Fevola Vs Lloyd

bluesforever · Oct 24, 2006

These two have been compared alot in the past I know but now Lloyd has come off a big break do you think it will effect his goal kicking next season?

Who will be more effective for their respective clubs next season?

Hawker_Boy · Oct 24, 2006

imo i recon Fev will do better

However if lloyd can bounce back well from his injury he will get 70+ goals

parrot · Oct 24, 2006

Fev has alot more natural talent and skill, but Lloyd has been a more reliable goal kicker over a longer time.

Klyntonius · Oct 24, 2006

Lloyd is a better full forward at this point in time but I like Fev better.

danzan22 · Oct 24, 2006

these sort of polls dont faze me, next year well see which one does better for there team

topdon · Oct 24, 2006

The BigFooty populus must have memories akin to goldfish.

Fev is even yet to kick 100+ in a season. Lloyd has done it twice.

In Fevola's 8 seasons in the comp, he has kicked 328 goals.
In Lloyd's first 8 seasons in the comp, he kicked 506 goals.

Its unknown how Lloyd will come back next season, but he was on fire earlier in the season prior doing his hammy in Round 3. I think the Lloyd will get back to his best in 2007.

Barry Zuckercorn · Oct 24, 2006

topdon said:
The BigFooty populus must have memories akin to goldfish.

Fev is even yet to kick 100+ in a season. Lloyd has done it twice.

In Fevola's 8 seasons in the comp, he has kicked 328 goals.
In Lloyd's first 8 seasons in the comp, he kicked 506 goals.

Its unknown how Lloyd will come back next season, but he was on fire earlier in the season prior doing his hammy in Round 3. I think the Lloyd will get back to his best in 2007.

Brilliant! Shall I lock it in now then that Lloyd will kick more goals than Fev next year based on that stat... That is what the poll is asking I believe.

PS: Lock in Carlton to win the flag next year. They have won 16 flags in their first 109 years in the comp so they're a monty! Good luck and happy punting

Longy413 · Oct 24, 2006

Barry Zuckercorn QC said:
Brilliant! Shall I lock it in now then that Lloyd will kick more goals than Fev next year based on that stat...

Did you not read the part that said it is unknown how Lloyd will come back next year?

Is goals the only variable on assessing who is more effective?

Jeremias · Oct 25, 2006

Fevola.

Back to back Coleman medallist is on the cards...

parrot · Oct 25, 2006

topdon said:
..Fev is even yet to kick 100+ in a season. Lloyd has done it twice....

That is a valid point. Lloyd has been far more consistent over a longer period. But with Fev, I think we've only seen about 60% of this guys potential. I doubt we'll ever see Matty kick over 100 again. Even before his injury, there were some signs that his one-dimensional old-fashion style FF technique was becoming much less effective. Many Dons fans noted this. Fev's style is more conducive to the modern game. I'm sure he'll be looking forward to delivery from elite talents like Marc Murphy, Bryce Gibbs , Kade Simpson etc next year, as would any KP forward.

Blues_Man · Oct 25, 2006

I think it's more the case of will the umpires remember their love child after he has been out of the game for so long ...and has he been maintaining his diving skills in his time out ? If the maggotts reclaim him as their own then i think the breezer boy will do quite well next year

Monkeyboy · Oct 25, 2006

Will be a great battle for the Coleman

Think Fevs greater supply and Carltons greater reliance on him may make it difficult for Lloydy. Expect Johns and Lucas to score 40 plus

parrot · Oct 25, 2006

Monkeyboy said:
.... Expect Johns and Lucas to score 40 plus

Is that Johns guy still on your list? He looks a bit like Cam Cloke Mk2. Johns goes OK so long as he doesn't have to run or jump.

Longy413 · Oct 25, 2006

He can run quickly, just not very far.

thebigboy · Oct 25, 2006

Lloyd and Fev will be close this year.

Lloyd will kick more IMO

footy_paul · Oct 25, 2006

Jeremias said:
Fevola.

Back to back Coleman medallist is on the cards...

yeah and carlton back to back to back spoons is certainely on too

Bombs Away · Oct 25, 2006

Barry Zuckercorn QC said:
Brilliant! Shall I lock it in now then that Lloyd will kick more goals than Fev next year based on that stat... That is what the poll is asking I believe.

PS: Lock in Carlton to win the flag next year. They have won 16 flags in their first 109 years in the comp so they're a monty! Good luck and happy punting

Barry was just staiting a fact, another fact is that essendon have also won 16 flags in their first 109 years in the comp. Will tht now confuse you with your monty?

Jeremias · Oct 25, 2006

footy_paul said:
yeah and carlton back to back to back spoons is certainely on too

Unsuccessful deflection board

Good to see you agree.

Big Scottknowsall · Oct 25, 2006

If both players play a full season fit, Lloyd will surely kick more. The reasons are as follws:

- He is better on the lead
- He is a better mark
- He reads the play better and will "steal" more goals
- He has more natural talent, contrary to what was previously written, as evidenced by his first few season return....
- He is a better kick for goal from any position on the ground.
- He is better at "working" the umpires
- Essendon have more inside 50's this year, and I expect that will continue next year even though Carlton apparently have such an awesome young midfield

.

Good day all......

Barry Zuckercorn · Oct 25, 2006

Bombs Away said:
Barry was just staiting a fact, another fact is that essendon have also won 16 flags in their first 109 years in the comp. Will tht now confuse you with your monty?

Hahaha! Good call. Let's just say that 15th and 16th from 2006 are now equal flag favourites in 2007 :thumbsu:

thebigboy · Oct 25, 2006

Barry Zuckercorn QC said:
Hahaha! Good call. Let's just say that 15th and 16th from 2006 are now equal flag favourites in 2007

This is coming from a guy who goes for a club with only 1 premiership in their tragic history...

half time raffle · Oct 25, 2006

i can't believe this comparision, Llyod is clearly the superior player, look at their records. One good season does not put Fev into Llyod's league, gee Carlton supporters will look for anything to hang their hat on.

windyhill · Oct 25, 2006

Blues_Man said:
I think it's more the case of will the umpires remember their love child after he has been out of the game for so long ...and has he been maintaining his diving skills in his time out ? If the maggotts reclaim him as their own then i think the breezer boy will do quite well next year

Loved the way carlton shopped him around last year, very close to joining richmond. Imagine how carlton would have gone this season without him.

dave_27 · Oct 25, 2006

windyhill said:
Imagine how carlton would have gone this season without him.

Finished bottom?

lol.

parrot · Oct 25, 2006

Barry Zuckercorn QC said:
Hahaha! Good call. Let's just say that 15th and 16th from 2006 are now equal flag favourites in 2007

1 flag and 26 spoons. Does that ring any bells?

Log In or Create New Account

World Cup game 13: Afg. v S Africa - Game 14: Australia v Ireland - Game 15: England v W.I.

Guest - BigFooty Tipping 2026 - Get on! - $500 first prize - Weekly Prizes - Click to Join

Fevola Vs Lloyd

Club Legend

Rookie

Brownlow Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Moderator

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Club Legend

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Dons. That’s it

Cancelled

All Australian

Moderator

Club Legend

Brownlow Medallist

Dons. That’s it

Team Captain

Hall of Famer

Norm Smith Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Similar threads