Win Prizes Draft Competition

[Kildonan]

This competition is to determine the winner of a [Draft Guru] badge and 12 months platinum membership

It is a competition to find the most accurate prediction of the players recruited in the National Draft by the St Kilda FC

Contestants will provide a prediction of each player St Kilda selects in the draft

and

A prediction of the entire first round draft picks for all participating clubs.

*Considerable emphasis will be given to the correct prediction of the St Kilda selections

*Editing of your selections will be permitted until just prior to the draft

Please only post your entry, no discussion posts in this thread - they WILL be deleted

 

[Kildonan]

St Kilda draft selections:

We want the names of the players recruited, not the pick number
There is no need to include rookie upgrades (Sinclair)

My picks:

Gresham
Rice
Gardner

National Draft First Round

1 Weitering - Carlton
2 Schache - Brisbane
3 Hopper (Acad) - GWS
4 Mills (Acad) - Sydney
5 Parish - Melbourne
6 Kennedy (Acad) - GWS
7 Francis - Essendon
8 Keays (Acad) - Brisbane
9 Hipwood (Acad) - Brisbane
10 Weideman - Essendon
11 Milera - Gold Coast
12 Curnow - Melbourne
13 Oliver - Carlton
14 Burton - Adelaide
15 Mathieson - Carlton
16 Balic - Richmond
17 Collins - Adelaide
18 Gresham - St Kilda
19 Hibberd - Hawthorn
20 Ah Chee - GC
21 Lovell - North Melbourne
22 Clarke - Hawthorn
23 H McKay - Carlton

 

[Winmar2Lockett]

St Kilda draft selections:

Milera
Rice
Markov

National Draft 1st Round

1. Weitering (Carlton)
2. Schache (Brisbane Lions)
3. Curnow (Melbourne)
4. Parish (Essendon)
5. Oliver (Essendon)
6. MILLS (Sydney Academy)
7. Francis (Gold Coast)
8. H.McKay (Melbourne)
9. HOPPER (GWS Academy)
10.KENNEDY- GWS Academy)
11. Weideman- (Carlton)
12. Collins- (Adelaide)
13. Mathieson- (Greater Western Sydney)
14. Ah Chee- (Carlton)
15. KEAYS- (Brisbane Academy)
16. Burton- (Richmond)
17. Gresham- (Adelaide)
18. Milera- (St Kilda)
19. HIPWOOD- (Brisbane Academy)
20. Bonner- (Hawthorn)
21. B.McKay- (Gold Coast)
22. Tucker- (North Melbourne)
23. Hibberd- (Hawthorn)

 

[Si_Simmo]

St Kilda
Gresham
Skinner
Rice

1st Round
1. Carl- Weitering
2. Bris- Schache
3. Syd- Mills (Acad)
4. Melb- Oliver
5. GWS- Hopper (Acad)
6. Ess- Parish
7. Ess- Weideman
8. GWS- Kennedy (Acad)
9. Suns- Ah Chee
10. Bris- Hipwood (Acad)
11. Melb- H McKay
12. Carl- Francis
13. Adel- Milera
14. Carl- Curnow
15. Rich- Rioli
16. Adel- Burton
17. StK- Gresham
18. Haw- B Mc Kay
19. Bris- Keays (Acad)
20. Suns- Mathieson
21. North- Tucker
22. Haw- Hibberd

 

[felsty]

St Kilda
Mathieson
Rice
Hullett

1st Round
1. Carl- Weitering
2. Bris- Schache
3. Syd- Mills (Acad)
4. Melb- Parish
5. GWS- Hopper (Acad)
6. GWS- Kennedy (Acad)
7. Ess- Weidemen
8. Ess- Francis
9. Suns- Milera
10. Melb- Curnow
11. Bris- Hipwood (Acad)
12. Carl- H McKay
13. Adel- Burton
14. Bris- Keays (Acad)
15. Carl- Tucker
16. Rich- Oliver
17. Adel- Bonner
18. StK- Mathieson
19. Haw- Hibberd
20. Suns- Gresham
21. North- Clarke
22. Haw- Cole

 

[L_W_P]

Hi Kildonan

Are we also predicting the Acedemy bids or just the first round of draft picks as it stands today?

