Changes V St Kilda

[FromDaics2Dids]

FWIW, the article I read never said Broughton was out, more that he just hurt his ankle. Harvey said he played through it. So he might be ok.

Obviously have him as your 7th back in DT.

 

[pistol17]

If Harvey (and match committee) are setting a standard or precedent ala Duffield from last week being dropped back to South Fremantle because of his high "clanger" count, I think we should look at who has the most clangers for the year.

Here is the top 5:

1. Paul Duffield with 14
2. Steven Dodd with 11
3. Matthew Pavlich with 10
4. Rhys Palmer with 9
5. Byron Schammer with 8
5. Josh Head with 8

Everyone has played 3 games except for Duffield who sat out last week yet still leads the club in clanger kicks. No wonder he was dropped.

Steven Dodd would be the next one on the chopping block you would think. Could even be a straight swap for Duffield to come back in after a big game for South Fremantle.

Out: Dodd, Head, Broughton (injured apparently)
In: Duffield, Hayden, Murphy (has to come in after kicking 7 goals)

 

[samseenee]

East Perth 10.12 (72) def by Peel Thunder 10.15 (75)

Adam Campbell: Played for Peel in the reserves, as West Perth had a bye. He played on the ball and forward, kicking four goals. His game was really just for match conditioning.

You'd have to think Kiwi could be a call up this week, I realise its the resies but still sounds promising.
Murphy with his 7 goals sounds great but we've seen him do this time and time again.

Maybe we drop PAV and TAZ and play these 2 blokes instead?

 

[estibador]

If Harvey (and match committee) are setting a standard or precedent ala Duffield from last week being dropped back to South Fremantle because of his high "clanger" count, I think we should look at who has the most clangers for the year.

Rumour has it he was dropped for squibbing in marking contests, not for clangers.

If we dropped everyone with a high clanger count we'd be playing with 5 guys this week.

 

[samseenee]

Rumour has it he was dropped for squibbing in marking contests, not for clangers.

If we dropped everyone with a high clanger count we'd be playing with 5 guys this week.

I count 4 Esti lol

 

[cp3_jr]

The saints have made no changes which is no suprise really but doesnt help our cause at all.