been, it hasn't been. And then I said I wouldn't drop him.

C'mon mate

 

[1970crow]

I cannot believe you are defending this

he's half way there. Step 1 is rationalising the error, step 2 is full agreement. He can't help himself.

 

[Brett Cummings]

Welcome back Brett. Any comment re your prediction of Thilthorpe?

back then I didnt want to pick him but I'm not unhappy we did.

 

[cmndstab]

I don't mind the O'Connor omission so much. Came in for an injury, had a taste, a few good moments. Goes back knowing what the level is and will be back in the team sooner or later. I'm not a big McHenry fan but he's earned his spot this year.

Hamill out over Mackay? That's a dead set shocker. Mackay was garbage last week and should not be a part of our future. Awful decision, damn near inexplicable.

 

[Scorpus]

I'm NOT you pill.

I've read how good Hamill's form has been, it hasn't been. And then I said I wouldn't drop him.

C'mon mate

Did anyone except you think his form was bad?

 

[Penske Material]

I cannot believe you are defending this

in defence, David offers great leadership and experience down back...

 

[conVINCEd]

He has been carrying an ankle. Hasn’t been the same since do that ankle.

Yep we rushed him back after missing just one game.

He is a flighty player; has Bambi vibes about the way he approaches the contest. Doesn’t shirk it, just has a such a raw style.

 

[dogs105]

he's half way there. Step 1 is rationalising the error, step 2 is full agreement. He can't help himself.

Hamill hasn't been great. Still would've dropped Mackay.

 

[Mutineer]

umm, no I didnt. if you can quote me saying that go for it.