Changes v GWS - 4 changes, welcome Maynard

[LeverPuller]

Out: Hogan, Trengove, ANB
In: Wagner, Pedersen, Jones

 

[schmuttt]

Out: Hogan, Trengove, ANB
In: Wagner, Pedersen, Jones

ANB doesn't go out before Harmes.

Out: Hogan, Trengove, JKH/Harmes (Take your pick both are shit)
In: Vince, Pedersen, Jones

 

[dylan93]

Out: Trengove (omitted), Hogan (injured) and Hannan.

In: Jones, Pedersen and Vince.

I'm pretty much ready to pack Tyson's bags for him for the Z. Jones trade. His disposal efficiency is disgusting...

 

[Simon_Says]

I'm pretty much ready to pack Tyson's bags for him for the Z. Jones trade. His disposal efficiency is disgusting...

Whats the use, if i know MFC's luck Swannies will probably turn him into a gun mid anyway

 

[VanDemonxx]

in: Pedo, Jones, Vince
Out: Hogan, Trengove, Hannan

 

[Sylvia Saint]

In. Pedersen, Jones, Vince
Out. Hogan, Trengove, Harmes/Hannan

I'm loathe to drop Hannan, who I think is a good player, but you can't have a game with 0 kicks! Bloody hell. I'd still probably lean to dropping Harmes. You know what you're going to get with him. 20 touches, a good effort, some butchery and 0.2.

 

[Darksidepoints]

In Chunk, Bernard, BenKen, Pedo
Out Hoges, Hannan (depending on injury), Trenners (last game for MFC), and anyone of JKH/Harmes/ANB (all 3 deserve to go)

Watts should be dropped, but that wont happen.

 

[PerfectFooty]

Out: Hogan, Trengove, ANB
In: Wagner, Pedersen, Jones

I never thought i'd see the day from you Striker, these are difficult times indeed

 

[PerfectFooty]

In Chunk, Bernard, BenKen, Pedo
Out Hoges, Hannan (depending on injury), Trenners (last game for MFC), and anyone of JKH/Harmes/ANB (all 3 deserve to go)

Watts should be dropped, but that wont happen.

RE on Watts, i don't think he's a bad player. But he's had two stinkers and should work his way back through the VFL like everybody else

 

[LeverPuller]

I never thought i'd see the day from you Striker, these are difficult times indeed

Credit where it is due

Hold on...is Bernie available?

 

[Crusty Demon]

Out: Trengove (omitted), Hogan (injured) and Hannan.

In: Jones, Pedersen and Vince.

I'm pretty much ready to pack Tyson's bags for him for the Z. Jones trade. His disposal efficiency is disgusting...

Where do I sign??

Tyson is a liability. The more disposals he gets, the more it hurts us. I'm done with him. Get Maynard to take his spot!

Watts has been truly awful since returning from injury. F*** off back to Casey. Plonk Pedo down in the F50 instead.

Harmes is hanging on by a thread too. It's only injuries that's keeping him in the team ATM. So I'd bring Jones in for Harmes.

Put a line through Trengove. He's done. Exactly the same as Grimes last season. Came back in and played well for the 1st week, then stunk it up after that. Vince can replace him.

Hogan's injury means the Weid probably gets a game. I'm not sure Goodwin has the balls to drop Watts, so Pedo probably replaces Hogan in the F50.

So I'd do

Out

Tyson
Harmes
Hogan
Trengove

In

Jones
Vince
Pedo
Maynard

 

[PerfectFooty]

Credit where it is due

Hold on...is Bernie available?

I believe so, gonna change?

 

[LeverPuller]

I believe so, gonna change?

Think so.

 

[mrmonkey]

Out: Trengove (omitted), Hogan (injured) and Hannan.

In: Jones, Pedersen and Vince.

I'm pretty much ready to pack Tyson's bags for him for the Z. Jones trade. His disposal efficiency is disgusting...

I don't think Z.Jones is going anywhere based on interviews and the fact that the Jones seem like loyal types otherwise, N.Jones would have left us a long time ago. Also based on todays performance why would he want to come here?

 

[PerfectFooty]

Think so.

Poor old Wagner gonna got a false alarm selection from you

 

[Trav 20]

I don't think Z.Jones is going anywhere based on interviews and the fact that the Jones seem like loyal types otherwise, N.Jones would have left us a long time ago. Also based on todays performance why would he want to come here?

I disagree.

On 9 he said he was concentrating on his footy and not contracts.

I reckon he's a good chance to move.

 

[Andy_Mac]

Where do I sign??

Tyson is a liability. The more disposals he gets, the more it hurts us. I'm done with him. Get Maynard to take his spot!

Watts has been truly awful since returning from injury. F*** off back to Casey. Plonk Pedo down in the F50 instead.

Harmes is hanging on by a thread too. It's only injuries that's keeping him in the team ATM. So I'd bring Jones in for Harmes.

Put a line through Trengove. He's done. Exactly the same as Grimes last season. Came back in and played well for the 1st week, then stunk it up after that. Vince can replace him.

Hogan's injury means the Weid probably gets a game. I'm not sure Goodwin has the balls to drop Watts, so Pedo probably replaces Hogan in the F50.

So I'd do

Out

Tyson
Harmes
Hogan
Trengove

In

Jones
Vince
Pedo
Maynard

Seriously?

 

[Crusty Demon]

Seriously?

Yep. His disposal hurts us. Until he learns how to hit targets and have an impact, then he's a liability. I see so many similarities between him and Taylor Adams. Both can find the footy, yet hurt their sides too often with poor disposals.

 

[stabler]

Is Harmes good at anything? I mean besides helping his opponents up when they have fallen over?

 

[stabler]

In Maynard, Jones, Vince, J Smith

Out: Trengove, Watts, limp dicks etc

 

[CTHORANGE]

Seriously?

Yeh it's weird, I thought Tyson was one of our best against North, he made a lot of contests, and made quite a few quality in close hand passes, not sure how this is missed. People see a couple of really bad kicks each game (yes they do stand out) and that's enough for them to forget the rest of his game. Sure Tyson needs to work on his kicking, but calling for him to be dropped and expecting a VFL standard player to perform better than him, is optimistic.

 

[Dancing Potato]

Is Harmes good at anything? I mean besides helping his opponents up when they have fallen over?

Decent mark, dangerous around goal (but misses a lot of opportunities) and tries hard. Bad skills and decision making too often though.

He's at the bottom of the best 22 and in danger of falling out right now. Injuries and suspensions working in his favour.

 

[Andy_Mac]

Yeh it's weird, I thought Tyson was one of our best against North, he made a lot of contests, and made quite a few quality in close hand passes, not sure how this is missed. People see a couple of really bad kicks each game (yes they do stand out) and that's enough for them to forget the rest of his game. Sure Tyson needs to work on his kicking, but calling for him to be dropped and expecting a VFL standard player to perform better than him, is optimistic.

Tyson has a few limitations, but is ultimately a good footballer who played well today.

 

[mrmonkey]

I disagree.

On 9 he said he was concentrating on his footy and not contracts.

I reckon he's a good chance to move.

He also said he was happy at Sydney. You never know with with players they always say they're happy and they want to concentrate on footy and the contracts will sort itself out. To me he seems to be happy but I guess we'll see.

 

[BG32]

Would love for Watts in VFL but with Hogan out we need him