Draft Watcher eDPS Draft Watch 2018

[eDPS]

What do you think of Hugo Munn?

A bit slow and doesn't have assured hands overhead, not a great combination for a modern key position player. I have him as a rookie prospect at this stage

 

[Turbocat]

A bit slow and doesn't have assured hands overhead, not a great combination for a modern key position player. I have him as a rookie prospect at this stage

OK fair enough. Mobility is an issue in your opinion.

 

[eDPS]

OK fair enough. Mobility is an issue in your opinion.

My biggest issue is his consistency overhead, if your not mobile your hands need to be vice like, he has good judgement overhead and good bodywork he just needs to start clunking them more.

 

[Turbocat]

My biggest issue is his consistency overhead, if your not mobile your hands need to be vice like, he has good judgement overhead and good bodywork he just needs to start clunking them more.

The review I have read , he seems aggressive .. he an exchange with Preuss in the academy match apparently.

 

[eDPS]

The review I have read , he seems aggressive .. he an exchange with Preuss in the academy match apparently.

Just about everyone had an exchange with Preuss haha, i think the big man was taking things a bit too seriously with the young players

 

[Turbocat]

Just about everyone had an exchange with Preuss haha, i think the big man was taking things a bit too seriously with the young players

OK who do you have the most under valued KPF ...

 

[eDPS]

OK who do you have the most under valued KPF ...

To be honest outside of the big 3 i haven't been that impressed with the key position forwards in this draft. Barzen got injured early in the year despite being 193cm he plays more of a 3rd tall role its hard to value him since i haven't seen him since last year. Garoni has showed some good signs but again like Munn his mobility is a bit poor. Will Kennedy from Sandringham plays similar to James Stewart from the bombers he is one i like late in the draft. Ben Silvagni is tied to Carlton but he has also showed some nice signs.

I haven't got anything on the key position players from WA so we might find some good players from them when the championships come around.

 

[mattyc75]

To be honest outside of the big 3 i haven't been that impressed with the key position forwards in this draft. Barzen got injured early in the year despite being 193cm he plays more of a 3rd tall role its hard to value him since i haven't seen him since last year. Garoni has showed some good signs but again like Munn his mobility is a bit poor. Will Kennedy from Sandringham plays similar to James Stewart from the bombers he is one i like late in the draft. Ben Silvagni is tied to Carlton but he has also showed some nice signs.

I haven't got anything on the key position players from WA so we might find some good players from them when the championships come around.

I realise its early days but Whats your reasoning behind the eagles taking kennedy? Did any thought go into it or are you just throwing names out there?

Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk

 

[eDPS]

I realise its early days but Whats your reasoning behind the eagles taking kennedy? Did any thought go into it or are you just throwing names out there?

Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk

A lack of WA players ive seen has alot to do with it since im pretty sure you guys favour WA players with those 2nd round picks. Kennedy has good upside and being a forward named Kennedy i thought was fitting haha

 

[LynchysMob]

When was the last time as tall as Max King went #1?

Isn't Tom Boyd about 201cm?

Sent from my MHA-L09 using Tapatalk

 

[mattyc75]

A lack of WA players ive seen has alot to do with it since im pretty sure you guys favour WA players with those 2nd round picks. Kennedy has good upside and being a forward named Kennedy i thought was fitting haha

Almost as good as me supporting chelsea because i had a crush on a chick named chelsea at high school

Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk

 

[Turbocat]

Isn't Tom Boyd about 201cm?

Sent from my MHA-L09 using Tapatalk

Thats a fair point. I suspect King will be taller by Nov but lets not be picky.

 

[eDPS]

 

[foj1]

interesting read.
i reckon kennedy, garoni, o'neill, mchenry and barzen especially high.
But it is a LONG season.

 

[eDPS]

interesting read.
i reckon kennedy, garoni, o'neill, mchenry and barzen especially high.
But it is a LONG season.

Barzen is that high because I feel he suits the Cats, I wouldn’t take him top 15 at this stage. McHenry purley because I have lions taking Walsh early. Garoni is high because I was running out of talls to think of for that pick haha same with Kennedy. O’Neill is hard to place but I like his contested game.

This is also very early and just a bit of fun so I’m not puting a massive amount of thought into it at this stage. I’d be expecting rhylee West to get a bid in the top 30 aswell

 

[foj1]

Barzen is that high because I feel he suits the Cats, I wouldn’t take him top 15 at this stage. McHenry purley because I have lions taking Walsh early. Garoni is high because I was running out of talls to think of for that pick haha same with Kennedy. O’Neill is hard to place but I like his contested game.

This is also very early and just a bit of fun so I’m not puting a massive amount of thought into it at this stage. I’d be expecting rhylee West to get a bid in the top 30 aswell

Mate no need to justify anything.
I think West is so far ahead of ONeill that it aint funny. If the talls are not good enough then that is that.

 

[eDPS]

Mate no need to justify anything.
I think West is so far ahead of ONeill that it aint funny. If the talls are not good enough then that is that.

Not really justifying more so agreeing with you that they are too high

Yeah West was super impressive against the academy I haven’t been able to see him as much as O’Neill but now yeah I’d have to agree with you

Yeah very true which does say a lot for this draft that the depth of talls is pretty poor.

 

[foj1]

Have a look at ONeill's stats mate.

 

[eDPS]

Have a look at ONeill's stats mate.

This last week his stats where poor, first 2 games look solid enough

 

[briztoon]

I'm jacked because GC keeping getting Berry jr.

 

[Schtinker]

View attachment 481957

Where are Gold Coast getting their 2nd round pick from? Traded it to West Coast.

 

[eDPS]

Where are Gold Coast getting their 2nd round pick from? Traded it to West Coast.

This is going of the list of picks made by Lore, she is the one to ask on this

 

[HedgeFund]

This is going of the list of picks made by Lore, she is the one to ask on this

Realistically that pick list will change quite a bit during Trade Period - so no need to get too worried just yet.

 

[Sin City]

interesting read.
i reckon kennedy, garoni, o'neill, mchenry and barzen especially high.
But it is a LONG season.

I thought the ranking of O'Neill was fair, he's been impressive this year.

 

[eDPS]

Realistically that pick list will change quite a bit during Trade Period - so no need to get too worried just yet.

Yeah at the end of the day this is just a little thing for the fun of it, it’s not serious and has no point for the grand scheme of things