Mongoose528
Senior List
- Mar 22, 2017
- 199
- 140
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Trades Round 17 Trades
- Thread starter yogibbear
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Sep 8, 2013
- 5,616
- 9,103
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Greenwood to Steele
Or
Gray to Stevens/Macrae/Yeo?
Or
Gray to Stevens/Macrae/Yeo?
SM
Bigfooty Legend
Yeah, might go Greenwood to Jelwood instead just for the extra cash and with the aim of Heppell > Rocky next week.
Witherden my only starting rookie now and with the scores he's churning out I'm perfectly happy to leave him. After Hepp > Rocky I get into the luxuries. Almost contemplating ditching Grundy if Cox stays in the team.
browncow
Club Legend
First trade is Marchbank to Joel Selwood.
I am a bit worried about the injuries to Kennedy, Jones and Newnes (any news?).
I have around $100,000 in the bank after the first trade so weighing up what to do with the second. Obviously injuries may dictate that trade, but I would like to hold Newnes and Kennedy if it is just the one week out.
Backline - Adams, Laird, Newnes, Lloyd, Ellis, Jones. (Ryan, Vickers-Willis)
Fwd - Yeo, Heeney, Macrae, Sheed, Dahlhaus, Gray (Pickett, Eddy)
Question is do I go Jones to Simpson or Gray to Stevens?
Yes I know I have Vickers-Willis, Pickett and Eddy to trade out, but I want to go a double 'upgrade' this week.
Or am I better off getting some cash by going Vickers-Willis to Hibberd or that new Freo rookie I can't spell?
I am a bit worried about the injuries to Kennedy, Jones and Newnes (any news?).
I have around $100,000 in the bank after the first trade so weighing up what to do with the second. Obviously injuries may dictate that trade, but I would like to hold Newnes and Kennedy if it is just the one week out.
Backline - Adams, Laird, Newnes, Lloyd, Ellis, Jones. (Ryan, Vickers-Willis)
Fwd - Yeo, Heeney, Macrae, Sheed, Dahlhaus, Gray (Pickett, Eddy)
Question is do I go Jones to Simpson or Gray to Stevens?
Yes I know I have Vickers-Willis, Pickett and Eddy to trade out, but I want to go a double 'upgrade' this week.
Or am I better off getting some cash by going Vickers-Willis to Hibberd or that new Freo rookie I can't spell?
- Thread starter
- #30
just think his name is "knee who is" = nyhuis
i'm sure it's probs pronounced nigh-hughous or something....
rimb
Team Captain
- Jul 5, 2011
- 316
- 242
- AFL Club
- Geelong
Eskimo_Fennel
Team Captain
I'd go the second one. If Greenwood plays he has money to make, Gray isn't going to be top 6 (or 10/15). The others you mentioned probably will be.
A Freo supporter could probably help us out, I thought it was pronounced "Ny-house"
*EDIT - lad above me on the ball
As for trades this week, I'm bringing in J. Selwood and I'm not sure who else. Save for S. Darcy in the ruck, my next worst player is either Z. Tuohy or Dahlhaus. Thinking Tuohy to Kade, though might just flip a non-playing rookie for a playing rook.
- Thread starter
- #33
"Ny house"
As in "Daft punk is playing at"
What's your address I'm coming over!
J.Selwood now cheap, but could be cheaper next week.
Forwards have been such a pain this year.
MaCrae pretty consistent. Greene missing games( don't have), Dahl not firing (traded him out ages ago)
Boak scored his first 100 since I got him at DPP announcement.
Cant be to harsh on Sheed when Treloar puts up a similar score and many other players turn in the odd shocker.
Forwards have been such a pain this year.
MaCrae pretty consistent. Greene missing games( don't have), Dahl not firing (traded him out ages ago)
Boak scored his first 100 since I got him at DPP announcement.
Cant be to harsh on Sheed when Treloar puts up a similar score and many other players turn in the odd shocker.
SM
Bigfooty Legend
His BE is getting into the achievable territory for him now though so might be worth jumping on.
- Sep 8, 2013
- 5,616
- 9,103
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Good call. Doing the same with Neale. It's sideways but makes 100k for roughly the same average
bl4ke
Premiership Player
- Nov 17, 2014
- 3,893
- 5,371
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Leeds United
Yeah I'll either do it this week or next, Gaff's BE is a gettable 116 so it wont make much difference
- Jul 1, 2013
- 22,047
- 18,470
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Fulham, 76ers, Cubs, Bills
Thinking similarly with either Gaff or Jack Steven. I expect Gaff to get 120+ though against Freo, so perhaps wait a week, Jelwood won't rise (BE 131).
