Judd or Cousins

[Marc Shmurf 3]

Simple, which one would you take.

Forget the issues Cousins has had in the past year.

 

[DeeMan27]

You cant really just cast aside all the controversy Cousin's has created this year. WHy not make the thread last year?

 

[smiddaz123]

Without the drug issues I'd take cousins.

With the drug issues I'd take Judd.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

You mean a 24 year-old vs. a 29 year-old?

Gee, let me nut that one out a while longer...

 

[huzy oner]

cousins is no chance he is just unreliable and not trustworthy then judd is a leader of the game and an amazing talent.

 

[Kerrby]

cousins is no chance he is just unreliable and not trustworthy then judd is a leader of the game and an amazing talent.

What are you,? He said forget about the issues recently.

 

[DeeMan27]

cousins is no chance he is just unreliable and not trustworthy then judd is a leader of the game and an amazing talent.

Cousins had an unblemished record 2 years ago. Unreliable now maybe..

definately

 

[blue_boys5]

I would take chris judd.... although ben cousins is a renowned hard runner and high possession winner i just feel that it is judds acceleration that sets him apart from cousins and the other midfielders.

 

[Heisenberg_]

lol at how insecure you are.
Of course most would take Judd, a bit younger.
Both great players, but at their peak Cousins>Judd.
Eagles will miss Cousins more then Judd without a doubt

 

[Kouta_legend]

Judd 2004 >>>>> Cousins 2005

For achievements under the age of 24, judd is miles ahead

 

[parrot]

Cousins had an unblemished record 2 years ago...

This behaviour has been going on for like 6 years though. And covered up by the Weagleland administrators.

 

[DeeMan27]

This behaviour has been going on for like 6 years though. And covered up by the Weagleland administrators.

Nothing was ever made official tho. Instead of covering it up they should have done somehting about it. well done WCE

 

[BABYBOMBERS2007]

Cousins is a better player. Judd just receives the ball. Cousins goes and gets it.

 

[DeeMan27]

Cousins is a better player. Judd just receives the ball. Cousins goes and gets it.

Are you saying Judd is an outside player?

 

[blue_boys5]

Cousins is a better player. Judd just receives the ball. Cousins goes and gets it.

Judd has lead the eagles in hard ball gets a few times in his career so i dont no where you got receiver from.

 

[blues4flag]

I've always rated Cousins as the best mid in the comp and my favourite player outside Carlton (strictly on field). A 22 yo Judd vs a 22 year old Cousins, ignoring off-field issues, I'd choose Cousins. His ability to dig down deep when his team needs him is absolutely phenomenal.

 

[Marc Shmurf 3]

I've always rated Cousins as the best mid in the comp and my favourite player outside Carlton (strictly on field). A 22 yo Judd vs a 22 year old Cousins, ignoring off-field issues, I'd choose Cousins. His ability to dig down deep when his team needs him is absolutely phenomenal.

But a 22y/o Judd had accomplished more than a 22y/o Cousins. Is thst the point your making or if they were both 22???

Look im not saying that Cousins isnt a star, i appreciate his ability to gut run like the rest of you. I just dont think that he has had the capability as Judd has to turn a game. When something is needed Judd has seemed to break the line, or kick a goal or two in quick succession and get the team going.

Cousins on the other hand was/is a work horse that will get his 30 touches and run out a game, but wouldnt change the momentum of the game as much as Judd has.

 

[DeeMan27]

But a 22y/o Judd had accomplished more than a 22y/o Cousins. Is thst the point your making or if they were both 22???

Look im not saying that Cousins isnt a star, i appreciate his ability to gut run like the rest of you. I just dont think that he has had the capability as Judd has to turn a game. When something is needed Judd has seemed to break the line, or kick a goal or two in quick succession and get the team going.

Cousins on the other hand was/is a work horse that will get his 30 touches and run out a game, but wouldnt change the momentum of the game as much as Judd has.

yes, agree with that.
While both are excellent players Judd is a matchwinner and has the ability to turn a match at his wim. (if uninjured that is)

 

[marcmurphy3]

lol at how insecure you are.
Of course most would take Judd, a bit younger.
Both great players, but at their peak Cousins>Judd.
Eagles will miss Cousins more then Judd without a doubt

That's garbage. Judd at his best > Cousins at his best and everyone would have agreed before Judd came to the Blues.

 

[DeeMan27]

Judd has more influence on a game

 

[Heisenberg_]

But a 22y/o Judd had accomplished more than a 22y/o Cousins. Is thst the point your making or if they were both 22???

Look im not saying that Cousins isnt a star, i appreciate his ability to gut run like the rest of you. I just dont think that he has had the capability as Judd has to turn a game. When something is needed Judd has seemed to break the line, or kick a goal or two in quick succession and get the team going.

Cousins on the other hand was/is a work horse that will get his 30 touches and run out a game, but wouldnt change the momentum of the game as much as Judd has.

get a copy of the 2006 prelim final WC and Adelaide.
Cousins turned that match in WC favour

 

[Heisenberg_]

That's garbage. Judd at his best > Cousins at his best and everyone would have agreed before Judd came to the Blues.

Wrong plenty thought Cousins was better, as well as heaps of WC fans who watched them both a lot more then the rest of us

 

[Marc Shmurf 3]

get a copy of the 2006 prelim final WC and Adelaide.
Cousins turned that match in WC favour

1 game???

Ok then

Enjoy Tambling

 

[Heisenberg_]

1 game???

Ok then

Enjoy Tambling

You're a dead set idot. 1 of many, and yeah its a pretty important game it would be fair to suggest
Are you capable of making a reasonable, intelligent post?

Pretty hard i gues when you only type with one hand because you're constantly jacking off to Juddy

 

[DeeMan27]

You're a dead set idot. 1 of many, and yeah its a pretty important game it would be fair to suggest
Are you capable of making a reasonable, intelligent post?

Pretty hard i gues when you only type with one hand because you're constantly jacking off to Juddy

LOL