Mcphee or Clement?

[trueblue_91]

Mcphee or Clement in your backline

 

[SIR SAINT HOTDOG]

mcphee for dream. But clement is a better defender

 

[Drummond]

Is this a joke?

Clement easily.

 

[Cassius_Clay]

McPhee is a poor mans Clement.

 

[Jeremias]

Clement. Easily.

 

[Smokin_Joe]

Completely different defenders...clement better body on body and better kick...mcphee marks and spoils better in the air and is more attacking and kicks more goals. Clement plays on the Full Back line and McPhee on the half back line.

Dont see how u can compare them.

 

[Thrawn]

Clement beats his man more often, and I find he's the more damaging player.

One of the few players I respect from Collingwood. I rate him highly enough that if he was playing on Fevola he would restrict him to under four goals at least.

 

[Coin_Toss]

Last time this same comparison was posted in the Polls Board Clement won comprehensively. Things don't change I see.

 

[hahaha]

From an Essendon perspective....

Clement.

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Completely different defenders...clement better body on body and better kick...mcphee marks and spoils better in the air and is more attacking and kicks more goals. Clement plays on the Full Back line and McPhee on the half back line.

Dont see how u can compare them.

Actually, I think they're very, very, very similar players.

I would say that McPhee is the most like Clement of any defender in the league in terms of style, opponent, size and ability.

However, he simply trails him in almost every area. Not by a lot, but when you are essentially trailing someone in every area, it's hard to be a better player overall.

 

[jonesy86]

freo have a real eye for talent

 

[Bell Ringer]

freo have a real eye for talent

Ahahahahahahahaha

 

[doppleganger]

Completely different defenders...clement better body on body and better kick...mcphee marks and spoils better in the air and is more attacking and kicks more goals. Clement plays on the Full Back line and McPhee on the half back line.

Dont see how u can compare them.

the only area that mcphee may get the nod over clement could be his tank, ie ability to play midfield

but in every other facet clement would shade mcphee, no shame in that tho!

pretty fair comparison to clement really

 

[dave_27]

Clement of course but Mcphee is only 23, plenty of up side their.

 

[wazzabp]

Clement for me, just as tight as they come on a tall or small.
I'm happy with McPhees efforts though so far and McPhees got time on his hands to get to that sort of class.

 

[windyhill]

Clement , a more stay at home defender, while McPhee actually takes a risk and has a crack. Clement is more worried about the red ink.

 

[MrAaron]

Does McPhee have a Premiership Medal though ? lol

 

[MrAaron]

um er scrub the last post lol

 

[jnash196]

Fremantle coaches think they r both bad.

 

[Neutral_observer]

2 of the worst All Australians of the modern era

 

[MrSquashed]

Should clement v fletcher

in which case u take fletcher

 

[HeLMie]

McPhee is a poor mans Clement.

McPhee is a poor mans Jason Cloke.

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

2 of the worst All Australians of the modern era

Uh... I know this has been said a lot, but you may want to have yourself tested for lead poisoning and/or brain tumours.

 

[Neutral_observer]

Uh... I know this has been said a lot, but you may want to have yourself tested for lead poisoning and/or brain tumours.

COming from a man with this in his signature....

Collingwood isn't a team on the rise.

Collingwood is a team that has risen.