Do Collingwood need to enter a rebuild phase?

[Mynamesinuse]

You're obviously basing this on your projected 2026 performance, because Daicos has outperformed both players in each of the four seasons they have all been in the system.

And by a considerable margin.

As I posted I like players who can do everything.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Awww look at that, the incompetence



Vintage St Kilda moment

 

[Corn Cobbers]

As I posted I like players who can do everything.

No you just don't like players who play for Collingwood, that's why you're up and about trolling us with your 50th burner account

Glorious stuff

 

[Fadge]

No you just don't like players who play for Collingwood, that's why you're up and about trolling us with your 50th burner account

Glorious stuff

He likes players who 'can do everything'.

It's just that 90% of what they do, they don't do as well as Daicos does.

 

[Mynamesinuse]

No you just don't like players who play for Collingwood, that's why you're up and about trolling us with your 50th burner account

Glorious stuff

I like Daicos he’s a great player I’d just take NWM before him.

 

[Fadge]

I like Daicos he’s a great player I’d just take NWM before him.

When do you think NWM will outperform Daicos on season output for the first time?

Because it's currently 4-0 in Daicos' favour.

And that's despite NWM receiving about 5% of the opposition attention Daicos has received throughout his career to date.

 

[Mynamesinuse]

When do you think NWM will outperform Daicos on season output for the first time?

Because it's currently 4-0 in Daicos' favour.

And that's despite NWM receiving about 5% of the opposition attention Daicos has received throughout his career to date.

Back half of last season NWM when he moved into the mid

 

[bungalow_bill]

Happy for you to provide a list of all these players under 25 who are superior to Nick Daicos.

Go.

21 YO dual Norm Smith medalist Will Ashcroft.

Most neutral fans would probably agree.

 

[Pleasedontfail11]

Going into this season I’d have NAS and Sam Darcy before him.

So 2 guys who have been about his level for 1 season max. I guess that's one way to go about it.

 

[Fadge]

21 YO dual Norm Smith medalist Will Ashcroft.

Most neutral fans would probably agree.

Yep.

The guy who opposition coaches choose to tag McGluggage, Neale and Rayner ahead of.

Great nomination.

 

[Pleasedontfail11]

21 YO dual Norm Smith medalist Will Ashcroft.

Most neutral fans would probably agree.

Not consistently at Nick's level even if you rewind Nick 1 year to put them at the same level of experience. Very good player though.

 

[Robertio]

21 YO dual Norm Smith medalist Will Ashcroft.

Most neutral fans would probably agree.

He has gone way past Daicos and his teamate Lauchie Neale is better as well.

 

[Mynamesinuse]

So 2 guys who have been about his level for 1 season max. I guess that's one way to go about it.

So it’s ok for you to declare Daicos is better than Bont Danger etc after a couple of years dismissing there 10 years of dominance.

 

[Pleasedontfail11]

So it’s ok for you to declare Daicos is better than Bont Danger etc after a couple of years dismissing there 10 years of dominance.

I never said that.

 

[Mynamesinuse]

I never said that.

It’s exactly what you said.

I said I’d take NAS going forward his last half of the season was ridiculously good. Now he’s earmarked to play permanently though the middle the extra stats will come.

I

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Daics is the player of the century so far, could be decades before he is overtaken (by one of his sons)

 

[Fadge]

So it’s ok for you to declare Daicos is better than Bont Danger etc after a couple of years dismissing there 10 years of dominance.

Yep.

Daicos' actual performance/output since the start of 2023 is superior to every other player in the competition, despite having received more opposition attention than every other player in the competition.

That is a bit different to saying that NWM has had half a season close to the output of Daicos at the same time (despite having received far less opposition attention over that time).

 

[Mynamesinuse]

Yep.

Daicos' actual performance/output since the start of 2023 is superior to every other player in the competition, despite having received more opposition attention than every other player in the competition.

That is a bit different to saying that NWM has had half a season close to the output of Daicos at the same time (despite having received far less opposition attention over that time).

Yeah not sure that’s true.

 

[Fadge]

Yeah not sure that’s true.

Happy for you to nominate players who have outperformed Daicos between 2023 and 2025, together with your rationale for your ratings.

I'll start with...

There's only one player in the competition who has finished top 5 in the 3 main individual awards every year since 2023 - that is Daicos.

So 9 x top 5 finishes for Daicos (7 of which are top 3).

Guess who has the second most top 5 finishes, and how many they have?

 

[Pleasedontfail11]

So it’s ok for you to declare Daicos is better than Bont Danger etc after a couple of years dismissing there 10 years of dominance.

I never said Daicos was better than Bont/Danger

It’s exactly what you said.

I said I’d take NAS going forward his last half of the season was ridiculously good. Now he’s earmarked to play permanently though the middle the extra stats will come.

I

What you talking about Willis? Are you okay. You're not making any sense.

 

[Worm4]

Happy for you to nominate players who have outperformed Daicos between 2023 and 2025, together with your rationale for your ratings.

I'll start with...

There's only one player in the competition who has finished top 5 in the 3 main individual awards every year since 2023 - that is Daicos.

So 9 x top 5 finishes for Daicos (7 of which are top 3).

Guess who has the second most top 5 finishes, and how many they have?

He wins sfa of them. Generally comes 2nd or 3rd. Consistent - yes. Individually outstanding - not so much

 

[Gavin Excell]

Betting market not overly bullish about a preliminary finalist in the Pies with them at $15 and 7 sides ahead of them at this stage

 

[Mynamesinuse]

Happy for you to nominate players who have outperformed Daicos between 2023 and 2025, together with your rationale for your ratings.

I'll start with...

There's only one player in the competition who has finished top 5 in the 3 main individual awards every year since 2023 - that is Daicos.

So 9 x top 5 finishes for Daicos (7 of which are top 3).

Guess who has the second most top 5 finishes, and how many they have?

Couldn’t give a stuff about individual awards.

I’d just go with Bont Danger or Daicos playing in each other who’s best.

 

[bungalow_bill]

He wins sfa of them. Generally comes 2nd or 3rd. Consistent - yes. Individually outstanding - not so much

One area where Nick is individually outstanding is appealing for free kicks.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Betting market not overly bullish about a preliminary finalist in the Pies with them at $15 and 7 sides ahead of them at this stage

Exactly where I've got us

We have to get some games into inexperienced players in 2026

2027 is the next flag window