Mega Thread Delist/Trade/Draft Super-mega-ultrathread

[Lyyynnnchy]

I'm guessing that's because West Coast had been talking to him beforehand, otherwise why would he nominate just West Coast and not just either WA club?

Because he doesnt like Ross Lyon (?) and he's supported WC all his life? Why would Wellingham only nominate West Coast? Same thing

 

[saintsrfreak]

I though he just said WA, and not West Coast in particular.

This is the latest article on afl.com.au that I could find about him:

http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/148910/default.aspx

Cripps, 20, has informed the Saints he would like to be traded to West Coast so he can return to his hometown of Perth.

http://www.afl.com.au/tabid/208/default.aspx?newsid=148795

 

[ziad]

Realistically, we were never going to part with a first round pick for Brown, so this trade doesn't change anything. Most WC supporters demand a first round pick. Most St Kilda supporters are saying he's not worth more than a 3rd round. Realistic result that the clubs may come to? Maybe a second round. It's been said many times by many people that fair negotiations leave with both parties unhappy.

I expect something like this to happen. In fact the fact we've got pick 24 now makes me think that we may use that to trade to you for Mitch Brown. I think that's over paying, but wouldn't be surprised if the Saints made their trade with GWS today after talking with you guys about what you might want for Brown - and this seems to me like it might be exactly it.

there is absolutely no certainty WC will trade.

people assume it must happen. This is very wrong.

 

[pantskyle]

I expect Brown to stay now. Unlikely to get what we want.

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Pick 24 (will become 25 with Goddard compo) and Cripps to us for Brown

Pick 18 and Lynch compo to Collingwood for Wellingham and their second rounder (40ish)

Stevens to Essendon for Pears.

Gain: Wellingham, Cripps, Pears, pick 25, pick 40
Lose: Brown, Stevens, pick 18, Lynch compo

Leaves us with picks 25, 39 and 40.

 

[The Falcon Strike]

Get it done FS

 

[eaglespremiers]

I expect something like this to happen. In fact the fact we've got pick 24 now makes me think that we may use that to trade to you for Mitch Brown. I think that's over paying, but wouldn't be surprised if the Saints made their trade with GWS today after talking with you guys about what you might want for Brown - and this seems to me like it might be exactly it.

As far as I understand 24 is for Hickey.
I can't see any deal occurring with what St Kilda have available/wish to trade.

 

[Lyyynnnchy]

http://www.afl.com.au/tabid/208/default.aspx?newsid=148795

As I said, Wellingham has done the same thing. There is a real possibility he didnt get along with Ross Lyon or would simply prefer a new coach plus he supported west coast as a kid

 

[TommyJay]

there is absolutely no certainty WC will trade.

people assume it must happen. This is very wrong.

I know there is no certainty. I'd say it's likely though. Not all players that say they want to leave end up leaving (like O'Keefe) However, most of them do.

I still think that this pick 24 would have been sounded out with the Eagles people and earmarked for Brown. The Hickey trade was from all reports our original second rounder, not this pick 24.

It may be the case that we have nothing to offer - but in the end, Eagles supporters are likely to put an inflated price on what they want, and Saints supporters are going to want to pay unders (like a third round). I'd suggest the two clubs after today would have at least talked, and have a better idea than we do what each is willing to do for a deal.

 

[MaxHunt]

Brown and Stevens to the dogs?

Brown cover for Lake?

 

[pantskyle]

Lake to the Hawks for pick 22.

 

[Carbine Chaos]

I know there is no certainty. I'd say it's likely though. Not all players that say they want to leave end up leaving (like O'Keefe) However, most of them do.

I still think that this pick 24 would have been sounded out with the Eagles people and earmarked for Brown. The Hickey trade was from all reports our original second rounder, not this pick 24.

It may be the case that we have nothing to offer - but in the end, Eagles supporters are likely to put an inflated price on what they want, and Saints supporters are going to want to pay unders (like a third round). I'd suggest the two clubs after today would have at least talked, and have a better idea than we do what each is willing to do for a deal.

We are allowed to put an inflated price on his head as he is contracted.

 

[TommyJay]

We are allowed to put an inflated price on his head as he is contracted.

Like I said before - that's why deals aren't done on BF. They're done by the clubs.

I can say my club won't take anything less than three first rounders for Cripps. Doesn't make it so. Unless we're in the know, we're just saying what WE want as supporters.

 

[eaglespremiers]

Like I said before - that's why deals aren't done on BF. They're done by the clubs.

Correct, and your club has nothing to offer ours.

 

[Carbine Chaos]

Like I said before - that's why deals aren't done on BF. They're done by the clubs.

What part of my sentence was untrue?

Though I will say what you have brought to this thread so far has been very impartial and well reasoned. Cheers.

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Lake to the Hawks for pick 22.

There's some other picks changing hands. Sounds like Dogs get 22 and 42 and Hawks get 28.

 

[eaglespremiers]

There's some other picks changing hands. Sounds like Dogs get 22 and 42 and Hawks get 28.

Wow, massive coup by Hawthorn.
Lake may not be worth that, but to them he certainly is.

 

[pantskyle]

There's some other picks changing hands. Sounds like Dogs get 22 and 42 and Hawks get 28.

If true massive win by the Hawks.

 

[swannies]

Get it done FS

Too soft! 24 for Brown, bah, contracted, doesn't have to leave, let the Aints sit there holding themselves while they wait for the outcome.
IF it's true GWS would offer pick 2 in the mini draft for Brown, send him there.

 

[Carbine Chaos]

If true massive win by the Hawks.

And the Dogs IMO. Win-Win trade.

 

[pantskyle]

And there goes our Stevens pick.

This trade week is sucking for us.

 

[nameless]

22 for Brown...hmm...

 

[jaxxon]

Too soft! 24 for Brown, bah, contracted, doesn't have to leave, let the Aints sit there holding themselves while they wait for the outcome.
IF it's true GWS would offer pick 2 in the mini draft for Brown, send him there.

I'd throw in our second round pick too, if it would help.

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Too soft! 24 for Brown, bah, contracted, doesn't have to leave, let the Aints sit there holding themselves while they wait for the outcome.
IF it's true GWS would offer pick 2 in the mini draft for Brown, send him there.

Melbourne considering offering pick 3 or 4, Dogs offering pick 5 or 6. Doubt they'd be too interested in Brown over a top 6 pick.

 

[September_Glory]

BIG NEWS!

Angus Monfries to Port Adelaide for 3rd rounder!