Collingwood 2010/11 vs Richmond 2017/18

[smasha]

Indeed. Also just imagine Rance's reaction to Brown's contempt shown to Warnock

Richmond players help out their team mates,Brown would had 5 players on him by this stage but Brown would know better with big tross breathing down his neck.

 

[smasha]

The Tigers are very good, but everyone else is pretty s**t this season and, aside from Adelaide, was pretty s**t in 2017. No shame in that, they were the only team to get their list and coaching staff in the right place after Hawthorn's era finished. That Pies side had to beat three teams (Geelong/Hawthorn/St Kilda) that would be a good shot at beating this Richmond side, so I'd vote them given they had to negotiate a tougher field.

Comp very even this year ,it’s just that Richmond don’t get that much credit on fruity footy.

 

[Frank Gallagher]

Richmond’s teams beat the Hawks in a few of their premiership years.

I think our defence would be too strong for Collingwood and our team doesn’t rely on a few to kick goals.

Yeah like we did either lol, multiple goal kickers was our strength, we played like you guys are now but with a massive press, forwards hate the press, especially key forwards, Cloke in his prime could've kicked 100 if he played for another team.

 

[nut]

There were only 6 points separating 4th from 7th in 2010. The drawn grand final takes a bit of shine off our dominance, but we were bloody good in back end of 2010 and only Geelong could touch us in 2011.

In terms of enhanced results Richmond's easy draw in 2017 enabling them to finish top 4 is the bigger advantage. And yes, we've had an easy draw so far this year, which is a big part of why we currently and surprisingly sit second.

Results vs the top 4 four

2010

|round|result|margin
\Geel| 9 19
PF | L W
W | 36 22
41
\StK| 3 16 GF GF | L W D W | 28 48 - 56
\WB| 1
11
QF | W
W
W | 36
10
62

2011

|round|result|margin
\Geel| 8
28
GF | L
L
L | 3
96
38
\Haw| 15
PF | W
W | 41
3
\WC| 10
QF | W
W | 52
20

2017

|round|result|margin
\Ade| 6 GF | L W | 76 48
\Geel| 21 QF | L W | 14 51
\GWS| 9 18
PF | L W
W | 3 19
36

top 6

|round|result|margin
\Port| 14 | W | 13
\Syd| 13 | L | 9

I've extended to top 6 for 2017 given it was close; conveniently it also gives Richmond the same number of H&A matches as we played against the top 4 in 2010.

H&A vs top 4

Coll (2010) - 6 games, 4 wins, 2 losses
Coll (2011) - 4 games, 2 wins, 2 losses
Rich (2017) - 4 games, 1 win, 3 losses
​

H&A vs top 6

Coll (2010) - 8 games, 6 wins, 2 losses
Coll (2011) - 8 games, 6 wins, 2 losses
Rich (2017) - 6 games, 2 wins, 4 losses

​

Sides with more than 10 wins (ie in finals contention)

2010 - a clear top 3, 5 sides battling for fourth, Carlton/North/Port battling for eighth
View attachment 523628

2011 - a clear top 4, Carlton, StKilda/Sydney/Essendon battling for 6-8 with North a bit far away
View attachment 523629

2017 - 6 sides battling for top 4, 5 sides battling for 7-8 with Hawthorn a bit far away
View attachment 523631

Are you doing a school project?

 

[Benny78]

Even that Saints team would be able to win a few premierships if they were around now

 

[Tzatziki_Man]

Even that Saints team would be able to win a few premierships if they were around now

Don’t be silly lol they’d still choke

 

[BEEG]

Who knows both extremely similar how they just hit the scene after introducing some kids getting rid of the oldies.

Just don't introduce a success plan.

 

[barrackers]

Are you doing a school project?

You're asking a Collingwood supporter about schooling?

 

[Seedsfan]

Collingwood did have 20-2 record in 2011 Richmond won’t be able to match that and the standard of the competition was stronger back then.

 

[nut]

You're asking a Collingwood supporter about schooling?

Ok who did you copy it off?

 

[HTT]

Collingwood did have 20-2 record in 2011 Richmond won’t be able to match that and the standard of the competition was stronger back then.

Agree, Gold Coast 2011 were such a strong team

 

[captain blood 17]

Collingwood did have 20-2 record in 2011 Richmond won’t be able to match that and the standard of the competition was stronger back then.

Easier to achieve with less teams in the comp.


Sent from my iPad using righteous Bhodi manpower

 

[treefingers]

Richmond are very good, but I don't think they're on the same level that the pies were back at then. I'd back Hawthorn '13 to pump the 17/18 tiges as well.

 

[Madison]

This seems like a weird thread given Geelong won the flag in 2011 and pumped the Pies a couple times along the way.

 

[captain blood 17]

This seems like a weird thread given Geelong won the flag in 2011 and pumped the Pies a couple times along the way.

Is it really a weird type of Richmond thread to see pop up on the MB? :think


Sent from my iPad using righteous Bhodi manpower

 

[Greggy]

Collingwood did have 20-2 record in 2011 Richmond won’t be able to match that and the standard of the competition was stronger back then.

A 20-2 record suggests the comp was arguably weaker.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[FastLane]

Even that Saints team would be able to win a few premierships if they were around now

legitimately lol'd

 

[Anderson Brown]

A 20-2 record suggests the comp was arguably weaker.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Yet in 2018, an ordinary and injury ravaged side currently sits 2nd on the ladder.

 

[captain blood 17]

Yet in 2018, an ordinary and injury ravaged side currently sits 2nd on the ladder.

With a draw that befits a team which has missed finals for how many years?


Sent from my iPad using righteous Bhodi manpower

 

[King_Steele]

Saints 04/05 would smash both.

 

[Captain_Bender]

Saints 04/05 would smash both.

Not in a grand final though, St Kilda don't win grand finals

 

[King_Steele]

Not in a grand final though, St Kilda don't win grand finals

No s**t.

 

[magpienato]

Collingwood 2011 easy

 

[BBC1967]

This seems like a weird thread given Geelong won the flag in 2011 and pumped the Pies a couple times along the way.

I would prefer a thread comparing Hardwick v Bucks coaching graph.

 

[Grisha]

Our pressure would be too much. Richmond by seven goals.