Player or Dud 2

[_RT_]

Following on from the first poll I thought I would put up another player. This one is a hff/midfielder and again I will give his first 3 years averages:

First Year:
20 games 6.8 possies 2.5 marks 1.4 goals
Second Year
21 games 7.4 possies 2.5 marks 1.8 goals
Third Year
21 games 11 possies 4 marks 1.4 goals

Again same question is he a player or dud?

 

[parrot]

Again I voted for "Player" instead of Tambling.

 

[Simon_Nesbit]

Following on from the first poll I thought I would put up another player. This one is a hff/midfielder and again I will give his first 3 years averages:

First Year:
20 games 6.8 possies 2.5 marks 1.4 goals
Second Year
21 games 7.4 possies 2.5 marks 1.8 goals
Third Year
21 games 11 possies 4 marks 1.4 goals

Again same question is he a player or dud?

Hmm.. played every game from when drafted, but relatively low stats. Forward Pocket/Flanker, who shows decent goal sense, and reasonable marking.

I'm saying player. Even with low possession tallies, takes marks, kicks goals, and plays most games in a season, so is obviously contributing.

 

[wce4premiership]

Possies aren't too good for that position but the goals average pushed him up to player.

 

[_RT_]

This seems to have been an easy one for people to vote on considering that many of you voted for him as a player. The player in this poll was Brad Green and it would be fair to say he has continued on to become a very good player at AFL level.

Thanks for particpating