Changes v Sydney

[Lambot]

Are we worried about the heel tap?

 

[port always]

In place of who? Don't think you can drop a defender from the Freo game.

I'd bring Young in for Neade probably.

Here is the obvious Move Pittard to the wing and tell him to run and make as many mistakes as he likes because that won't be as crucial he is not a defender anyway Stewart can then slip in

 

[RangaInTeal]

Out: Everyone

In: Winners

Ken on thin ice!

 

[RossFC]

Out: Butcher
Neade

In: Lobbe
Young

This. + White as sub.

 

[RangaInTeal]

Seriously;

Out: Butcher
In: Lobbe

 

[reCOGnise]

Are we worried about the heel tap?

Ebo's back pocket might be.

 

[PepeSilvia]

Holy hell Paul Stewart has been our best player in the games thus far..His game against Goody Saints was unbelievable..WHY IS HE NOT PLAYING lets reward performance please

Do you have a sexual relationship with Paul Stewart?

Are you his sister?

Are you related to him?

One of these will explain why you have such an obsession.

Edit: Sorry, one more possibility. Are you Paul Stewart?

 

[RossFC]

Holy hell Paul Stewart has been our best player in the games thus far..His game against Goody Saints was unbelievable..WHY IS HE NOT PLAYING lets reward performance please

He played well against a bunch of amateurs in a 100 point win? Better call him up.

 

[Power Raid]

This.

this before that ^^

 

[finbarr]

If Lobbe isn't fit play Redden instead of Butcher.

 

[finbarr]

And **** the AFL for sending us to Perth on a Sunday night essentially giving Sydney two extra days to prepare for round 2.

 

[Dylan8]

If Lobbe isn't fit play Redden instead of Butcher.

Wow

 

[finbarr]

Wow

How is that "wow"?

 

[Dylan8]

How is that "wow"?

Underdone Redden who has played bugger all footy in over a year? He'd barely run out 2 quarters. He really wasn't great as a forward in 2013 pre injury either.

If you're that adamant about dropping Butcher should Lobbe not play, Shaw and Harvs would be better options.

 

[pafc88]

This fixture is actually a joke... Playing quality teams in the first month is fine but at least give us a decent break coming back from Perth. Guaranteed that would not happen to Collingwood

 

[pafc88]

Butcher has to go.. Clearly. Sydney would expose him like something shocking. He didn't even look like a footballer out there at times. Couldn't read the play, almost got hit in the head by the ball, stood there like an idiot. Sorry but he's gone. Felt like being a man down at times

 

[finbarr]

Underdone Redden who has played bugger all footy in over a year? He'd barely run out 2 quarters. He really wasn't great as a forward in 2013 pre injury either.

If you're that adamant about dropping Butcher should Lobbe not play, Shaw and Harvs would be better options.

Lobbe is a ruckman who can play forward. Redden is a ruckman who can play forward. Redden is a beast who possesses deft tap work, and playing him allows Ryder to spend time forward. And at least Redden would provide a presence whilst forward. Butcher provides practically no presence at all.

 

[port always]

He played well against a bunch of amateurs in a 100 point win? Better call him up.

what was he going to do Play badly like Oshae?

 

[PepeSilvia]

This fixture is actually a joke... Playing quality teams in the first month is fine but at least give us a decent break coming back from Perth. Guaranteed that would not happen to Collingwood

Please, spare me.

 

[finbarr]

This fixture is actually a joke... Playing quality teams in the first month is fine but at least give us a decent break coming back from Perth. Guaranteed that would not happen to Collingwood

But Carlton and Richmond MUST play the season opener apparently. Honestly, tonight's game should have been played last night at the latest.

 

[PepeSilvia]

Lobbe is a ruckman who can play forward. Redden is a ruckman who can play forward. Redden is a beast who possesses deft tap work, and playing him allows Ryder to spend time forward. And at least Redden would provide a presence whilst forward. Butcher provides practically no presence at all.

You're saying this on the basis of one game (where, let's face it, we didn't make it easy for our tall forwards) about a 24-game KPF, whom everyone knows has confidence issues?

 

[port always]

Do you have a sexual relationship with Paul Stewart?

Are you his sister?

Are you related to him?

One of these will explain why you have such an obsession.

Edit: Sorry, one more possibility. Are you Paul Stewart?

Not related but I know him well along with a lot of the Power players...I am only on his case because I am so impressed with what he has done this year and also the limited opportunities he had last year..If we can give Neade and Butcher a go (based on What??) surely we can consider a versatile performer who is doing well..Geez some are criticising him because he played a blinder against Goodwood.....I will get on somebody else's wagon soon

 

[Dylan8]

Lobbe is a ruckman who can play forward. Redden is a ruckman who can play forward. Redden is a beast who possesses deft tap work, and playing him allows Ryder to spend time forward. And at least Redden would provide a presence whilst forward. Butcher provides practically no presence at all.

Lol Redden and Lobbe are rucks. Resting forward because they can't rest anywhere else other than the bench. Neither of them are stand out forwards.

Redden has the size but he's never been dominant when he's forward. Not to mention he's probably a few months off and will probably take some time to get his bearings just playing SANFL.

Would you really have him over Shaw or Harvey?

 

[pafc88]

Please, spare me.

You are happy with Sydney having a extra 2 day break on the back of us coming back from Perth?

 

[finbarr]

You're saying this on the basis of one game (where, let's face it, we didn't make it easy for our tall forwards) about a 24-game KPF, whom everyone knows has confidence issues?

So should we tread carefully around Butcher's confidence issues then? C'mon, he's barely played a good game at SANFL level. I'd love nothing more than for Butch to get his shit together but right now he's not and AFL standard footballer. What's more he's fast running out of time to prove he is one. We're in our premiership window and simply don't have time to mollycoddle Butcher and his confidence issues.