Robbo's mid-year AA. Grundy loses out to Gawn. Maynard included

Remove this Banner Ad

Sea fog

Norm Smith Medallist
Jun 24, 2012
6,509
4,810
Melbourne
AFL Club
Collingwood
Jack Steele, Brayden Maynard among new faces in Mark Robinson’s mid-season All-Australian team
Who would’ve thought Nat Fyfe and Patrick Cripps would be missing from the mid-year All-Australian side? See who Mark Robinson has named in his 2020 team of the year — so far.
Mark Robinson, Herald Sun
Subscriber only
|
July 31, 2020 2:37pm



FOXSPORTS0:34
'Dusty, you are a freak!'
AFL: Dustin Martin continued his dominance against the Western Bulldogs, booting three goals in Brownlow level display.

MORE IN SPORT

Dark place: Bucky reveals depth of depression battle


Inside Dees’ review with ‘p****d off’ Goodwin


Brereton unloads on ‘idiot’ Scott over salary cap claims

similars

It’s a crazy season, so we’re borrowing a line from Bob Dylan.
So, come gather ’round people, wherever you roam …
That’s the footy to the halfway mark of the season.
In this cluster muck, we’ve gathered at home as the footballers have roamed far and wide and everything before us and them “is a changing”.
So, too, are potential All-Australian spots.
Who would have thought at the start of the season the likes of Jacob Weitering, Brayden Maynard and Caleb Daniel would unseat the likes of Jeremy McGovern and Bachar Houli from defence?
Or the Patties — Cripps and Dangerfield — and Nathan Fyfe wouldn’t get a spot in the midfield.
Top-100-paid-AFL-players-650x100-black.jpg
026821f5e61721140bacdfc13b17a9dc

The Cats champ makes the team on the bench, but Port’s Travis Boak, Melbourne’s Christian Petracca and Brisbane’s Lachie Neale get the gigs in the centre square.
With Max Gawn as the ruck.

St Kilda’s Jack Steele makes the bench. The bum-down, head-up midfielder is running third in the coaches award.
His consistency gets him a spot. And the fact he curtails the opposition’s best midfielder, while winning the ball himself.
He is one of the competition’s most valuable players.
Kayo is your ticket to the 2020 Toyota AFL Premiership Season. Watch every match of every round Live & On-Demand. New to Kayo? Get your 14-day free trial & start streaming instantly >
Caleb Daniel is an elite ball-user coming out of the backline.
Caleb Daniel is an elite ball-user coming out of the backline.
The backline has three relative newbies.
The Bulldogs’ Daniel the distributor, Weitering the stopper and Maynard the general defender.
They join Harris Andrews, Dane Rampe and Nick Haynes.
For the last spot on the bench, it was a decision between West Coast’s Brad Sheppard, Richmond’s Nick Vlastuin and Collingwood’s Darcy Moore.
I opted for Sheppard, who could be leading the club best-and-fairest at this point.
Moore, of course, was unlucky, but you can say that about plenty of players.
Dustin Martin slots in at mid-forward as does Toby Greene, while Charlie Dixon and Tom Hawkins take the key posts.
Dixon has been the most threatening of the key forwards, while Hawkins rates elite for disposals, marks, forward 50 marks, score involvements and goals.
Mark Robinson's Team - 0


Sydney’s Tom Papley was one the first magnets put on the board and he leads the Coleman Medal, while the other forward pocket landed with Dan Butler ahead of Charlie Cameron.
Of course, Cameron is the talent of the two, but Butler’s defensive commitment won him the spot. Gee, it was close.
This year might be the year the selectors recognise legitimate wingmen and not plonk gun mids in those positions.
DID ROBBO GET IT RIGHT? HAVE YOUR SAY IN THE COMMENTS SECTION BELOW
That’s why Brisbane’s Hugh McCluggage and Geelong’s Mitch Duncan deserve their spots — they are legitimate wingmen and it’s a position that has effectively been discarded over the past decade by AA selectors.
The skipper?
After handing over the captaincy at Port Adelaide, Boak’s standing as a leader has not diminished.
The coach?
Brett Ratten, Ken Hinkley or Stuart Dew were top of the list. Ratten gets the nod at the midway mark.
 
Far enough on Grundy omission. Started out on fire but has had some fairly mediocre games mixed in.

I think Moore has been better than Weiters because of his awesome rebounding, but understand it's a 50/50 call.

The Pendlebury omission is a shocker. Genuinely been in the top handful in the league yet again this year. Much better and more consistent than Martin, Dangerfield and Duncan.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Was he Drunk when he did this?
Gawn has been better than Grundy this year specifically in the last few games, even though the Demons are not travelling well
 
Gawn has been better than Grundy this year, even though the Demons are not travelling well

Guess Winning does not mean much then for AA Then.

Moore not there is a Joke Really
 
I have no problem with Grundy not being the AA ruckman for 2020. Gawn has been better & Nic Nat had his measure.
The season isn't over yet though & form isn't permanent, class is.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Can't see Moore getting AA this year because Weitering is flavour of the month and Andrews will be pencilled in. He has to stay fit too.

and Moore plays for Collingwood
 
Why should anyone care what Robbo thinks?Since when did he become an expert on actual football matters?
I know this topic has been discussed a lot around here but I cant remember a single time he has said anything that was interesting or insightful, or that made me think about football in a different way. Whereas I've lost count of the amount of people on this board who have done that
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top