Its Time For The Axe

[Louie22]

These players should never play seniors again.

OUT

Saddington
Scotland
Carrazzo
French
Wiggins
Bannister

IN

Blackwell
Smith
Bower
Russell
Hartlett
Bryan

Denis Pagan your responsible for this mess, i know we had draft penaties but by going out and getting recycled players has put the club back further behind these players are not good enough but why keep playing them i've had it. I thought we were improving we are worse.

 

[mediumsizered]

These players should never play seniors again.

OUT

Saddington
Scotland
Carrazzo
French
Wiggins
Bannister

IN

Blackwell
Smith
Bower
Russell
Hartlett
Bryan

Denis Pagan your responsible for this mess, i know we had draft penaties but by going out and getting recycled players has put the club back further behind these players are not good enough but why keep playing them i've had it. I thought we were improving we are worse.

You take French out of the side and you will really see some floggings and I think Carazzo still has a lot to offer over the next couple of years at least.

 

[Kooley]

These players should never play seniors again.

OUT

Saddington
Scotland
Carrazzo
French
Wiggins
Bannister

IN

Blackwell
SmithBower
Russell
Hartlett
Bryan

Denis Pagan your responsible for this mess, i know we had draft penaties but by going out and getting recycled players has put the club back further behind these players are not good enough but why keep playing them i've had it. I thought we were improving we are worse.

why do people keep bringing smith's name up for selection. don't you realise he can't be elevated off the rookie list unless we have long term injury and at this stage we only have Hartlett and davies out for 3 and 2 weeks respectively

 

[Napolean]

Denis Pagan your responsible for this mess, i know we had draft penaties but by going out and getting recycled players has put the club back further behind these players are not good enough but why keep playing them i've had it. I thought we were improving we are worse.

So what were we to do when we had the draft penalties? Draft a truckload of players after pick 50? Because if we did this we wouldn't be in the mess we are in now as everyone out there knows players drafted with late picks will be stars.

By all means lay blame at the coach for the list performing below its perceived abilities but accept the weak state of the list at the moment is a combination of both recruiting before Pagan took over and the draft penalties.

 

[stokesy]

Hate to say it, but French was one of our worst yesterday.

He was slow. Couldn't get off the ground. Didn't do the stuff needed. He stood out quite noticeably too.

Hopefully just a bad day like everything else.

 

[blues4flag]

I'd definetly have Carrazzo in our 22.

 

[saint13]

I'd definetly have Carrazzo in our 22.

agreed, he has something to offer IMO

 

[stokesy]

I'd definetly have Carrazzo in our 22.

Carraz should be in the centre square all the time. Not in the backline.

He can get a hard ball, shrug tackles and run.

 

[Jeremias]

for next week.

out: bannister, wiggins, saddington, scotland

in: prendergast, blackwell, russell (a little reluctant to move him around so much), bryan.

emer: bower, longmuir, deluca

when is harts ready? we need him in the side to see if he is any good. but we cant rush him.

 

[HBF]

for next week.

out: bannister, wiggins, saddington, scotland

in: prendergast, blackwell, russell (a little reluctant to move him around so much), bryan.

emer: bower, longmuir, deluca

when is harts ready? we need him in the side to see if he is any good. but we cant rush him.

He's a month off at best. Won't play senior footy until the latter part of the year.

 

[fev22]

These players should never play seniors again.

OUT

Saddington
Scotland
Carrazzo
French
Wiggins
Bannister

IN

Blackwell
Smith
Bower
Russell
Hartlett
Bryan

Denis Pagan your responsible for this mess, i know we had draft penaties but by going out and getting recycled players has put the club back further behind these players are not good enough but why keep playing them i've had it. I thought we were improving we are worse.

scotland and carrazzo!? u crazy man

 

[Kooley]

Hate to say it, but French was one of our worst yesterday.

He was slow. Couldn't get off the ground. Didn't do the stuff needed. He stood out quite noticeably too.

Hopefully just a bad day like everything else.

french has been average since round 1.

 

[BlueWorld]

These players should never play seniors again.

OUT

Saddington
Scotland
Carrazzo
French
Wiggins
Bannister

IN

Blackwell
Smith
Bower
Russell
Hartlett
Bryan

Denis Pagan your responsible for this mess, i know we had draft penaties but by going out and getting recycled players has put the club back further behind these players are not good enough but why keep playing them i've had it. I thought we were improving we are worse.

French? Who's going to ruck for us. Not in peak form atm admittedly but never play again? Bryan played one good game last year & we could not compete in the ruck until French returned from ijnury.

Carrazzo has doen some good defensive jobs. All teams need those types of players.

 

[Kooley]

French? Who's going to ruck for us. Not in peak form atm admittedly but never play again? Bryan played one good game last year & we could not compete in the ruck until French returned from ijnury.

Carrazzo has doen some good defensive jobs. All teams need those types of players.

french has been terrible. but i agree with you he is capable of turning it around and we need him against hille this weekend.