Chris Judd vs Ben Cousins vs Daniel Kerr

[SWANNIES RULE]

You support Richmond, you shouldn't be commenting on the subject of 'talent'.

 

[Tarkyn_24]

You said you were biased

And I am. Pretty obviously too.

 

[Heisenberg_]

You support Richmond, you shouldn't be commenting on the subject of 'talent'.

Hows about making a proper argument other then "Go watch thugby" or "You barrack for Richmond"
I will just be like you and say You're a moron who knows nothing
Its true as well

 

[Heisenberg_]

You support Richmond, you shouldn't be commenting on the subject of 'talent'.

How is that Relevant to Cousins vs Judd anyway, just shows you know nothing, that you have been pwned in this thread

 

[Milkman]

Kerr> Cousins IMO

No offence to your family friends, as Kerr is great. But no way known is he ahead of Cousins.

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Don't worry. He will be

 

[Milkman]

Don't worry. He will be

You have no idea how much I want that to be true. If Kerr was able to produce his best as often as Cousins and Judd, there wouldn't be too much in it.

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Kerr was ripped off in the 05 Brownlow. Easily BOG in round 22, yet didn;t get a vote. Would've loved to see a draw though. Cousins, as much as I hate him, has had a career that deserves a Brownlow.

 

[Milkman]

Or two.

I can't remember the game you're talking about, but in '05 Cousins was head and shoulders above the rest of our squad IMO.

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Or two.

I can't remember the game you're talking about, but in '05 Cousins was head and shoulders above the rest of our squad IMO.

Yeah, he was. But Round 22, Kerr dominated, didn't get a vote. Would've loved a draw. I guess I like going for the underdog. My user name should explain that.

 

[Milkman]

Yeah, he was. But Round 22, Kerr dominated, didn't get a vote. Would've loved a draw. I guess I like going for the underdog. My user name should explain that.

To be honest, I would've felt a little sorry for Cousins had Kerr pinched it. Love watching Kerr laugh his head off every time he gets votes though. Hopefully he'll get one. I'd say not getting suspended will be his biggest challenge in that regard.

 

[Tarkyn_24]

To be honest, I would've felt a little sorry for Cousins had Kerr pinched it. Love watching Kerr laugh his head off every time he gets votes though. Hopefully he'll get one. I'd say not getting suspended will be his biggest challenge in that regard.

Would've been great if they'd drawn. But there's no denying Cousins deserved it, and he was the best Eagle that year.

 

[Fletchers Girl]

I went for Judd. While Cous works his ass off, imo only Judd has the ability to perform something amazing and win the game off his own boot. Taking nothing away from Cous I think he is great and I admire how hard he works and runs especially considering he suffers from asthma, but I would say Judd is just ahead of him only because he can change the course of a game more so then cous.

 

[OBJECTIVE]

I went for Judd. While Cous works his ass off, imo only Judd has the ability to perform something amazing and win the game off his own boot. Taking nothing away from Cous I think he is great and I admire how hard he works and runs especially considering he suffers from asthma, but I would say Judd is just ahead of him only because he can change the course of a game more so then cous.

Are you Fletcher's girlfriend?

 

[Brewster_]

Cousins > Judd > Kerr

 

[bunsen burner]

Very hard to split these three. Sorry to all the West/Goodwin/Hayes/Hodge/Black fans, but I think these are the three best midfielders in the league.

 

[Teddy13]

Judd

 

[makethat2]

Weagles talent ranking:

1. Judd
2. Daylight
3. 4 light years
4. Monster talent gap
5. Cousins
6. Second tier midfielders - take your pick Kerr? Embley? Fletcher? etc
7. Midfielder taggers - there's a lot of them i.e Stenglein, Selwood etc etc

Its funny how Parrot braggs about Murphy dominating a tag(More of a you do what you do thing and I'l do what I do) from Stenglien(Who addimitly is average at best)and Murph getting some touches but it means nothing if Stenglien is so lowly rated. Which is Parrot? Stenglien a gun tagger that Murphy beat or Stenglien just a real average player that Murphy beat.

 

[parrot]

Its funny how Parrot braggs about Murphy dominating a tag(More of a you do what you do thing and I'l do what I do) from Stenglien(Who addimitly is average at best)and Murph getting some touches but it means nothing if Stenglien is so lowly rated. Which is Parrot? Stenglien a gun tagger that Murphy beat or Stenglien just a real average player that Murphy beat.

Stenglein is a good tagger, but a terrible midfielder. Hope that clarifies it. Selwood is similar but is not as good a midfield tagger as Stenglein

 

[Milkman]

Its funny how Parrot braggs about Murphy dominating a tag(More of a you do what you do thing and I'l do what I do) from Stenglien(Who addimitly is average at best)and Murph getting some touches but it means nothing if Stenglien is so lowly rated. Which is Parrot? Stenglien a gun tagger that Murphy beat or Stenglien just a real average player that Murphy beat.

Stenglein average at best? Hope that was a troll.

The way I recall it; Stenglein arguably the best tagger in the comp, wasn't actually tagging Murphy for the majority of the match. In fact nobody was.

 

[parrot]

Stenglein average at best? Hope that was a troll.

The way I recall it; Stenglein arguably the best tagger in the comp, wasn't actually tagging Murphy for the majority of the match. In fact nobody was.

I agree Stenglein is a very good tagger - a terrible midfielder though. Oh BTW he WAS tagging Murph for most of that game, but if you feel comfortable believing otherwise then thats OK.

 

[Milkman]

I agree Stenglein is a very good tagger - a terrible midfielder though. Oh BTW he WAS tagging Murph for most of that game, but if you feel comfortable believing otherwise then thats OK.

Yes I do, thanks for the understanding.

 

[dales.girl38]

I rate Kerr over Cousins, even with his cowardly act on Sammy Mitchell which I have chosen to forget. Judd > Kerr > Cousins. Kerr would probably have a Brownlow if he didn't keep getting suspended.

 

[Lynch takes a mark]

Judd is the clear stand out, Entire game is based around aggression and getting the ball in contested situations. Ultimate professional footballer.

Cousins is a champion and works harder than anybody at the club to improve his game, good in traffic and is courageous as they come.

Kerr is really really good, somebody from outside the club could argue that he is the best of the 3 but the fact is that he is injury prone, an inconsistent kick, not reliable around goals, can be unaccountable, doesn't work as hard off the track and doesn't do well when copping a tag, much lower overall work rate than the other 2.

Judd > Cousins > Kerr

 

[parrot]

Judd is the clear stand out, Entire game is based around aggression and getting the ball in contested situations. Ultimate professional footballer.

Cousins is a champion and works harder than anybody at the club to improve his game, good in traffic and is courageous as they come.

Kerr is really really good, somebody from outside the club could argue that he is the best of the 3 but the fact is that he is injury prone, an inconsistent kick, not reliable around goals, can be unaccountable, doesn't work as hard off the track and doesn't do well when copping a tag, much lower overall work rate than the other 2.

Judd > Cousins > Kerr

Amazing. Finally a semi-sensible assessment from a Weagles supporter. I'm impressed.