Gibbs requests trade to Adelaide

[pjcrows]

Dangerfield + pick 50 was worth picks 9, 28 + Gore.

Gibbs worth pick 13 plus a player like Mackay, CEY or Lyons.

Contracted v uncontracted.

 

[pjcrows]

His complete lack of right side is a liability that's enough to make him "expendable" IMO.

A reason he slipped to Pick 80.

 

[Brighton_Diggins]

No thats actually just bullshit. Given Camerons age I wouldn't straight swap him for Gibbs.

really? hmmm.

 

[Glenno23]

Lol, hartlett has said he won't leave Adelaide... & Gibbs doesn't want to play for port.

Bone is trying to compete with his tiser colleagues for the biggest out of touch idiot.

Plus Port won't have any cap space in the slightest to pay him.....Its AFC or CFC for Gibbs

 

[Elite Crow]

LOL - I wonder what you really think of Mark Stevens - you know, that guy who gave so much pleasant commentary on the Dangerfield deal.

And Jon Ralph who would give us complement after complement when we were trading Dangerfield.

Is that the Mark Stevens and Jon Ralph who said Geelong wouldn't trade? And I can't believe you brought up Ralph, he is known as an idiot up there with Rucci and Bonehead.

 

[Sam_Malone]

Is that the Mark Stevens and Jon Ralph who said Geelong wouldn't trade? And I can't believe you brought up Ralph, he is known as an idiot up there with Rucci and Bonehead.

So we only like them who are nice to the crows?

 

[MRB37]

Is that the Mark Stevens and Jon Ralph who said Geelong wouldn't trade? And I can't believe you brought up Ralph, he is known as an idiot up there with Rucci and Bonehead.

Ralph makes this face like he's concentrating really hard to stop his eyebrows from falling off his face when he talks.

 

[footywedge]

Or you just admit you were wrong and we move on

Don't be daft... More chance of trading Sloane and B Crouch for Gibbs than this happening .

 

[Sam_Malone]

Don't be daft... More chance of trading Sloane and B Crouch for Gibbs than this happening .

More salt.

 

[footywedge]

So we only like them who are nice to the crows?

No. Just the ones with half a brain or who aren't entirely biased. Not a difficult equation.

 

[fairfooty]

Charles is contracted and I doubt he'd want to leave Adelaide and Eddie. Can't see it happening - and I'll be really really pissed if it does. Yet to be convinced that Gibbs is the right 'fit' for us - and certainly not at the expense of Charles.

 

[Jars458]

No.

maybe

 

[Golumless]

Why is it a Carlton tradition or something and can't be worn elsewhere

Probably loses all of his kicking ability.

 

[footywedge]

More salt.

Hahaha no salt here. Never has been. Not like your comments above getting angry and someone criticising your absurd trade!

 

[Anzacpaul]

His complete lack of right side is a liability that's enough to make him "expendable" IMO.

Matt crouch suffers from the same problem

 

[RudyBlue]

Rats pretty happy here. Has a gig down Morphetville helping out with the horses in his down time.

Living the dream?

 

[Sam_Malone]

Hahaha no salt here. Never has been. Not like your comments above getting angry and someone criticising your absurd trade!

 

[Elite Crow]

So we only like them who are nice to the crows?

You just don't get it do you?

After reading my posts for a few years now do you honestly believe I think the club doesn't deserve to be criticised when it's warranted?

As I do on here when I think someone's is full of shit I let them know, it's the same with journos having crappy opinions. It has nothing do with if they are criticising the club, its whether they are talking shit or not.

 

[Jars458]

Matt crouch suffers from the same problem

Not quite as bad does have ability in an emergency

 

[fairfooty]

Cameron was prepared to die trying against Sydney in the semi final. Those players you never let go. Coupled with the fact he is a massive X factor.

He will get to a stage in his career where he only needs 15 or so disposals to turn a game on its head.

Yep. Even contemplating trading Charles is absolute nuts. At the risk of overstating it, he's not a 'fit' to Carlton anyway.

 

[Golumless]

His complete lack of right side is a liability that's enough to make him "expendable" IMO.

Posts like this and how some have seen the idea of trading in Gibbs makes me wonder if our supporters hate the idea of someone who isn't a butcher of the ball.

 

[FR0GGY]

Dangerfield + pick 50 was worth picks 9, 28 + Gore.

Gibbs worth pick 13 plus a player like Mackay, CEY or Lyons.

Don't think so, Patrick was in the top 5 players in the league, 3 years younger and now the best player in the league.
Imo danger we got unders and gibbs for 13 plus a player would be overs.
Gibbs worth no more than 13 but as he is contracted yes, we may have to add something.

 

[footywedge]

You just don't get it do you?

After reading my posts for a few years now do you honestly believe I think the club doesn't deserve to be criticised when it's warranted?

As I do on here when I think someone's is full of shit I let them know, it's the same with journos having crappy opinions. It has nothing do with if they are criticising the club, its whether they are talking shit or not.

He does get it 100% but takes a contrary view in an attempt to start a fight. If you'd agreed with Bone he'd have said it was a stupid article. With respect, I'm surprised more people haven't caught on yet! Hahaha

 

[Elite Crow]

He does get it 100% but takes a contrary view in an attempt to start a fight. If you'd agreed with Bone he'd have said it was a stupid article. With respect, I'm surprised more people haven't caught on yet! Hahaha

Just like Bone when he was on 5AA

 

[Sam_Malone]

You just don't get it do you?

After reading my posts for a few years now do you honestly believe I think the club doesn't deserve to be criticised when it's warranted?

As I do on here when I think someone's is full of shit I let them know, it's the same with journos having crappy opinions. It has nothing do with if they are criticising the club, its whether they are talking shit or not.

And that's my point, when their opinions changes and it become a positive - that 'full of shitness' goes away

Someone is full of shit or they are not. Just like on this board, if someone is full of shit - they are full of shit 100% of the top.

And yes, I maybe full of shit to you but I really don't care.