Dane Swan or Luke Ball

[Lazyboy]

What one would you take in your side, myself i would much rather Swanny, think this year could be his biggest yet.

 

[Dave The Man]

Should be on Poll Board but I would take Luke Ball

 

[hawks_time]

A fit Luke Ball is something to be scared of. Luke Ball comfortably for me.

 

[CrazyQ]

A fit Luke Ball is something to be scared of. Luke Ball comfortably for me.

Yep.

A fit Luke Ball is a proper gun.

 

[DoubleO7]

Luke Ball

 

[beatlesmith]

If i made a team right now? Swan
On talent? Ball

 

[HARKER]

Luke Ball

Are you serious?

Luke Ball:
Potential: 9
Achievement: 6

Dane Swan:
Potential: 5
Achievement: 8

I'l take Swan, thank you.

 

[Palmer Stoat]

Ball's the greater talent, but he's been brought undone by injury. So I'd take Swan, who's proven pretty durable in his career thus far.

 

[smiddaz123]

Swan.

Can rely on him to be fit all year around. Can't say the same for Ball.

 

[Lotch]

A fully fit Ball

 

[HARKER]

A fully fit Ball

Is that a well pumped Sherrin?
Or maybe a well trained testicle?

 

[adelaide_40]

Luke ball

 

[Knife Wrench]

Swanny

 

[eldorado]

Quite a thought provoking comparison, unlike some of the oddball pairings here.

Hmmm, I'd have to go Swan.

I honestly can't remember what a fit and firing Luke Ball was like, while Swan has been a major force for Collingwood the last two years.

 

[Themi#9]

Swan for sure

Ball hasn't showed anything, always injured.

 

[Ochre]

Luke Ball just

 

[celtic_pride]

Luke Ball easily.

Dane Swan is grossly overrated.

 

[lion4life]

Luke Ball Comfortably

 

[DoubleO7]

Luke Ball easily.

Dane Swan is grossly overrated.

In what way?

 

[mattys123]

Dane Swan quite easily.

Luke Ball has not had a full consistent, injury free season in years, yet the last 3 years from Dane Swan have been All Australian selection quality.

Swan last year developed into an elite midfielder in the competition, and for a rookie vs a no.2 draft pick, value for selection is also much higher.

I saw both players play live alot last year, my gf is StKilda supporter, and when Ball was fit he was probably as good as Swan, playing a similar type of role, but the problem with Ball is his fitness.

Swan hardly ever misses a match, and in the last quarter of games he shows that he is the most dominant midfielder fitness wise now Harvey has retired.

 

[__aria__]

Ball by a mile. As an AFL fan I am offended by this poll.

 

[DoubleO7]

Ball by a mile. As an AFL fan I am offended by this poll.

Please give us some reasons?

 

[HARKER]

Ball by a mile. As an AFL fan I am offended by this poll.

The poll is pretty even.
I hope the AFL followers that don't agree with you are not equally offended

 

[krisholio14]

Luke Ball's biggest problem is playing for a shit truck club like St Kilda, who like to run their young stars into the ground.

If he was at Geelong, West Coast or Hawthorn, he'd be a bonafide champion by now, like Jimmy Bartel, Chris Judd and Luke Hodge, his fellow top 10 draft picks from that year. .

 

[Bananayard]

The player that doesnt have groins of an 85 year old.