Preview Rd 9 vs GWS - Changes & prematch discussion

[Flawed Genius]

All in here

 

[Deddy]

If McDonald plays next week I’ll spew. Not sure what he’s offering at the moment.

 

[rippersnipper]

Goldy, Turner and Lmac are on thin ice. A couple of others in a bit of bother too. Ahern, Walker, garner and zurhaar should be in with a shout. Would say LDU but he got injured.

 

[The Nostradamus]

Unleash ahern vs his old teammates

 

[Isaac Cumming No 1]

Unleash ahern vs his old teammates

Yes please
I'm going and would love to watch his debut. In anyone's colors.

 

[remfan101]

Out: Turner, Goldstein
In: Zurhaar, McKay

Williams - Tarrant - Thompson
Wright - McKay - MacMillan
Simpkin - Cunnington - Waite
Atley - Wood - Zurhaar
Ziebell - Brown - Anderson

Daw - Jacobs - Higgins

Int: Dumont, Clarke, McDonald, Hartung

Daw, McKay and Waite to ruck against Lobb. Goldy v Preuss in the VFL, a spot is there if either can show any glimpse of form around the ground.

 

[roos_fanatic08]

Out: Turner & Mcdonald

In: Zuhaar & Ahern

Goldy in thin ice surely. He is just lucky that Preuss hasn’t stepped it up in the twos.

 

[trooroo4life]

Out: LMac - Turner - Goldy (wishful thinking)
In: Ahern - Zurhaar - McKay (Maj to ruck)

 

[billnats]

Simples:
In: Ahern, Zurhaar
Out: LMac, Turner

If Waite doesn’t get up, BMac comes in.

 

[Rod Stroker]

Turner needs a spell. Not impacting enough. I'd be OK for Ahern to come in.

I'm also be OK with LMac having a spell, but I think he'll survive. He did get 24 today.

 

[Reagan Smash]

Turner and McDonald need a dose of reality and be dropped to the 2's.

On principle alone I would also drop Hartung and Clarke for their effort in the 3rd

 

[Chadwiko]

Out: McDonald, Wright
In: Ahern, Zurhaar

 

[Billy Not Really]

We can actually win this considering how we took it very hard to the premiers, beat sydney etc. Giants have looked pretty soft all season and we play very hard, and it won't match their game style.

I'm optimistic and we need to come outta this tough run of 4 games with at least 2 wins.

 

[naturally north]

Out: McDonald, Wright
In: Ahern, Zurhaar

Was wonderin whether Wright would get a mention, slower than a wet week. McDonald was borderline getting dropped for this game was given a specific role, unknown to what that was. I think he'll survive.

Turner I feel is safe until we get Garner back, well if he ever gets back.

Unless Waite has suffered his usual six week injury I see no changes.

 

[domiroo]

Out : Turner , Write & Goldstein maybe Clarke
In : Ahern , Pruess & Zurhar maybe Walker . Funny thing is we could have got Charlie Spargo instead of Walker and he is running riot for Melbourne ..

 

[Smoocher]

Out : Turner , Write & Goldstein maybe Clarke
In : Ahern , Pruess & Zurhar maybe Walker . Funny thing is we could have got Charlie Spargo instead of Walker and he is running riot for Melbourne ..

Absolutely correct. We are in a rebuild and pick a project player in Walker when lots of ready made midfielders still available.

Not a time to pick maybe/what ifs and could be.




Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

 

[remfan101]

Out : Turner , Write & Goldstein maybe Clarke
In : Ahern , Pruess & Zurhar maybe Walker . Funny thing is we could have got Charlie Spargo instead of Walker and he is running riot for Melbourne ..

Kelly is the one we should have drafted, was saying it at the time and will probably be saying it till the day I die. Bloke's an absolute gun, and we'd be top 4 right now if we'd picked him.

 

[domiroo]

Kelly is the one we should have drafted, was saying it at the time and will probably be saying it till the day I die. Bloke's an absolute gun, and we'd be top 4 right now if we'd picked him.

Which Kelly ?

 

[Passmore]

Kelly is the one we should have drafted, was saying it at the time and will probably be saying it till the day I die. Bloke's an absolute gun, and we'd be top 4 right now if we'd picked him.

There’s already a bit of talk around him going home.

 

[tazaa]

Who did Wright play on?
Turner out
Zurhaar in

Considering GWS like to play attacking footy then Wood Brown Ziebell Waite stays

 

[Passmore]

Absolutely correct. We are in a rebuild and pick a project player in Walker when lots of ready made midfielders still available.

Not a time to pick maybe/what ifs and could be.




Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Every drafted player is a maybe/could be/what if. Judge them in 3 years.

 

[kool kangas]

Turner 6 possessions today out for Ahern and Goldy 8 possessions out for Preuss. Leave Maj on the backline and ruck occasionally. McDonald to last another week.

 

[Mav]

I’d like JZ to go back to the 2’s to find some form but we may be better served playing him so we keep his trade value up.

 

[King Hansen]

It's time for Ahern

 

[Billy Not Really]

Absolutely correct. We are in a rebuild and pick a project player in Walker when lots of ready made midfielders still available.

Not a time to pick maybe/what ifs and could be.

Except it kinda is, despite performances is been clear from the outset we're in rebuilding and shuffling phase of players, and the VFL backend has all the work to do. It is a time to experiment and pick maybes, it's not like we had the foresight to both know how decent we'd be so far this year AND know to pick Charlie Spargo over a prospect like Walker.

There’s already a bit of talk around him going home.

Some say his dad used to play for North