List Mgmt. Gibbs - 2017 Trade Discussions! V2.0

[Roovolution]

• If the gibbs deal happens i think it will be our pick 10 +16 to carlton and we will get carltons 2018 2nd rd pick and they will get our 2018 2nd rd pick.

Eh?

 

[Eagleboy2011]

Basically 2x first round picks for Gibbs and a 2018 2nd round pick upgrade of about 10 spots.
A woeful trade that would be.

Agree. Don't blink Reid. I see you squirming a little.

 

[mickfaxis]

How would we feel about 10 and 16 for gibbs and Carlton 2018 second round?

If 12 comes back from Brisbane, then yes.

 

[FAITH]

Tmrws Headline: 'SOS sends SOS to Crows'

 

[Iron]

gut feel 10 is off the table, crows want the sa lad from the draft.

Ideally yes. But think there's little chance of walking away from the trade without having given up two firsts in some capacity. Too much ego on both sides.

 

[Anzacpaul]

Tmrws Headline: 'SOS sends SOS to Crows'

I'm hoping it's more like

"Silly Sosage"

 

[Untouchables22]

• If the gibbs deal happens i think it will be our pick 10 +16 to carlton and we will get carltons 2018 2nd rd pick and they will get our 2018 2nd rd pick.

Yuck.

 

[FAITH]

I'm hoping it's more like

"Silly Sosage"

Actually i like 'Blues Send SOS to Crows'

 

[Aaron929]

12 + 16 with a second round back next year might not be terrible this years draft is very weak

But Carlton approached us so we should have the upper hand

 

[The Sloane Ranger]

IMO the Gibbs deal has been weeks in the pipeline and the today's announcement is more to do with an agreed Comms strategy between the clubs that best lands the deal with the Carlton members and supporters

 

[Bicks]

If we're getting a 2018 second coming back this way I like it. One would have thought that would be top 25 and potentially in Rozee/Hateley territory

You must think Rozee and Hately are going to have ordinary years in 2018 because at this stage both would be right in 1st round discussions.

 

[Wood_Duck]

If we're getting a 2018 second coming back this way I like it. One would have thought that would be top 25 and potentially in Rozee/Hateley territory

Id do it

 

[jo172]

You must think Rozee and Hately are going to have ordinary years in 2018 because at this stage both would be right in 1st round discussions.

Highly rated South Australians. They all end up at least 5-10 spots lower over the course of their drafting year.

EDIT - come to think of it, Gibbs might be the last bloke who held his value from age 16.5 to 17.5

 

[dogs105]

Actually i like 'Blues Send SOS to Crows'

Get it done SOS

 

[Johnny Rutten]

IMO the Gibbs deal has been weeks in the pipeline and the today's announcement is more to do with an agreed Comms strategy between the clubs that best lands the deal with the Carlton members and supporters

You make a lot of sense, young man.

 

[Danoz]

Highly rated South Australians. They all end up at least 5-10 spots lower over the course of their drafting year.

EDIT - come to think of it, Gibbs might be the last bloke who held his value from age 16.5 to 17.5

Trengove, Toumpas and Day all held their value. It wasn’t until after the draft their value dropped.

 

[Bicks]

12 + 16 with a second round back next year might not be terrible this years draft is very weak

For the umpteenth time this years draft at the top end [10 & 16] is NOT very weak and there will be very decent prospects still on the table at those picks

 

[Drummond]

If we give up 2 first rounders we're hopeless. Dead set muppets.

 

[Bayno82]

16 take it or leave it he would be nice to have but nothing has changed not worth 2 firsts

 

[Jack is Back]

12 + 16 with a second round back next year might not be terrible this years draft is very weak

But Carlton approached us so we should have the upper hand

This is about what I expected.

Carlton "I told you we would get two first round draft picks"

Crows "We have given them pick 12 for Gibbs. In other news we have swapped this years end of first round draft pick for a pick at the start of round 2 in next year's superdraft."

 

[Drummond]

Though Kennedy should. He's a gun.

GWS Kennedy? Contested beast, tough as nails, but slow and poor disposal. Not great. 2nd rounder would be fair compensation.

 

[FAITH]

For the umpteenth time this years draft at the top end [10 & 16] is NOT very weak and there will be very decent prospects still on the table at those picks

Heard WC list manager say today that its a fallacy this years draft is weak, and the top 20 are very strong.
you reckon Fogarty will be avail at 10? and what your thoughts on a fair deal for gibbs?

 

[The Sloane Ranger]

If we give up 2 first rounders we're hopeless. Dead set muppets.

All depends and IMO we need to look at the overall transactions to balance out the net effect

Lever deal is a big tick
Getting 12 back for Charlie would be a big tick
Getting a future 2nd round pick back from Carlton would be a small tick

 

[crowsontv]

10 and 16 for gibbs?
I would expect Reid's resignation on my desk by 5 pm

Sent from my GT-S7275T using Tapatalk

 

[dogs105]

10 and 16 for gibbs?
I would expect Reid's resignation on my desk by 5 pm

Sent from my GT-S7275T using Tapatalk

Why your desk?