Jenkins v Dixon...who really cares? Some people clearly do

[Sanders]

Relevance to what, not sure what you on about.

No, I don’t imagine you do

 

[Sanders]

This page is the perfect example of Sanders' lunacy. You and Marty are giving personal examples which is backing up medical facts, and yet Sanders still has a counter-argument regarding "anyone can google". Even if your "googling", so what? It's still medical facts for crying out loud!
For the record, the conversation on this page is only for Jenkins' earlier rounds this year with rib injury. No excuses for poor performances prior to the injury and in the latter half of this year!

You seem confused about the meaning of certain words, like “medical fact” for example

 

[Sanders]

Yeah crazy talk.

It's like saying that the only reason David Mackay is still best 22 & 185 not out is because we signed him to a massive long term deal and... ahhh, nevermind.

In my clinical estimation I see no reason why below average intelligence people on a website cannot out-diagnose real medical experts with experience in the field.

I mean they once had heartburn from an over-spiced curry, now they are performing open heart surgery when the Doctor has only prescribed a rennie

 

[marty36]

In my clinical estimation I see no reason why below average intelligence people on a website cannot out-diagnose real medical experts with experience in the field.

I mean they once had heartburn from an over-spiced curry, now they are performing open heart surgery when the Doctor has only prescribed a rennie

Maybe it's the same doctors that said Burton would never walk again and be bound to a wheel chair for the rest of his life


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Maybe it's the same doctors that said Burton would never walk again and be bound to a wheel chair for the rest of his life


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[John Who]

You seem confused about the meaning of certain words, like “medical fact” for example

This will be my final attempt to inform you of the medical facts:
- the doctors who examined Jenkins are in the best position to determine his injury outcome, when he can return to playing again.
- rib injuries hurt, like any other injuries that do damage to the bones/cartilage
- rib injuries usually take longer time to heal than damage to the bones elsewhere in the body, because you're constantly using the ribs (to breathe) and not allowing absolute rest.
- once a player returns on a footy field (after being cleared by a doctor), it usually takes several weeks up to several months to get back to peak fitness/potential, depending on extent of the injury.

The stories by Marty and Ad Victoriam are all in line with the facts. Stop trying to impose your opinions against the facts, it's getting old.

 

[marty36]

This will be my final attempt to inform you of the medical facts:
- the doctors who examined Jenkins are in the best position to determine his injury outcome, when he can return to playing again.
- rib injuries hurt, like any other injuries that do damage to the bones/cartilage
- rib injuries usually take longer time to heal than damage to the bones elsewhere in the body, because you're constantly using the ribs (to breathe) and not allowing absolute rest.
- once a player returns on a footy field (after being cleared by a doctor), it usually takes several weeks up to several months to get back to peak fitness/potential, depending on extent of the injury.

The stories by Marty and Ad Victoriam are all in line with the facts. Stop trying to impose your opinions against the facts, it's getting old.

Couch potatoes dont experience any injuries

I can truly conform I had two pins put into my broken hip and still my broken ribs caused me more pain and my broken arm was a like a scratch compared to my ribs, but thats not the first time Ive broken my Ribs that are a s**t of an injury

 

[Coopers]

In my clinical estimation I see no reason why below average intelligence people on a website cannot out-diagnose real medical experts with experience in the field.

I mean they once had heartburn from an over-spiced curry, now they are performing open heart surgery when the Doctor has only prescribed a rennie

Wow, you just took what was said and ran away with that didn't you.

 

[Bender20]

Maybe it's the same doctors that said Burton would never walk again and be bound to a wheel chair for the rest of his life


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Touche

 

[Sanders]

Wow, you just took what was said and ran away with that didn't you.

Whooosh

 

[spenze]

Sanders needs to calm down, I remember a priest administering last rights on Josh in the change room and when he was being put into the ambulance, they had already pulled the sheet over his head.

To come back from a near death experience, barely cracked rib like he did was testament to his fantastic powers of recovery and should not be looked upon sarcastically or with derision.

 

[Sanders]

Sanders needs to calm down, I remember a priest administering last rights on Josh in the change room and when he was being put into the ambulance, they had already pulled the sheet over his head.

To come back from a near death experience, barely cracked rib like he did was testament to his fantastic powers of recovery and should not be looked upon sarcastically or with derision.

Mea Culpa

 

[Thetrader15]

What round will Fogarty make his debut?

 

[spenze]

What round will Fogarty make his debut?

Given it is us, lets ask which year

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Couch potatoes dont experience any injuries

I can truly conform I had two pins put into my broken hip and still my broken ribs caused me more pain and my broken arm was a like a scratch compared to my ribs, but thats not the first time Ive broken my Ribs that are a s**t of an injury

Then another explanation obviously is ....

 

[marty36]

Then another explanation obviously is ....

Nah I didn't bounce at 60 kmh


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[ad victoriam]

Nah I didn't bounce at 60 kmh


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

I have a similar weakness as well not a 60km but my problem was I don't bounce that well. from heights.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I have a similar weakness as well not a 60km but my problem was I don't bounce that well. from heights.

Then stay on the ground

 

[CrowsB4hoes]

I’m willing to concede that Ports most important forward could be considered a better player than our 5th most important forward

It is Christmas after all

 

[1970crow]

Because Dear hasn’t shown enough at SANFL level for a call up. I would have thought that was obvious.

I don't know why Dear even gets mentioned. He's a KPD, JJ's role would surely be replaced by a flanker. Isn't that their argument?

 

[LC40]

I think watts will surprise people.

In watt way?

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

In watt way?

Watts will be the same frustrating player that he was at Melbourne.

For those frustrated with JJ at times, it could be much worse with Watts or Motlop or McKenzie or Thomas... The awesome recruits.

 

[douglyzia]

Dixon could well be the stupidest key forward, maybe even stupidest player, in the AFL.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Dixon could well be the stupidest key forward, maybe even stupidest player, in the AFL.

Reckon Lindsay Thomas has him covered.

 

[Bearded Clam]

How many has Dixon kicked so far this year?..