Kerr Vs Bartel

[carmi99]

Who is the better player?

 

[Glassjaw]

Kerr is marginally better, but I'd rather Bartel at Geelong.

 

[tonywce23]

I voted for Kerr, only on the basis that he has been good/great for more than one season. Having said that, I rate Bartel very highly and would love to have him at West Coast

 

[carmi99]

Kerr for mine....

The guy is a superstar, Bartel is a gun but Kerr is comfortably better.

 

[HFF]

Kerr is marginally better, but I'd rather Bartel at Geelong.

As good as Bartel is and i do rate him, 'marginally' is being far too generous.

More along the lines of 'comfortably' better.

 

[EB&W Pieman]

I love Jimmy, but I would take Kerr in a heartbeat. Not even close.

 

[CF]

Kerr has been an elite midfielder for several years now while Bartel has had one good year at that level. At the moment Kerr is easily in front but if Bartel backs up 2008 with another excellent year (top 5 in the Brownlow) then I would say the gap is closing.

 

[carmi99]

As good as Bartel is and i do rate him, 'marginally' is being far too generous.

More along the lines of 'comfortably' better.

Yeah, and no guessing who he voted for.....

At the end of the poll we will have to get the admin to tell us what % of Bartels votes were from Geelong supporters, likewise for Kerr..

 

[Kooley]

kerr easily

 

[Bomber32]

Kerr for mine.

 

[Lynch takes a mark]

Kerr is the better player but I would much rather have Jimmy at the club

 

[carmi99]

15 votes for Bartel yet not one person has posted a comment in this thread in favour of him. Who thinks that all the votes for Bartel are from Geelong supporters?

 

[sabby]

Even tho Bartel has won a brownlow I still rate Kerr higher although his off field discretions makes him less appealing

 

[boulos]

I think "Kerr comfortably" describes it perfectly.

 

[Kochie 16]

Kerr by a fair margin, the votes confirm my theory!

 

[Whiskers]

let me be the 1st

JIMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMY by a whisker, he is a team man, with fantastic marking ability, great wet weather player. Can adapt to anything.

Oh but im a cats fan so no one is listening.

 

[carmi99]

let me be the 1st

JIMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMY by a whisker, he is a team man, with fantastic marking ability, great wet weather player. Can adapt to anything.

Oh but im a cats fan so no one is listening.

On the contrary, i admire the fact that you voiced your opinion.

It's a shame the other 17 Cats supporters that voted for Jummy didn't do the same.

 

[tiger trooper]

kerr by an absolute country mile.

best midfielder in the comp IMO. Both extrfemely good players but kerr just has that thing about him, the X factor. Also every time he gets the ball he uses it brilliantly and has the ability to hurt you in a game more then bartel IMO

 

[Kochie 16]

Oh look at that

Kerr 41
Bartel 18

Seems like the majority of people know their footy!

 

[Isandula]

Kerr easily but that's not saying Bartel isn't any good, hes definitely way up there as the 3rd/4th best midfielder in the comp.

 

[carmi99]

Oh look at that

Kerr 41
Bartel 18

Seems like the majority of people know their footy!

Wait till that Seethus bloke sees this thread, the poor bugger will probably neck himself!

 

[Kochie 16]

Wait till that Seethus bloke sees this thread, the poor bugger will probably neck himself!

LOL!

 

[Whiskers]

Oh look at that

Kerr 41
Bartel 18

Seems like the majority of people know their footy!

Or not.

U take a poll at start of 2007. Will Geelong be this years premiers? Yes or No? Majority say no, most are wrong.

Not sayin im right but my guess is Jimmy has more better years than kerr coming up. Better player in 07 and shall continue.

 

[Glassjaw]

Yeah, and no guessing who he voted for.....

I voted for Kerr, because as I stated I believe him to be better.

I'm not going to vote for Jimmy just because I'm a Geelong supporter.

 

[PendlePie]

Kerr > Bartel

Kerr has been good for several years, Bartel has a fair way to go to catch him

I have Kerr 2nd and Bartel 4th in the comp