Ranking the current brothers.

[Lingsface]

Who are the top 5 brothers playing in the AFL at the moment.
I will have a try and I’m sure I’ll miss some.

1- Brayshaw brothers
2- Daicos
3-Guthrie
4- Mckay
5- Curnow

Considered for the 5- Mcartin McGovern

 

[Kipz]

Daicos
McLachlan
Brayshaw

The rest honestly are not even worth mentioning. One has had injury problems or is no where near as good as the other (or both are average like the Guthrie's)

 

[Cursed Cat]

Who are the top 5 brothers playing in the AFL at the moment.
I will have a try and I’m sure I’ll miss some.

1- Brayshaw brothers
2- Daicos
3-Guthrie
4- Mckay
5- Curnow

Considered for the 5- Mcartin McGovern

Henrys

 

[Cmarsh]

King brothers are mossing. And De koening.

 

[Cringle]

The Guthrie brothers in the top 3 LOL

 

[PrinceCharles]

Kennedy brothers would have been up there a couple of years ago.

 

[Milanista28]

Not in the top 5 but the Daveys another duo, there's a 3rd as well, apparently can play.

 

[GROTTO]

McGovern Brothers right up there.






In who eats the most fast food.

 

[00Stinger]

Daicos
McLachlan
Brayshaw

The rest honestly are not even worth mentioning. One has had injury problems or is no where near as good as the other (or both are average like the Guthrie's)

so Daicos brothers who between them have one Rising star award are the best? lol

The best combo are the McGoverns on produced results. Yes one is a piece of poo ( the Carlton one) but the other is/has been a ******* star and has all of the rest combined covered on produced form

FYI the Daicos bros will probably easily be the best combo

 

[Osho]

The Daicos boys look marvellous.

The Marvellous Miraculous Macedonians.

I trust they are indeed Macedonian. No offence intended.

 

[Kipz]

so Daicos brothers who between them have one Rising star award are the best? lol

The best combo are the McGoverns on produced results. Yes one is a piece of poo ( the Carlton one) but the other is/has been a ******* star and has all of the rest combined covered on produced form

FYI the Daicos bros will probably easily be the best combo

OP says the best playing at the moment, nothing about their achievements. If you think the McGovern's are currently the best, then lol @ you

 

[The 747]

Who are the top 5 brothers playing in the AFL at the moment.
I will have a try and I’m sure I’ll miss some.

1- Brayshaw brothers
2- Daicos
3-Guthrie
4- Mckay
5- Curnow

Considered for the 5- Mcartin McGovern

Not brothers

 

[Lingsface]

I think Daicos will be the best no doubt, Guthrie both just won a premiership and one got the best and fairest as well for the year.

Good point on the Kings they are the 2 that if reach there potential could be better than the Daicos brothers.

Brayshaws have the most runs on the board both top 5 Brownlow finishes afl mvp premierships and consistently good players.

 

[00Stinger]

OP says the best playing at the moment, nothing about their achievements. If you think the McGovern's are currently the best, then lol @ you

so we are basing it on 2 games?

 

[74561347]

Undertaker and kane

 

[PhatBoy]

The Guthrie brothers in the top 3 LOL

One of them is a premiership best and fairest and recent all Australian so I don’t think it’s as far fetched as you think. His brother held down a permanent spot averaging 15 touches out of the backline in that same flag winning side. It’s not as inconceivable if we are talking about a reasonably extended period of time as what you think. Still, I’d have them behind the Brayshaws, probably the McKays, the McGoverns etc

 

[Kipz]

so we are basing it on 2 games?

Didn't watch the footy last year?

 

[PrinceCharles]

Think the Curnow's are being underrated, reigning Coleman medalist and a 200 gamer who locks down on the best mid each week, runs 15ks and averages 22 touches a game doing it.

 

[Grand Uncle Horace]

The Warners will get a mention next year.

Tom and Paddy McToughies will both be in the run for AA this year.

 

[00Stinger]

Didn't watch the footy last year?

Well if you want to go on the last 12 months its the Brayshaws by a large margin

Both in the AA squad & one won the AFL MVP

 

[Kipz]

Well if you want to go on the last 12 months its the Brayshaws by a large margin

Both in the AA squad & one won the AFL MVP

I had them in my 3 but I believe the Daicos boys are better looking so had them on top.

 

[Cringle]

What about in terms of package value?

How would you split the McKays, Kings and Daicos brothers?

Ed would be worth nothing. However, you’d probably value Charlie enough to overtake obviously the Guthries and maybe the Brayshaws (KPF vs Mid).

 

[Lingsface]

What about in terms of package value?

How would you split the McKays, Kings and Daicos brothers?

Ed would be worth nothing. However, you’d probably value Charlie enough to overtake obviously the Guthries and maybe the Brayshaws (KPF vs Mid).

Yeah this is good.

I think I’d take

Kings #1 two dominant big guys.

#2 Daicos just because they are that good.

#3 Mckay one at each end very good players, I’m taking Carlton Mckay before Curnow.

#4 Brayshaws
Andy is the aflmvp Angus is a 100 percent player every week, as close to the safest choice you could have of the brothers even at #1- potential less than Kings Daicos but in terms of your getting two great players locked in they could be 1.

#5 Guthries
One is a star one is improving and ready to become a top level half back flanker. Also very safe pick.

 

[Cringle]

Yeah this is good.

I think I’d take

Kings #1 two dominant big guys.

#2 Daicos just because they are that good.

#3 Mckay one at each end very good players, I’m taking Carlton Mckay before Curnow.

#4 Brayshaws
Andy is the aflmvp Angus is a 100 percent player every week, as close to the safest choice you could have of the brothers even at #1- potential less than Kings Daicos but in terms of your getting two great players locked in they could be 1.

#5 Guthries
One is a star one is improving and ready to become a top level half back flanker. Also very safe pick.

I don’t think anyone is taking Cam & Zach Guthrie over Charlie tbh

 

[DavidKing]

Not enough respect here for Paddy and Thomson Dow, both elite midfielders with sublime skills.