Changes Round 17

[ata33cro]

I forgot about Rance - I wouldnt mind seeing him back. I wondering whether some of our young players need a rest as we did look very flat today.

Time to try some other young players before the season is over.

 

[RichosGuns]

OUT:
Nahas - Has gone backwards at a rate of knots this year. Should have had a day out in those conditions. I reckon he would want to be contracted at the end of this year.

Tambling - Has run out of chances. Needs to go back and find some form or be at risk of being traded for ANYTHING

Vickery - Was insipid today. Give Browne games for the rest of the year, surely won't show any less. I know he is young but he still hasn't come on like I would have wanted him to this year.

Cotchin - TBH he had a shocker today. One of the worst out there. But he will be gone for his bump, not for his game.

IN:
Nason
Browne
Morton
Hicks

 

[ToroHombre]

Out: Tambling, Vickery, Nahas Cotchin (susp)
In: Nason, Browne, Gourdis, Morton

 

[rombosghost]

OUT:
Nahas - Has gone backwards at a rate of knots this year. Should have had a day out in those conditions. I reckon he would want to be contracted at the end of this year.

Tambling - Has run out of chances. Needs to go back and find some form or be at risk of being traded for ANYTHING

Vickery - Was insipid today. Give Browne games for the rest of the year, surely won't show any less. I know he is young but he still hasn't come on like I would have wanted him to this year.

Cotchin - TBH he had a shocker today. One of the worst out there. But he will be gone for his bump, not for his game.

IN:
Nason
Browne
Morton
Hicks

I haven't seen a lot of Hicks this year. Now that Tassie are out of the VFL we don't get VFL games on TV. Is he a fairly light bodied type like Nahas? I'm just worried that he mightn't be much better (at this stage in his career). On the other hand I suppose being skinny hasn't stopped Predator (Nason!)

BTW, does anyone know how Contin is going? Is he generally stuck in the Coburg Magoos?

 

[peejay]

Gary March hinted in the after match that Browne and Gourdis will be in the side soon.

 

[rombosghost]

Gary March hinted in the after match that Browne and Gourdis will be in the side soon.

That's good news. Vickery really struggled today but he had plenty of friends. Bloody bads news about big Griff last weekend. Jack was up against it today. Thought he battled manfully, the old Jack would have dropped his head, but needs a wingman. Maybe Posty up forward for a few weeks? Damn shame Rance struggles to mark over his head.

 

[Almighty tigers]

OUT:
cotchin - most likely will be suspended
Tambling - terrible enough said
Vickery - needs to hit the gym and have some agression classes and also its time to give browne a run i beleive he was best on this week please correct me if im wrong
and a few others maybe

IN:
Browne definately
and maybe either gourdis, morton, post, hicks, o'reily, taylor any one of these guys and i will be happy

 

[Tomnat Tigers]

OUT:
Vickery
Cotch
Collins(bloody hopeless)

INS:
Browne
GOO
?(who ever was good for coburg)

 

[richoatthedisco]

Out: Cotchin (susp.), Thursfield (concussion), Nahas, Tambling.
In: Rance, Morton, Gourdis, Nason.

Others like Vickery, White and Farmer get some grace thanks to recent good performances, but are on notice.

 

[sante]

OUT: Cotch (Looked angry/out of sorts yesterday, maybe something personal), Nahas, Vickery
IN: Browne, Nason and Morton

I think we should give Browne a shot. Vickery has played a lot this year. Nahas is too small at the moment and Collingwood will just eat him alive.

 

[ScallyWag1]

OUT:
Tambling (needs to find form and/or fitness, whether that's a rest or back to coburg i don't know)
Nahas (too small for this level)
Vickery (browne deserves a shot, go back and see if you can dominate the VFL ruckmen for a while)
Thursfield (if concussed)

IN:
Browne
Morton
Nason
Rance or Gourdis if Thursfield doesn't come up

i get the feeling that once morton eventually makes it back in he'll stay in.

 

[Roachy8]

Gary March hinted in the after match that Browne and Gourdis will be in the side soon.

It would want to be soon... fast running out of weeks!

 

[lesrythmes]

If Tambling isn't dropped I'll lose a touch of my faith in Hardwick. Has had endless chances and continues to go backwards. Needs to be told either find your form from last year or you're ****ing gone come season's end. As Crawford said on radio during the game, if you're not gettiong a touch, the least you can do on a day like yesterday is lay tackles. Tambling did neither.

i've had enough, plenty of players at Coburg who at least have an upside (unlike him), give one a shot.

 

[Dannyy]

Out - Tambling, Vickery, McGuane.

In - Browne, Post, Rance.

 

[smasha]

OUT-FIFA REFS
IN-Umpires.

 

[Madtiger2006]

Out - Tambling, Vickery, McGuane.

In - Browne, Post, Rance.

why mcguane? I think you mean nahas

 

[HobarTiger]

Out

Vickery - form poor and prob just needs a rest
Nahas - love his attitude but he is to small and too one dimensional, oppositions have him worked
Cotchin - suspension or soreness
Astbury - needs a rest

In

Browne - Coburg form on the board
Nason - fit again and week off would have refreshed
Gourdis - time to see what he has got - match up on Dawes or Brown not that daunting if good enough
Taylor - need to get games into this kid now he is fit again, JR8 needs a foil. Need to quickly work out if he is our version of Mickey O

I have by-passed Morton, the kids need the games. We are going to be terribly thin in mid-field without Cotchin Jackson and Foley. Lot of pressure on Tuck Martin Cousins. Tambling keeps his place just to keep another mature body to go through the mid-field. Boy if there was ever a week for a breakout game for Ritchie!

 

[The Sqawka]

Cant work out why Mitchy Morton isnt a regular, has he suffered from injury this year or just form?

As a Collingwood support I think Nahas is far more dangerous then any other likely INs (barring Morton) and i think he can really turn it on when he gets his consistancy right. I watched him over at port a few weeks back and thought wow!

As for Tambling.. really need to get rid of him. He is a list clogger who will bring down your team morale.

Goodluck guys, hope you all make it out there and we can get 75,000 plus!

 

[santa claws]

just a bit of wishful thinking i suppose, as it wont happen.
although all outs bar perhaps mcguane are justifiable.

ins - browne, polo, gourdis, nason, post, and morton.
outs - vickery, white, tambling, mcguane, cotchin (susp) nahas.

 

[THE THIN MAN]

Out
Tambling

In
Nason

 

[Kyusss]

Out -
Cotchin Suspended,
Bling (surgery in the offseason has set him back let him rest up get fit and focus on 2011)
Nahas Needs to do well to keep his spot and he didnt
Vickery due a rest will be a gun
Thursfield looked to cop a huge knock no harm giving him a week off

In -
Rance been burning in the 2s is a big part of our future get games into him
Post leave astbury across half back have post as a target up fwd will contest
Morton 3rd fwd and off a wing give him room to use his footskills
Browne lets have another look against a quality ruckman
Naso should be right to come straight back in

 

[nufan_tigers]

I'd like to see Gourdis or Rance get a gig and play up forward as the decoy forward... Without Griffiths there it was too Riewoldt-centric, the decoy provides another target and who knows they could bob up and kick a few goals

 

[BILC]

Out - Nahas, Vickery, Cotchin (Susp)

In - Morton, Browne, Nason(if available)/Polo

 

[Bazzar]

Out - Cotch - Nahas

In - Polo - Nason

Morton in, if Thursty out from concussion.

 

[TFLUA-Tiger]

Loved the Hicks is shortening call.