Cotchin Vs Swallow

[shankd it]

A mate and I who is a north supporter were arguing, as you could imagine i would prefer Cotchin, he would prefer Swallow

Only way to settle it is to let big footy decide

So, Who would you prefer ?


thanks

 

[Bulldog1954]

Right now definitely Swallow. In the future that will probably change

 

[Lights On]

If we are going on the past 12 months. Swallow by a mile.

 

[00Stinger]

What has Cotchin actually ever done except for go @ pick 2 in the draft?
Swallow has a club b&f which would mean he is clearly in front

 

[B-Rock]

Swallow is a long way ahead of Cotchin at present.

Cotchin is two years younger and has the potential to go past him.

Not flying past him at the present though.

 

[a_fighting_fury]

Cotch

 

[shankd it]

i personally may be have a richmond bias , but its all down to consideration of if both were standing on the wall and you to pick one who would you rather in your side , i think cotch has potentially much more upside,although both will be great footballers

 

[Sin City]

Swallow has him covered in most areas at the moment. Cotchin has better disposal, but doesn't get enough meaningful possessions yet.

 

[half_back_flank]

The Cotch is class. Not saying he is better than Swallow at the moment, but i think he will be the better player over his career.