Changes V Carlton- Round 5

[E Shed]

I have to say I think Suban is in trouble. I've long been a backer of his but he's showed very little this year. He is the weakest link.
Anthony did just enough. He shows great effort, he's quite intelligent and just needs to hold a couple of those almost marks where he got in good position.
Kepler would stay out.
If Fyfe comes back it would be Fyfe for Suban.
Else Slivagni for Suban.

Everyone else stays, Neale sub again.

 

[Schauermann]

Silvagni for Suban will make our backline to tall for Carlton I would think.

 

[purplefrog]

Still not a fan of Dawson.
If Silvagni is match fit then much prefer him.
Great effort by the boys.
Lachie Neale looks cool under pressure and very quick thinker.

 

[E Shed]

Silvagni for Suban will make our backline to tall for Carlton I would think.

McPhee handled Milne ok tonight!

 

[Schauermann]

Still not a fan of Dawson.
If Silvagni is match fit then much prefer him.

Same for me, but not both against Carlton.

 

[mr.11]

We need 2 quick small/medium defenders that can go with Betts and Garlett.

No doubt Crowley will goto Judd!

 

[DOCKERZ]

Reckon Crowley might go with Murphy..

Mundy looked knackered, maybe Green Vest worthy?

Lower (as midfielder not defender) for Suban if Fyfe still out.

 

[Jezzitizle]

Grover in maybe to try to cover a small forward? Gonna be a tough game..

 

[Sman-21]

Dawson was very crucial in 2nd half with his 1 on 1 work and at times took massive risks to leave opponents an stop saints players and did very well.

Once again dumb costly turnovers.
He constantly lives on the edge of giving away free kicks in marking situations which is scary.

Still beleive Silvagni to be the better option but harsh to drop him after that effort.

Out
Suban - not a defender, been doing nothing
Ibbo - Is not soft, just dont think he can play the game, fumbles, no awareness etc

In
Fyfe - no reason necessary
Morabito - sub

Broughton back to defense/midfield at times whatever Ibbo has been doing.

Forwardline is perfect
The structure i have wanted since rnd 1.

 

[purplepassion82]

Ibbo out? I thought he was really quite good in the first half.

Out - Suban
In - Fyfe or Mora

 

[ImperialPurple]

Does anyone think Dawson might be in a bit of strife for the late high elbow to Milne in the 2nd?

 

[Chops_a_must]

Silvagni for Suban will make our backline to tall for Carlton I would think.

But Suban in will make our backline too slow.

And also too shit.

And will make our backline more prone to falling over and pretend efforts.

 

[FreoRicci]

Does anyone think Dawson might be in a bit of strife for the late high elbow to Milne in the 2nd?

The question would be did it even hit milne ? As soon as the little scab saw zac coming he expected impact and took it. Barely anything in it, but its MRP...

 

[purplefrog]

Reckon Crowley might go with Murphy..

Mundy looked knackered, maybe Green Vest worthy?

Lower (as midfielder not defender) for Suban if Fyfe still out.

Has Lower even played a WAFL game?
Has anyone even seen him in full training as I don't think I have heard him mentioned?

 

[FreoRicci]

I have been a fan of Suban particularly with a great start to the year last season before that injury but he's suffering from a lack confidence clearly. Could not get into tonight's game and had little influence. Too much of a liability against blues so probably him for Grover or a small player.

 

[SH Tracer Bullet]

Yes think Dawson may come under MRP questioning for the hit, but not sure if he will get rubbed out, if he does then its Silvagni to come in, if not he stays in.

Think, Mcpharlin will be fine with his accidental hit on Rooboy.

Subes for Fyfe sounds ok and rotate the green vest between Mundy and Neale.

Noticed Balla pulled up sore in the third term, hoping its nothing, as he played through.

 

[andreww90]

any chance dawson might be suspended for that elbow on milne so silvagni can come in

 

[valkorum]

Does anyone think Dawson might be in a bit of strife for the late high elbow to Milne in the 2nd?

Are you serious - he hardly touched the tiprat and he dropped like he was acting for one of those fanciful award statue thingys

 

[tacopavlich]

Funny how Pearce has quickly become the player we wished Suban would be.

Fyfe for Subes is the obvious one, who goes out for Lower? Can't think of anyone off the top of my head.

 

[FreoRicci]

Do we actually need Lower at this stage? Crowley does the tagging, Pearce the hard work plus Barlow, Mundy as well as Fyfe and Hill. Where would Nick go ?

 

[masai]

Does anyone think Dawson might be in a bit of strife for the late high elbow to Milne in the 2nd?

There was little force in it and I saw Milne do similar later. To me it was a nothing thing, but who knows what the MRP think ?.

Out - Suban

In - Fyfe ( fitness ) / Silvagni if Fyfe doesn't come up

As for Mora, I'd hold him back for another week. Mundy is slowly getting back up to speed, and I feel we can't carry too many underdone players at once. Bring them back in a phased manner.

 

[chinggis77]

Yeah, poor Nick is going to find it hard to crack the team this year I think unless injury strikes.

To be honest I wouldn´t want all of Barlow, Fyfe and Lower in there anyway. Too many clangers amongst them. Loved the set up today, we had a lot of class through the middle.

Fyfe for Suban.

 

[masai]

Noticed Balla pulled up sore in the third term, hoping its nothing, as he played through.

Nah, he was just frustrated that no one would talk to him !!!!!.

 

[Schauermann]

Has Lower even played a WAFL game?
Has anyone even seen him in full training as I don't think I have heard him mentioned?

Played a good game last weekend. But was his first...

 

[Chris25]

I have to say I think Suban is in trouble. I've long been a backer of his but he's showed very little this year. He is the weakest link.

I remember when seemingly the whole board ganged up on me a couple of years ago for saying Suban wasn't a superstar. I questioned his speed, ability to win his own ball and particularly his decision making. Nothing has changed.

He needs to go back to the WAFL for a good couple of months, and prove he can actually win the ball. But I just don't know where he fits in any more. He is no shut down defender in my opinion, and Clancee has taken that tough, outside hitter type role. It could be a long year for him, especially now that Neale is up and running too.

Out: Suban
In: Fyfe or Grover