Jordan Lewis vs Nathan Jones

[Benny78]

Been tossing and turning in bed the past hour unable to make up my mind. Premierships and accolades aside who do you think is the better player?

 

[HolyWars]

Is?
Probably Jones.

Was?
Definitely Lewis.

 

[MadMaxx]

Lewis Best and Fairest in a premiership year.

Pretty good, when you consider the guns that were around him in that 2014 team (Frankin was still an HFC too)


Jones is a damn good player as well of course. A fine career, and rightfully held his head high, even when his teammates needed to hand thiers in shame a few years ago.

 

[MinerBoy]

Lewis Best and Fairest in a premiership year.

Pretty good, when you consider the guns that were around him in that 2014 team (Frankin was still an HFC too)


Jones is a damn good player as well of course. A fine career, and rightfully held his head high, even when his teammates needed to hand thiers in shame a few years ago.

Franklin kicked 4 goals against us in the 2014 GF

 

[00Stinger]

Lewis Best and Fairest in a premiership year.

Pretty good, when you consider the guns that were around him in that 2014 team (Frankin was still an HFC too)


Jones is a damn good player as well of course. A fine career, and rightfully held his head high, even when his teammates needed to hand thiers in shame a few years ago.

I remember having a discussion with a Hawthorn supporting friend 5-6 years ago. We agreed that the two were very comparable players just one was in a bloody good team where he could showcase his skills and the other was in a piss poor team where he was smashed from pillar to post.

 

[blitzer]

Pretty even contest but I'd give a slight nod to Lewis because of his performances in big games. It may be a bit unfair because Jones didn't get the same opportunities but that's probably just the way it is.

 

[MadMaxx]

Franklin kicked 4 goals against us in the 2014 GF

You have a salient point ;-)

At least he played..

 

[MadMaxx]

I remember having a discussion with a Hawthorn supporting friend 5-6 years ago. We agreed that the two were very comparable players just one was in a bloody good team where he could showcase his skills and the other was in a piss poor team where he was smashed from pillar to post.

Agreed. The Poll is a valid comparison, unlike a lot of them.

Now where was that Cloke is better than Franklin Poll... ? ;-)