 

[Kildonan]

Think of predicting where the academy picks go as a bonus

Most important is correctly predicting St Kilda's first pick.
Then Rice is a bit of a gimme (but some suggest that he may be taken with our third selection in this draft)
Then any other pick we may take in the National draft.

Because we have a limited involvement in the draft we may get several posters predicting correctly

This is where your first round selections come into play - if there is more than one correct prediction made then the closest prediction of the first round will be used as the decider

 

[goodie23]

St Kilda draft selections:

Tucker
Rice
Capiron

National Draft First Round
1 CARL Weitering
2 BRIS Schache
3 SYD Mills (Acad)
4 MELB Parish
5. GWS Hopper (Acad)
6. GWS Kennedy (Acad)
7. ESS Weidemen
8. ESS Curnow
9. GC Francis
10. MELB Milera
11. BRIS Hipwood (Acad)
12. CARL McKay
13. ADEL Oliver
14. BRIS Keays (Acad)
15. CARL Mathieson
16. RICH Gresham
17. ADEL Burton
18. STK Tucker
19. HAW Collins
20. GC Hibberd
21. NM Partington
22. HAW Rioli

 

[L_W_P]

St Kilda
Jade Gresham
Marthew Allen
Bailey Rice

National Draft
1 - Carlton - Weitering
2 - Brisbane - Schache
3 - Sydney - Mills
4 - Melbourne - Parish
5 - GWS - Hopper
6 - Essendon - Francis
7 - Brisbane - Hipwood
8 - Essendon - Weideman
9 - GCS - Curnow
10 - GWS - Kennedy
11 - Melbourne - Oliver
12 - Carlton - Burton
13 - Adelaide - H.McKay
14 - Brisbane - Keays
15 - Carlton - Milera
16 - Richmond - Matheison
17 - Adelaide - Balic
18 - St Kilda - Gresham
19 - Hawthorn - Collins
20 - GCS - Ah Chee
21 - NM - Clarke
22 - GWS - Himmelberg
23 - Hawthorn - Hibberd

 

[STK2020]

ST KILDA
Gresham
Rice
L.Walker

ROUND 1
1 Carl - Weitering
2 Bris - Schache
3 Syd - Mills ( A)
4 Melb - weideman
5 Gws - Hooper ( A )
6 Gws - Kennedy ( A )
7 Ess - Parish
8 Ess - Curnow
9 GC - Milera
10 Melb - Francis
11 Bris - Hipwood ( A )
12 Carl - H McKay
13 Ade - Burton
14 Bris - Keays ( A )
15 Carl- Oliver
16 Rich - Mathieson
17 Ade - Balic
18 Stk - Gresham
19 Haw - Collins
20 Gc - Hibberd
21 Nm - Tucker
22 Haw - Rioli

 

[Gangnam Saint]

St Kilda draft selections:

Tucker
Rice
Gardner

National Draft First Round
1 CARL Weitering
2 BRIS Schache
3 SYD Mills (Acad)
4 GWS Hopper (Acad)
5. MELB Parish
6. GWS Kennedy (Acad)
7. ESS Oliver
8. ESS Weidemen
9. GC Milera
10. MELB Francis
11. BRIS Hipwood (Acad)
12. CARL McKay
13. BRIS Keays (Acad)
14. ADEL Balic
15. CARL Mathieson
16. RICH Ah Chee
17. ADEL Burton
18. STK Tucker
19. HAW Collins
20. GC Hibberd
21. NM Gresham
22. HAW Rioli

 

[RobbieMuir]

St Kilda’s selections:

