Kade Simpson v Clinton Young v Scott Pendlebury

[Woewodin#1]

All great young players, all skilful left footers but who is the better of the bunch.

 

[marcmurphy3]

Pendlebury > Simpson > Young

 

[HBK619]

Pendlebury>>>>>>>>Simpson>>>>>>>>>>>Shit>>>>Young.

 

[DonMania#5]

Obviously Pendlebury is way better than the rest, why start this poll for when you know Pendlebury will win.

 

[trunks]

Not a bad pick up by Hawthorn. Young was a rookie elevation

 

[HBK619]

Obviously Pendlebury is way better than the rest, why start this poll for when you know Pendlebury will win.

Because he is a Collingwood supporter. Gotta do something to compensate for todays loss.

DUHHHHH!

What about this poll:
Pendlebury Vs Judd???

Who would win that one.

 

[blues4flag]

Stupid poll, Pendles definitely. Out of the other two, Kade well ahead of Young.

 

[lids2004roar]

I think Young is being underrated by a fair margin even if he isn't the best of these 3.

 

[Woewodin#1]

FFS, I thought I was the only unbias Collingwood supporter on BF. I actually think Kade Simpson & Clinton Young will be future leaders of there club for now Pendlebury is ahead yes but you can't tell the future for all we know Pendlebury could end up being the most over hyped hack which I hope not.

 

[blues4flag]

FFS, I thought I was the only unbias Collingwood supporter on BF. I actually think Kade Simpson & Clinton Young will be future leaders of there club for now Pendlebury is ahead yes but you can't tell the future for all we know Pendlebury could end up being the most over hyped hack which I hope not.

Pendles is also 19 - Young is 21 and Simpson is 23. While the other two are good to very good players, Pendles has elite potential, which the other two don't.

 

[dipper86]

Pendlebury>>>>>>>>Simpson>>>>>>>>>>>Shit>>>>Young.

Shit >>>>>>>>>Young>>>>>>>>Richmond FC. The End.

 

[HBK619]

Shit >>>>>>>>>Young>>>>>>>>Richmond FC. The End.

At least you agree Young is worse than Shit.

 

[BedlamHawk]

At least you agree Young is worse than Shit.

At least you admit that Richmond Football Club is worse than shit

 

[DapperDon]

At least you admit that Richmond Football Club is worse than shit

good to see you both enjoy shit above your players and club

 

[Drummond]

All great young players, all skilful left footers but who is the better of the bunch.

Worst poll ever. Pendlebury was what, pick 5? Young was a rookie draft selection.

I wonder who will win!

 

[Cynic]

Pendelbury > Young > Simpson

 

[dipper86]

good to see you both enjoy shit above your players and club

don't act as if , Shit >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Bolton, Bradley. You know it to be true.

The only solace we can take away from this is

Shit >>>>>>>>>> Richmond FC.

 

[davey_magik]

Simpson.
Though he is four years older then Pendlebury, so you would think Pendlebury will become a better player.
Young has been great for a rookie pickup, I'd go as far as saying he is the best kick out of the three.

 

[Silvagnis]

Pendlebury can play forward and shown more poise than Simmo at the same age so he gets my vote. But they're closer than the poll shows and terrific young players for their clubs.

But they're no Gibbs and Murphy.

Simmo provides more run out of the backline than Pendlebury, is a brave player despite being known as Slimmo and has a terrific left foot which he unleashes on the run. Kade has stepped up this year because he needed to kick more goals and he's delivered that in spades with brilliant long bombs this year.

He'll captain Carlton this week.

Young a distant third.

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Worst poll ever. Pendlebury was what, pick 5? Young was a rookie draft selection.

I wonder who will win!

Care to start a Bryce Gibbs vs. Brent Macaffer poll?

 

[james Dean]

Care to start a Bryce Gibbs vs. Brent Macaffer poll?

Who?

 

[HBK619]

Who?

Exactly!

 

[CrazyQ]

Kade is 4 years older than Scott.

Kade is NOT a youngster.

 

[CrazyQ]

Pendlebury can play forward and shown more poise than Simmo at the same age so he gets my vote. But they're closer than the poll shows and terrific young players for their clubs.

But they're no Gibbs and Murphy.

Simmo provides more run out of the backline than Pendlebury, is a brave player despite being known as Slimmo and has a terrific left foot which he unleashes on the run. Kade has stepped up this year because he needed to kick more goals and he's delivered that in spades with brilliant long bombs this year.

He'll captain Carlton this week.

Young a distant third.

He's averaging 17 possies and not even a goal a game.

"Delivering in spades"?

Yeah sure.

 

[Jeremias]

He's averaging 17 possies and not even a goal a game.

"Delivering in spades"?

Yeah sure.

Poor CrazyQ...his favourite player to bag is performing very well (Walker) so he needs to try and find someone else to bag.