Riewoldt Vs Franklin Vs Brown Vs Pavlich

[a_fighting_fury]

1. Pav
2. Roo
3. Brown
4. Franklin

 

[NatheM]

Brown, Pavlich and Riewoldt are all at least 26 years old.

Pavlich has a well earned reputations for missing vital set shots.

Riewoldt has a reputation for missing set shots, as well as getting a lot of ball away from goals.

Brown has a reputation for getting injured, due to his style of play.

Quite simply, it has to be Franklin. Riewoldt and Brown then in some order, in front of Pavlich.

I would agree with you, but your missing out on a small piece of detail.

It was said that "if they were all 18"

So seeing what they have done *slash their potential, Pavlich would easily be my first choice.
You know im unbiased because non of those players are from Collingwood.
Pav ftw.

 

[Carlton_Blues]

Fev & Pav in our forward line would see us top 4! Alas, we can only deam of it.

 

[MinerBoy]

Brown and Franklin are hard to split IMO, both have played in good sides and been dominate, however the fact Franklin has played better footy earlier in his career then Brown as the number 1 forward, so i would take him just above Brown. So IMO:
1. Pavlich
2. Franklin
3. Brown
4. Riewoldt

Does it seem coincidental to you that we were a rabble when we drafted Franklin and the season we won the premiership he won the Coleman Medal and our club B&F?

He didn't waltz into a dominant side, he was a primary reason it became a dominant side. Even this season when the side isn't dominating, and he himself isn't dominating, he is still the leading goal scorer out of all these players.

 

[HolyWars]

Buddy
Pav
Roo
Brown