Changes v WCE

[Honeyboy Wilson]

Logan's out. BigFooty rejoice.

 

[King_Tredrea]

Logan's out. BigFooty rejoice.

Leaving him stranded on 99 games for the PAFC?

 

[bringbackbucky]

Leaving him stranded on 99 games for the PAFC?

Legend deserves to play 100 - he has bled for this Club more than any other AFL player...

 

[Schulzenfest]

Forza, reserves or not, Banner is getting 30+ touches and a couple of goals per week. Our selections shouldn't be hamstrung by stupid SANFL selectors.

hocking is proving beyond a shadow of a doubt that i wouldnt want him near our senior coaching job

his selections are as piss weak as mattys

Wait until 4:30 before you say that. If Logan, Rodan and McCarthy drop out of the 22 then he's already shown more balls at the selection table in two weeks than Primus has all year.

 

[Andre]

Legend deserves to play 100 - he has bled for this Club more than any other AFL player...

Usually by colliding with his teammates.

 

[Schulzenfest]

Posted before reading page 4.

Logan's out? HOCKING FOR COACH 2012!

Don't mind if he has a farewell game next week. Not sure if Logan the player deserves it, but Logan the person certainly does. As long as it's a farewell game.

 

[Hot Saucerman]

Logan's out. BigFooty rejoice.

 

[bringbackbucky]

Usually by colliding with his teammates.

No doubt the kid is horribly out of form and got absolutely pantsed by Puopolo but I reckon people are quick to forget some of the ball winning acts he has performed over the journey...

Not saying he deserves to be on the list next year - just doesn't deserve some of the vitriol that comes his way IMO.

 

[Schulzenfest]

I've been waiting so long for Logan to get dropped so I could post this

 

[Honeyboy Wilson]

No doubt the kid is horribly out of form and got absolutely pantsed by Puopolo but I reckon people are quick to forget some of the ball winning acts he has performed over the journey...

Not saying he deserves to be on the list next year - just doesn't deserve some of the vitriol that comes his way IMO.

As much as I agree - I don't think the vitriol is directed at him mainly, more at the fact that he has been selected when he hasn't deserved it. His form is poor at the moment. Having said that, the fact he wasn't in the Round 1 team after finishing 3rd in the best & fairest last year was also undeserved. So it has swung both ways for Tommy this year.

 

[Oliver King]

I don't think I've been less interested before a game before.

 

[The Smaller Warrior]

Final Changes:

In: Carlile, Stewart, Young, Jonas, Wingard
Out: Chaplin, Hartlett, Redden, Logan, McCarthy

Redden, have we not learnt? wtfz

 

[Schulzenfest]

Redden out for Daniel 'inanimate carbon rod' Stewart is a massive facepalm, especially against Cox and Naitanui (we're going to get SMASHED at the clearances and we have only ourselves to blame) and especially while Rodan also retains his spot despite his game last week featuring every single deficiency that led to him being dropped in the first place and less of his usual good stuff. He better be sub at the very least.

Quite happy with the rest of the changes. 4 out of 5 isn't bad I guess. And it's good to finally see some significant unforced changes after a bad loss.

 

[PJ Power]

So Lobbe up against Natanui and Cox - Sam Jacobs' world record for hit-outs against Lobbe could be in danger of being smashed..........by each of WCE's ruckmen in the same game.

 

[Malibu#27]

Redden, have we not learnt? wtfz

Apparently he was caught out socialising with some shady characters last night. Rumour has it that another player put him in, with rumours Daniel Stewart was involved.

 

[manureid]

Please tell me that is not Danielle Stewart as an in............?

For Redden, against Cox and NicNat.....

 

[Wargreymon90]

So we go with two ruckman against.....Max bailey

And we go with one ruckman against.....Cox and Natnui!!!

That is some funny shit

 

[PatientMental]

Yep, **** the lot of em.

I want every coach/performance based staff replaced.

 

[bringbackbucky]

Reckon we'll get up this week...

 

[PatientMental]

Isn't Kennedy playing?

 

[Forzaport]

Don't think Redden will play for WWT so there's hope he may be a late inclusion.

Glad McCarthy finally got dropped.

 

[Malibu#27]

Rightly or wrongly, its pretty obvious that they are worried about Redden being able to cover the ground given how athletic the West Coast pair are.

 

[ploppy]

How is Pittard not back in the Power side let alone not in the sturt league side...are they serious..

 

[Oliver King]

...and Cox goes straight into my Dream Team.

 

[Steve Dore]

Some posters obviously rate Redden very highly if they are suggesting we will be smashed in the ruck because he is not playing. I've seen nothing in his play to suggest he wouldn't be smashed by Naitanui and Cox just as much as Lobbe and D. Stewart will be smashed.