Round 10 trades

[Sherman41]

And then he underperformed Round 1 and then the whole thing got shut down and he had two months to heal.

Valid point.
I’d love to know which player doesn’t have a niggle during a home and away season though.

Everyone is carrying something.

 

[FFB1]

Take out his 145 and the injury score and it’s a 98 average for Stewart. Good enough for $443k? Contemplating offing Docherty for him, normally wouldn’t entertain a sideways trade but Docherty is sitting at a 77 average over his past 5 / 82 over his past 3, for $25k more. A trade for $25k doesn’t seem a smart move normally.

 

[vanders]

Take out his 145 and the injury score and it’s a 98 average for Stewart. Good enough for $443k? Contemplating offing Docherty for him, normally wouldn’t entertain a sideways trade but Docherty is sitting at a 77 average over his past 5 / 82 over his past 3, for $25k more. A trade for $25k doesn’t seem a smart move normally.

He had an interupted preseason which is why nobody started the season with him but was one of the best defenders last year.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Sholl to debut.

WaynesWorld19

 

[Red Syrah]

simpson or rankine to trade out?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Sholl to debut.

WaynesWorld19

Interesting .....elite kick, very outside though ....if they play him in DEF .....if they play him Wing

 

[rocker_oz33]

Interesting .....elite kick, very outside though ....if they play him in DEF .....if they play him Wing

Who they drop/rest.
Skywalker?

 

[keithrichards]

1 trade has been made already (Rankine to Draper)

Thoughts on the next couple?

Initially looked at Devon/Simpkin>Neale

Could otherwise do Budarick>Rookie and Hill>Neale but that wipes out 2 x DPP.

Seems like most my rookies will hold value for at least 1 more week

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Who they drop/rest.
Skywalker?

Not sure ....trying to find out now, but if I'm a betting man, Laird will play more midfield minutes ......particularly given there's a cloud over Smith who played midfield last week

Would not surprise if M.Crouch makes way again

 

[rocker_oz33]

Not sure ....trying to find out now, but if I'm a betting man, Laird will play more midfield minutes ......particularly given there's a cloud over Smith who played midfield last week

Would not surprise if M.Crouch makes way again

Hope your boys go better this week.



I'm looking for a rookie to bring in unsure who yet..

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Hope your boys go better this week.



I'm looking for a rookie to bring in unsure who yet..

Guaranteed mate ....no questions, it'll happen

When you're already at rockbottom, everything from there is better

 

[rocker_oz33]

Guaranteed mate ....no questions, it'll happen

When you're already at rockbottom, everything from there is better

Pound the rock...

 

[Borgan]

will we get geelongs team in 10 mins? simpson goes if not named instead of rankine

 

[Borgan]

asked it before but 1. pickett to duncan or 2. starc to stewart?

 

[Ollie1981]

I don't know weather to just hold Simpkin and hope he comes good. Devon Smith is the other one that's doing nothing.
My Thoughts
Option1
Rankine > Skinner
Simpkin > Duncan
Conroy > Draper leaved $82,400

Option 2
Rankine > Skinner
Devon > T Stewart (Via Simpkin to forward and Stark to Mid)
Conroy > Draper

Or if you can come up with a better trade


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Red Syrah]

asked it before but 1. pickett to duncan or 2. starc to stewart?

starc to stewart

Stewart more chance to be top 6 defender than Duncan in mids.
Pickett has more money to make and Starc doesnt

 

[GT619]

We don't really tag I expect Simkin to tear us a new one.
Just my feels.

Can you trade someone else.

Can we trade 2020 instead

 

[GT619]

Righto 2 trades left 100k in piggy bank.

Unsure which rookie to grab.ANYone got some input.

Would like sturt back soon.

View attachment 927228

Willo to sholl from crows

 

[hoddo]

Guaranteed mate ....no questions, it'll happen

When you're already at rockbottom, everything from there is better

You'll do well. Melbourne have a habit of playing struggling teams back into form.

 

[CrozaN]

Not worried about Witherden getting dropped?

Why would Witherden get dropped lol?

 

[Spanish Sahara]

Why would Witherden get dropped lol?

Because Birchall and Rich need to come back into the side. Potentially Lester too.

Look he may well keep his spot now (he played really well on the weekend) but he was out of favour at the start of the season

EDIT - they preferred a mix of Starce, Birchall, Rich, Ah chee, Bailey to go with Andrews and Gardiner

 

[CrozaN]

Because Birchall and Rich need to come back into the side. Potentially Lester too.

Look he may well keep his spot now (he played really well on the weekend) but he was out of favour at the start of the season

Withdern is like one of their best defenders lol and he seems over his injury after last weeks performance.

Yes but i highly doubt they will drop him for Rich.....witherden played almost every game last 2 years even with Rich in side.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

You'll do well. Melbourne have a habit of playing struggling teams back into form.

We should cry together over a beer .....talk about a sombre thought

 

[Spanish Sahara]

Withdern is like one of their best defenders lol and he seems over his injury after last weeks performance.

Yes but i highly doubt they will drop him for Rich.....witherden played almost every game last 2 years even with Rich in side.

I am fairly certain he hasn't been injured. Has not been on any injury lists and I know for a fact he was out of favour during pre season

 

[Barnzy]

Trade out Hill or Starc for Stewart?