Mathieson
Rice
Adams

National Draft

1 CARL Weitering
2 BRIS Schache
3 SYD Mills (Acad)
4 MELB Weidemen
5. GWS Hopper (Acad)
6. GWS Kennedy (Acad)
7. ESS Parish
8. ESS H. McKay
9. GC Francis
10. MELB Milera
11. BRIS Hipwood (Acad)
12. CARL Oliver
13. ADEL Burton
14. BRIS Keays (Acad)
15. CARL Collins
16. RICH Tucker
17. ADEL Bonner 18 . STK Mathieson
19. HAW Curnow
20. GC Gresham
21. NM Ah Chee
22. GWS Himmelberg (Acad) 23. HAW B McKay

 

[CHBench]

Hibberd
Rice
Skinner

1. Carlton - Jacob Weiterging
2. Brisbane - Josh Schache
ACADEMY BID - Callum Mills
3. Melbourne - Clayton Oliver
ACADEMY BID - Jacob Hopper
ACADEMY BID - Matthew Kennedy
4. Essendon – Aaron Francis
5. Essendon - Darcy Parish
6. Gold Coast – Callum Ah Chee
7. Melbourne - Sam Weideman
ACADEMY BID - Eric Hipwood
8. Carlton – Harry McKay
9. Adelaide – Wayne Milera
10. GWS - Used for academy selelctions
11. Carlton – Charlie Curnow
12. Richmond – Jade Gresham
13. Adelaide – Ryan Burton
ACADEMY BID - Ben Keays
14. St Kilda – Mitch Hibberd
15. Hawthorn – Rhys Mathieson
16. Gold Coast – Harley Balic
17. North Melbourne – Jade Gresham
18. Hawthron - Kieran Collins

 

[HaynePlane]

STK PICKS:
R.Mathieson
B.Rice
S.Skinner

1st ROUND PREDICTION:
1. CARL - J.Weitering
2. BRIS - J.Schache
3. SYD - C.Mills (Acad)
4. GWS - J.Hopper (Acad)
5. GWS - M.Kennedy (Acad)
6. MELB - C.Oliver
7. ESS - D.Parish
8. ESS - S.Weideman
9. BRIS B.Keays (Acad)
10. GCS - W.Milera
11. BRIS E.Hipwood (Acad)
12. MELB H.McKay
13. CARL A.Francis
14. ADEL C.Curnow
15. CARL R.Burton
16. RICH C.Ah Chee
17. ADEL H.Balic
18. STK R.Mathieson
19. HAW R.Bonner
20. GCS J.Gresham
21. NM D.Tucker
22. HAW K.Collins

 

[MCG-Unit]

St Kilda

Balic
Rice
Jordan Snadden


1 Carlton - Jacob Weitering
2 Brisbane - Josh Schache
3 Swans - Callum Mills (A)
4 Melbourne - Clayton Oliver
5 GWS - Jacob Hopper (A)
6 Essendon - Darcy Parish
7 Essendon - Aaron Francis
8 Gold Coast - Callum Ah Chee
9 Melbourne - Sam Weideman
10 Carlton - Charlie Curnow
11 Brisbane - Eric Hipwood (A)
12 Adelaide - Wayne Milera
13 Carlton - Kieran Collins
14 GWS - Matthew Kennedy (A)
15 Richmond - Daniel Rioli
16 Adelaide - Ryan Burton
17 St Kilda - Harley Balic
18 Brisbane - Ben Keays (A)
19 Hawthorn - Mitch Hibberd
20 Gold Coast - Jade Gresham
21 North Melb - Ryan Clarke
22 Hawthorn - Darcy Tucker
23 Carlton - Harrison McKay
24 Essendon - Rhys Mathieson

 

[dewah07]

Saints Picks
BALIC
rice
Schoenfield
sinc

 

[Kildonan]

St Kilda draft selections:

We want the names of the players recruited, not the pick number
There is no need to include rookie upgrades (Sinclair)

My picks:

