Opinion Matthew Nicks: Adelaide's Coach (Part 2) - Full Support of the Board

Is Matthew Nicks the right coach for Adelaide?

  • Firmly yes (I love what I'm seeing)

  • Leaning yes

  • Can't decide either way

  • Leaning no (but don't sack him yet)

  • Firmly no (he should be sacked)


Results are only viewable after voting.

Remove this Banner Ad

I think the club has to sack Nicks as of now. The players are now having their say and clearly they don't respect Nicks as a coach.

Either;
1. Nicks message is getting across to the playing group and they are playing exactly how he wants
or
2. Nicks message has not gotten through and the players aren't listening.

Either way its over. There is no coming back from this. Its an untenable situation. Rip the bandaid off and let Burns take the reigns for the rest of the season and bring in Nankervis, Dowling, Bond, Gollant, Curtin, Edwards etc and Walker, Smith, Sloane, Sholl, Murphy, McHenry should all be removed from the best 22 permanently.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

The question is: should we * him off mid-season and continue with a caretaker coach, or * him off at season's end? Are we going to miss out on any good coaches if we go too late?
Mid season. Must be done. Pull the bandaid off.
 
Who should be our next coach? Nicks wont last the season. Anyone think he honestly will? By the time we play north we will be winless. Lose and hes gone.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

The question is: should we * him off mid-season and continue with a caretaker coach, or * him off at season's end? Are we going to miss out on any good coaches if we go too late?
You are clutching at straws. He will be given next year and if it's the same s**t as this for the 1st half of the season, that's when he will be sacked with a year and a bit left on his contract.
 
You are clutching at straws. He will be given next year and if it's the same s**t as this for the 1st half of the season, that's when he will be sacked with a year and a bit left on his contract.
No coach survives bottom bottom 4 5 years into a rebuild. Even the inept crows will act.
 
You just gotta play our boys into record breaking form now Matty.
Just like you do with opposition players.
 
Honestly the amount of times we completely miss targets, it's no wonder we can't score. Skills are an absolute joke, even when under no direct pressure
Hinge smith milera dawson laird rachele ROB pedlar none of these guys can hit a barn. And when it starts happening our response is to slow play up and look for easy targets. Which makes going forward harder because 15 opposition players are in front of them all of a sudden
 
You are clutching at straws. He will be given next year and if it's the same s**t as this for the 1st half of the season, that's when he will be sacked with a year and a bit left on his contract.
Absolutely. Surely we’re not so flush as a club that we can afford to sack a coach with close to three years to run on his contract… which again, makes the decision to re-sign him so baffling.

We’re stuck with him for 18 more months you’d guess… but if he does go early, then everyone involved in his re-signing also has to go… and can anyone honestly see that happening.
 
Back
Top