Preview Changes: R5 v Sydney

[Scorpus]

May as well check out the kids.

OUT: Ellis-Yolmen, Sloane (injured), Betts (hamstring), Jacobs, Atkins

IN: Gallucci, Wilson, Poholke, O'Brien, Knight

Sloane clearly shouldn't be playing.

 

[jackster83]

Out: Betts, Lynch, Jenkins, CEY

In: Knight, Gallucci, Wilson, Hampton (yes we're that desperate)

 

[dylan123]

OUT: Ellis-Yolmen, Sloane (injured), Betts (hamstring), Jacobs, Atkins

There were a hell of a lot more worse than CEY and Atkins, at least they were able to find the ball...

 

[SloaneysDanger]

Out: players who don't give a shit.
In: players who give a shit.

 

[haydo]

In: players who give a shit.

Sorry, your request cannot be found

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

Out: Betts, CEY, Atkins, Jenkins, Mackay (concussion)
In: Knight, Poholke, Murphy, Wilson, Gooch

Sloane and Sauce really should be dropped too but we know that'll never happen.

 

[Houston]

Out: Anyone with a niggle. I'd rather expose underdone depth than run all of our leaders into the ground before round 10.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

There needs to be changes after that performance.

I'll await the sanfl game, but they should be motivated for spots.

 

[Redleg Crow]

Out: Betts (inj), Sloane (inj), Mackay (concussion)), CEY (not this level)

I’d also drop Walker.
Call it injury -
Much better than “dropped because he is a liability unless everything is going well”

 

[1970crow]

Out: Sloane injured, Tex injured, Betts injured
In: Wilson, Gooch, Hampton

Most likely Tex and Sloane will push through injured and it'll just be Betts out for whoever goes best out of Wilson and Gooch.

 

[Crowked]

Out: Betts, McKay, Sloane, CEY, Atkins, Lynch, Hartigan, Milera, Jenkins, Jacobs, Douglas, Walker

In: The SANFL top up players.

 

[adelcrows]

Atkins won’t be dropped after 29 possessions so not sure why anyone bothering to say it..
Sloane if not right they won’t play him again next week surely? Betts obviously out.. Mackay maybe as another head knock.
Then there is a lot of others that could go but you would think first weather will dictate this.. if wet a fair few possible changes.. if dry not so many other than what I’ve said above.

Regardless of what we think, they won’t drop Jacobs next week.

 

[Rory Walkerfield]

Out: players who don't give a shit.
In: players who give a shit.

Out: coaches who don’t know how to deal with an opposition made up predominantly of midfielders
In: coaches that do

 

[RePete]

SANFL game will give us a better idea of who is ready buuuut we probably need make atleast 2 or 3 changes.

Out: Betts (inj), Fogarty (omit)
In: Galluci, Murphy

On the edge: CEY for Knight, Jacobs for Obrien

Don't have a lot of choice though. Missing a lot of our best-22 players, and then missing a lot of our depth players, after losing two best-22 players. We are in quite a tight spot. Most our AFL-listed players are to young and raw, not what we need at the moment, or speculative rookies that we are developing. It could be an ugly 3-5 weeks.

 

[Jcpdragonx]

We're going to get flogged from the get go. Our second best mid will be a C grader.

2 and 3 means no top 4.

 

[Bearded Clam]

How people can continue to defend Mackay is fuc*in beyond me... I reacon there was only 1 touch he had tonight that he didn’t turn over and was soundly beaten by his opponent all game.

Atkins is shit. Trade or delist.

CEY.. not AFL standard but not exactly fair given his injury run and ability to get a good run at it... delist anyway.

Greenwood... inconsistent and still no tank for AFL

Sloane is injured.. shouldn’t have been played and surely won’t play next week. Our midfield apart from Gibbs was non existent.

We are gonna get flogged next week... might as well play;

Poholke for atkins (would Essendon give us Francis in a straight swap for atkins!??)
Dear in.. rest Tex, he’s carrying something
Sig or Davis in for Sloane
Wilson for Mackay
Sauce junior.... give the big bottle a rest.
Gallucci in for Betts
Play CEY just to give himself the opportunity to embarrass himself again.

If things don’t improve after the Swans flogging next week... then tank and play our young guys for the rest of the season. Then trade Sloane and Lynch for first rounders. Lynch was terrible tonight but he’ll come good.

Would love a mid season trade period right about now.

 

[slice]

Jacobs has to go. Learn how to not tap to the opposition FFS.

 

[The Sloane Ranger]

Poholke for CEY
Wilson for Milera
Knight for Betts
Gallucci for Fogarty
Hampton for Sloane (if not fit)

 

[MRB37]

I like Hampton, but if they're not planning on keeping him past this year then it seems pointless to put games into him.

 

[Redleg Crow]

Fogarty needs to learn to not be dumb. No point having talent if you’re on the sidelines suspended

 

[Bearded Clam]

Out: Mackay
In: Chelsea Randal

 

[Archie87]

Wait... I didn't pick up on the injury at the game but did Betts get injured?

Bloody hell - ANOTHER Hass hammy? How many more soft tissue injuries until this guy finally comes under eve a modicum of scrutiny? We've added Murphy and Betts to the list in the space of two days alone...

 

[WetCrow1991]

Jacobs for Aleppo

 

[RePete]

Out: Mackay
In: Chelsea Randal

You want to go even taller?

 

[Bearded Clam]

You want to go even taller?

She’s 1000 times harder than him