Gresham
Rice
Gardner

National Draft First Round

1 Weitering - Carlton (10)
2 Schache - Brisbane (10)
3 Hopper (Acad) - GWS (4)
4 Mills (Acad) - Sydney (9)
5 Parish - Melbourne (8)
6 Kennedy (Acad) - GWS (3)
7 Francis - Essendon (10)
8 Keays (Acad) - Brisbane (-)
9 Hipwood (Acad) - Brisbane (5)
10 Weideman - Essendon (6)
11 Milera - Gold Coast (6)
12 Curnow - Melbourne (8)
13 Oliver - Carlton (-)
14 Burton - Adelaide (-)
15 Mathieson - Carlton (-)
16 Balic - Richmond (-)
17 Collins - Adelaide (-)
18 Gresham - St Kilda (10)
19 Hibberd - Hawthorn (-)
20 Ah Chee - GC (5)
21 Lovell - North Melbourne (8)
22 Clarke - Hawthorn (-)
23 H McKay - Carlton

Total = 102

St Kilda
Jade Gresham
Marthew Allen
Bailey Rice

National Draft
1 - Carlton - Weitering (10)
2 - Brisbane - Schache (10)
3 - Sydney - Mills (10)
4 - Melbourne - Parish (8)
5 - GWS - Hopper (8)
6 - Essendon - Francis (10)
7 - Brisbane - Hipwood (3)
8 - Essendon - Weideman (6)
9 - GCS - Curnow (4)
10 - GWS - Kennedy (7)
11 - Melbourne - Oliver (5)
12 - Carlton - Burton (-)
13 - Adelaide - H.McKay (8)
14 - Brisbane - Keays (-)
15 - Carlton - Milera (6)
16 - Richmond - Matheison (-)
17 - Adelaide - Balic (-)
18 - St Kilda - Gresham (10)
19 - Hawthorn - Collins (-)
20 - GCS - Ah Chee (5)
21 - NM - Clarke (-)
22 - GWS - Himmelberg (4)
23 - Hawthorn - Hibberd (-)

Total = 114

ST KILDA
Gresham
Rice
L.Walker

ROUND 1
1 Carl - Weitering (10)
2 Bris - Schache (10)
3 Syd - Mills ( A) (10)
4 Melb - weideman (5)
5 Gws - Hooper ( A ) (8)
6 Gws - Kennedy ( A ) (3)
7 Ess - Parish (10)
8 Ess - Curnow (2)
9 GC - Milera (2)
10 Melb - Francis (6)
11 Bris - Hipwood ( A ) (8)
12 Carl - H McKay (10)
13 Ade - Burton (-)
14 Bris - Keays ( A ) (-)
15 Carl- Oliver (-)
16 Rich - Mathieson (-)
17 Ade - Balic (-)
18 Stk - Gresham (10)
19 Haw - Collins (-)
20 Gc - Hibberd (-)
21 Nm - Tucker (-)
22 Haw - Rioli (-)

Total = 94

St Kilda
Gresham
Skinner
Rice

1st Round
1. Carl- Weitering (10)
2. Bris- Schache (10)
3. Syd- Mills (Acad) (10)
4. Melb- Oliver (10)
5. GWS- Hopper (Acad) (8)
6. Ess- Parish (10)
7. Ess- Weideman (6)
8. GWS- Kennedy (Acad) (5)
9. Suns- Ah Chee (10)
10. Bris- Hipwood (Acad) (6)
11. Melb- H McKay (8)
12. Carl- Francis (2)
13. Adel- Milera (10)
14. Carl- Curnow (10)
15. Rich- Rioli (10)
16. Adel- Burton (-)
17. StK- Gresham (10)
18. Haw- B Mc Kay (4)
19. Bris- Keays (Acad) (5)
20. Suns- Mathieson (-)
21. North- Tucker (-)
22. Haw- Hibberd (-)

Total = 140

There were four posters who were equally accurate on their prediction of the Saints recruits
So I used a complicated scoring system where perfect = 10, same club but different pick = 5, near correct but different club = 10 minus difference x2 Academy player exact = 10, Academy near correct = 10 minus difference.

Winner = Si_Simmo congratulations

I'll see about awarding you your prize ASAP