Remove this Banner Ad

Prediction Changes vs Port Adelaide

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
We can't drop Hughes. He was dropped unfairly earlier in the year and he can't be dropped after a game like that. He needs a chance to string some games together.

It's really hard to think of many changes aside from Tucker. Matera will keep his spot until Grey / Switty are ready to be exposed.
 
Time to bring in Bennell, don’t care how much time he spends with the handbrake up.

In: Bennell, North, Duman
Out: Tucker, Matera, Hughes
Hughes doesn't deserve to be dropped. Hardly the worst out there. Tucker has to be dropped, what does he offer? Confused with him. Why are we turning these types into half back/half forward plodders? Sheridan exactly the same.

In: Duman, Bennell
Out: Tucker, Giro,
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

As much as I hate to admit it Ballantyne is straight in after he’s back for Matera.

Bennell could offer more than either if ready.
 
We can't keep bringing in guys off meh WAFL form. If there isn't someone demanding a spot isn't much point forcing it. Tom North just had 15, Bennell had 13.

In: Duman
Out: Tucker
 
Ross won’t select Bennell yet. Said as much last week- that he has a bit more in front of him before being considered.

I was hoping he'd be back for the Hawks game, although based on the presser you're referring too I actually don't think we'll see him until Carlton or even Collingwood.

No biggie. We're not playing finals this year so there's no rush to play him. The big hurdle he needs to get through is the pre-season. I think if we keep playing him at Peel, play him for 1 AFL game this year and he makes it through the pre-season relatively fine then we could get 15+ games out of him next season.
 
I agree with rewarding good wafl form which is what makes this year the most frustrating. At least in the last 2 years peel have been good and some players to pick from. Based on Friday’s peel game you could only really pick d.pearce, Johnson or Duman.

IMO all of tucker, Matera, Hughes, apeness should be dropped but not enough to replace with
 
You'd really drop Hughes again after a single game? He wasn't that bad.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Dont agree with the calls to drop Hughes.

Give him a go at it, like everyone else has had.

Melbourne had 75+ inside 50s! Drop the midfield if anyone.
 
Matera needs to get the message and go back to Peel.
Hardly gets involved, doesn’t know how to lay a tackle and hasn’t been spied within coo-ee of goals for weeks.

Getting sick of his $shithouse sweep/hook kicks around the body that inevitably end up not hitting a target.
 
Hopefully Sutty gets a game for Freo next game
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Bennell for Tucker
North for Giro (more help for the inside roster and couldn’t be worse than Giro last night)

Oh - and Neale makes a minimum of 6 tackles next week or he’s gone too.
 
??? Dixon, Watts, Westoff/Ryder. Port play one of the taller forward lines in the comp.

Dixon - Pearce
Watts & Westhoff play high, especially Westhoff. Hughes or Ryan could take Watts.
Hamling takes Westhoff when he is a forward. Ryder hasn’t spent much time as a designated forward lately.
 
Do you bring in D Pearce?
Just to show reward for effort and send Tucker back to the WAFL for 2 or 3 weeks.

I am not sure there is any one else in the WAFL that deserves a game, although it was hard to tell with the team getting smashed by so much.

Bennell can play when he plays a full game in the WAFL, I have not seen that yet.
 
Matera should have been dropped after the Brisbane game. And should be dropped this week and preferably never play again. He is way too short and slow and has poor endurance.
 
Do you bring in D Pearce?
Just to show reward for effort and send Tucker back to the WAFL for 2 or 3 weeks.

I am not sure there is any one else in the WAFL that deserves a game, although it was hard to tell with the team getting smashed by so much.

Bennell can play when he plays a full game in the WAFL, I have not seen that yet.

Ross highlighted Duman in his presser.

Tucker -> D Pearce
Matera -> Duman
Apeness -> Strnadica
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom