Live comments regarding the PSD

[strengthwithin]

West Australian bias much? Sam Jacobs and Shane Mumford say hi!

A combined 9 AA's say hi

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Seriously stupid by Essenon and that is being nice. Gartlett was a perfect choice and we take Steinberg. I don't care if he is 'promised' a spot, you take the more talented player!

 

[blueiris]

Can someone, please explaine how Ben Hudson can be a rookied did they change the rule I thought Afl players over 30 couldn't be rookie listed

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Can someone, please explaine how Ben Hudson can be a rookied did they change the rule I thought Afl players over 30 couldn't be rookie listed

Mature age rookie- came in either last year or the year before.

 

[Slattery_20]

Can someone, please explaine how Ben Hudson can be a rookied did they change the rule I thought Afl players over 30 couldn't be rookie listed

That rule went, a long time ago.
btw, you do know he already got rookied once, over 30? (like... say... last year... for... say... your club?)

 

[Mego Red]

Can all we all acknowledge there are issues with Garlett that the AFL industry know but the public doesn't?

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

BT just blew his load about being able to call JACK FROST, THE WINTER SPECIALIST, OH BOY WOWWEE

Pity Frost can only perform real early in the Morning.

 

[Theo X]

u can put sam jacobs in this catagory

And Mark Jamar

 

[Theo X]

Mumford, Grima, Pyke, Jacobs, Crameri (if he counts due to height), Casboult, Podsiadly, Giles.

Wouldn't put Casboult in the company of those others yet

 

[dlanod]

That rule went, a long time ago.
btw, you do know he already got rookied once, over 30? (like... say... last year... for... say... your club?)

He was never a rookie for Brisbane. They traded him off the Bulldogs for a pick in the 70s...

 

[Righteo]

Wouldn't put Casboult in the company of those others yet

Neither, seems like he is a good chance to at least "make it" though. Still though it's an impressive group of players, don't think we'll see Steel back in this thread. Think his attemptred dig at our drafting backfired somewhat.

 

[Silvagnis]

Wouldn't put Casboult in the company of those others yet

Who rates the 29 year old Pyke?

Even Aaron Keating has a premiership medal.

Casboult would get a game ahead of Pyke at Carlton.

 

[Theo X]

Who rates the 29 year old Pyke?

Even Aaron Keating has a premiership medal.

Casboult would get a game ahead of Pyke at Carlton.

That's likely true, but only because Pyke's mainly a ruck (although he's probably a better kick at goal than Casboult)

 

[Carbine Chaos]

Jamie Bennell.

Baha

Jesse Crichton.

Twice.

Baha.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Who rates the 29 year old Pyke?

Even Aaron Keating has a premiership medal.

Casboult would get a game ahead of Pyke at Carlton.

When Casbolt plays as good a game as Pyke did in the GF...come back. Until then Pyke is MUCH better!

 

[sTeeL]

Some of us have jobs kiddie.

That list is full of potatoes. Half barely make the cut as stop gap KPP. In fact only Mumford can be considered great. You list stop gaps and 30 year olds as reasons? Sure

 

[sTeeL]

Jamar was 2001 draft. Podsiadley should have been like 2001 as well. Grima barely makes KPP. Just because North has no proper defensive options he doesn't play medium. Casboult? Pyk? Joking right calling these actual KPP successes?

 

[Mego Red]

What is Pyk?

 

[DREAM TEAM BUFF]

What is Pyk?

I think they mean Pyke

 

[yaco55]

Two morals to the draft

- ( read Garlett and his ilk ) is to party,when you are in the AFL system - Not before you enter the system.
- Clubs spend $20m on their footy department but dont have the resources/aptitiude to help wayward, young talents. This is an indictment on AFL clubs.

 

[MarkJohnson#1]

Jamar was 2001 draft. Podsiadley should have been like 2001 as well. Grima barely makes KPP. Just because North has no proper defensive options he doesn't play medium. Casboult? Pyk? Joking right calling these actual KPP successes?

Just admit it mate, he got ya...

 

[Righteo]

Did you call me "kiddie" bud?

 

[Asgardian]

Haha Kane Mitchell - sucks to be you Port

Why?

 

[MarcMaverick]

A little PO that we did not get Hannath. Oh Well. Such is life,eh?

 

[tigs2010]

A little PO that we did not get Hannath. Oh Well. Such is life,eh?

I guess so...