NCFL Season 2021

[Trent the flight Steward]

The scores are tied, the shot is after the siren, and the video shows the player runs in a straight line to the goals. That's pretty clear. For the umpire who wasn't even the closest umpire to come in and over rule the decision to say that it's no score, has altered the result on purpose. This is the umpires first game umpiring Donald after they had complained about him previously, it's a mess.

How can you say it was clearly a decision by the ump to fix the game? What would he have to gain by making that decision? He would have known the game was being videod and that by making that decision would have come under scrutiny. To say he is a cheat is pretty strong.

 

[Trent the flight Steward]

I see the league has somehow agreed with the ump and the decision stands, what a disaster, why would these guys travel down from Melbourne each week to play ncfl footy, the inference that this would open a can of worms in regards to umpires decision is garbage, it's no different to the AFL changing the result in the saints dockers game a few years, how about the league shows it has a backbone

 

[fatkidinthepocket]

I see the league has somehow agreed with the ump and the decision stands, what a disaster, why would these guys travel down from Melbourne each week to play ncfl footy, the inference that this would open a can of worms in regards to umpires decision is garbage, it's no different to the AFL changing the result in the saints dockers game a few years, how about the league shows it has a backbone
[/QUOte Hope you were watching Melb. v Hawks 3 quarter time. Very similar.

 

[Trent the flight Steward]

Goss has being a proven goal kicker for a number of years, with you would imagine the same run up and technique, I wonder how many times an umpire has called play on. I'd imagine 0. Furthermore he kicked 4 on the day, did the umpire call any of those play on? For the league to pretend it didn't happen is garbage, I note Goss didn't play on the weekend, any reason why?

 

[Iwishicouldplay4themoney]

Goss has being a proven goal kicker for a number of years, with you would imagine the same run up and technique, I wonder how many times an umpire has called play on. I'd imagine 0. Furthermore he kicked 4 on the day, did the umpire call any of those play on? For the league to pretend it didn't happen is garbage, I note Goss didn't play on the weekend, any reason why?

He did his hammy when he played on.

 

[fatkidinthepocket]

Goss has being a proven goal kicker for a number of years, with you would imagine the same run up and technique, I wonder how many times an umpire has called play on. I'd imagine 0. Furthermore he kicked 4 on the day, did the umpire call any of those play on? For the league to pretend it didn't happen is garbage, I note Goss didn't play on the weekend, any reason why?

And Luke Bruest hasnt either until yesterday. The rule says the kicker Must kick OVER the man on the mark. Goss was told twice by the umpire who called play on he had to do this. Goal umpire initially couldnt see Goss because he was in line with the player on the mark as he ran in to kick he somehow appeared to the left of the bloke on the mark.Grainy video from side on doesnt show that. Umpire was correct. MOVE ON

 

[Trent the flight Steward]

He clearly kicked over the mark, your obviously mates with the umpys or a Wedderburn or possibly krong Vale native,
Worst decision I've ever seen in 30 years of watching footy by far, and I've got no allegiances with Donald, I'm just like the many thousand that have seen the footage and can't believe what they saw.

Hopefully that guy is never allowed to umpire again, even a club umpire from Wedderburn would not have called that play on. Let's hope that a club in the league doesn't miss out on finals from it

And Luke Bruest hasnt either until yesterday. The rule says the kicker Must kick OVER the man on the mark. Goss was told twice by the umpire who called play on he had to do this. Goal umpire initially couldnt see Goss because he was in line with the player on the mark as he ran in to kick he somehow appeared to the left of the bloke on the mark.Grainy video from side on doesnt show that. Umpire was correct. MOVE ON

 

[fatkidinthepocket]

He clearly kicked over the mark, your obviously mates with the umpys or a Wedderburn or possibly krong Vale native,
Worst decision I've ever seen in 30 years of watching footy by far, and I've got no allegiances with Donald, I'm just like the many thousand that have seen the footage and can't believe what they saw.

Hopefully that guy is never allowed to umpire again, even a club umpire from Wedderburn would not have called that play on. Let's hope that a club in the league doesn't miss out on finals from it

Wrong on all accounts again.

 

[Chadwiko]

Atrocious decision and no serious football player, coach, or fan would think that was play on unless they were biased.

 

[Truck]

Atrocious decision and no serious football player, coach, or fan would think that was play on unless they were biased.

Move on, Donald have.

 

[Chadwiko]

There's one of the biased people now ^

 

[Trent the flight Steward]

Not sure they had much choice truck, there only Avenue was the supreme Court, which is extreme for country footy, why couldn't the league overturn it?

Move on, Donald have.

 

[Truck]

There's one of the biased people now ^

Got pantsed by Donald last week and spoke to a few of their blokes. Sure they were disappointed but it is what it is.

Maybe you could grab a whilst and give it a go, happy to offer you my best advice as you go.

 

[Made4September]

Got pantsed by Donald last week and spoke to a few of their blokes. Sure they were disappointed but it is what it is.

Maybe you could grab a whilst and give it a go, happy afford you some of my best advice as you go.

I believe there are still a couple of spots up for grabs with the whistle in your reserves game tomorrow

 

[Iwishicouldplay4themoney]

Is it true, that Charlton has rejected the offer to stand or sit in a pavilion and watch a game of football. Must like the outdoors.

 

[ROOTA#6]

Is it true, that Charlton has rejected the offer to stand or sit in a pavilion and watch a game of football. Must like the outdoors.

what?

 

[Made4September]

what?

I believe he is asking whether Charlton voted no for potential merger with the Demons

 

[ROOTA#6]

I believe he is asking whether Charlton voted no for potential merger with the Demons

that would be pretty ordinary considering they went to a number of players stating that they need to come home as this is their last year as a stand alone club

 

[Iwishicouldplay4themoney]

that would be pretty ordinary considering they went to a number of players stating that they need to come home as this is their last year as a stand alone club

Correct and wyche kids play at charlton already.

 

[Trent the flight Steward]

Don't think it's dead and buried yet, they needed 75% of members to vote yes. You'd imagine a few of the older die hards would vote no, great by wyche, getting on the front foot to merge and I reckon it will still happen by the end of the year

Correct and wyche kids play at charlton already.

 

[Truck]

yeah It’s a big decision and for a lot of members it will seem out of the blue, and will feel they don’t need to “now”.
Its not about where Joel Turner is going to finish his career, but where his young fella is going to start his career.

 

[ROOTA#6]

 

[Truck]

What’s the thoughts on the proposed games for 2 points where impacted melb players are involved??
I’m not sure if they are aware but we don’t have 10 blokes missing out each week that can now simply get a game.
Then again, June - July is has always been the best time to talk blokes into playing footy. The middle of winter!

 

[Made4September]

What’s the thoughts on the proposed games for 2 points where impacted melb players are involved??
I’m not sure if they are aware but we don’t have 10 blokes missing out each week that can now simply get a game.
Then again, June - July is has always been the best time to talk blokes into playing footy. The middle of winter!

Clearly proposed by someone safe in finals.

 

[ROOTA#6]

What’s the thoughts on the proposed games for 2 points where impacted melb players are involved??
I’m not sure if they are aware but we don’t have 10 blokes missing out each week that can now simply get a game.
Then again, June - July is has always been the best time to talk blokes into playing footy. The middle of winter!

Its one of the more ridiculous things I’ve heard. I know everyone is wanting to get back playing but severely compromising the competition isn’t the way