- Jul 1, 2013
- 22,047
- 18,470
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Fulham, 76ers, Cubs, Bills
253k in the bank
Thinking:
Nankervis to Macrae
then either:
Stef Martin to Kreuzer
OR
Greenwood to Papley
OR
Downgrade (Melican, Cousins or Beech)
Not keen on getting Kreuzer at max price but he is in such great form, and not keen on dumping Greenwood a couple of weeks early. But either of those trades will be improving my weekly points, whereas downgrade will just be gaining cash on bench.
Thinking:
Nankervis to Macrae
then either:
Stef Martin to Kreuzer
OR
Greenwood to Papley
OR
Downgrade (Melican, Cousins or Beech)
Not keen on getting Kreuzer at max price but he is in such great form, and not keen on dumping Greenwood a couple of weeks early. But either of those trades will be improving my weekly points, whereas downgrade will just be gaining cash on bench.
Jay-Z
North's Enforcer
Early days but thinking
Marchbank -> Zorko
Greenwood -> Macrae
Means the only rookies I'm fielding are Newman and Darcy. Happy with that.
But that could all be thrown out depending on injury news / team selection surprises later in then week
Marchbank -> Zorko
Greenwood -> Macrae
Means the only rookies I'm fielding are Newman and Darcy. Happy with that.
But that could all be thrown out depending on injury news / team selection surprises later in then week
If I can avoid any Thursday choas I can finally bring Docherty in. Tuohy can piss off his form has been terrible. Cue the 80 for Docherty this weekend.
Sixpence
Brownlow Medallist
At over 500k, not sure you can still call Newman a rookie! Only 20k behind Laird.
Sixpence
Brownlow Medallist
Fisher -> Jenkins is pretty much locked in.
Second is dependant on JPK starting:
Cousins/Bolton -> Nyhuis via Hibberd to mid.
Next week could be interesting. May do:
Martin -> Darcy
Cousins/Bolton (the one not traded this week) -> Selwood
Second is dependant on JPK starting:
Cousins/Bolton -> Nyhuis via Hibberd to mid.
Next week could be interesting. May do:
Martin -> Darcy
Cousins/Bolton (the one not traded this week) -> Selwood
Jay-Z
North's Enforcer
Yeah I almost left him out for that reason. Not worrying about him right now. Will probably end up keeping him
Yeah it's a gross situation.
I have him too and have been considering either him, Hannebery, or Treloar -> Kelly.
I currently have Treloar on the way out but I wonder if I'm being too reactionary just based on a particularly bad week.
Rockliff actually seems like the most rational option as there looks to be a direct line between the injury he suffered and his drop in form. But emotionally I'm letting the possibility of giving him the boot and then him going for a 180 or something get the better of me. Which I suspect is how all his owners are feeling right now.
Anyone have thoughts on Toby McLean?
Going at 105 over his last three, 88.8 over five, all at $459,000. My forward line looks like crap so this could be a decent upgrade for a few weeks (I don't think I can go any higher $$ at this stage); otherwise I either hold Buzza one more week, or upgrade him to someone like Gray (I know), Tom (J) Lynch (probably the safest bet). Any other cheapies I should consider?
Going at 105 over his last three, 88.8 over five, all at $459,000. My forward line looks like crap so this could be a decent upgrade for a few weeks (I don't think I can go any higher $$ at this stage); otherwise I either hold Buzza one more week, or upgrade him to someone like Gray (I know), Tom (J) Lynch (probably the safest bet). Any other cheapies I should consider?
- Thread starter
- #48
Kieran Jack. But has a cloud over his actual role when Swans have a full midfield. Because he played midfield after Hanners got corked last w/e and this w/e played midfield but JPK was late out. So............. iffy. I'm jumping on board assuming no carnage (Newnes)
browncow
Club Legend
Is it crazy to use my 2nd trade and spend $40,000 to go Vickers-Willis to to Witherden?
Anybody know his break even? He'd be on my bench with Ryan, but would be super handy to have floating between D7 and M9. Also means I can cash Ryan in when he maxes out.
Would also be good cover for Newnes or JPK either are out this week.
2nd trade if not that one would be Gray to Stevens.
Thoughts?
Anybody know his break even? He'd be on my bench with Ryan, but would be super handy to have floating between D7 and M9. Also means I can cash Ryan in when he maxes out.
Would also be good cover for Newnes or JPK either are out this week.
2nd trade if not that one would be Gray to Stevens.
Thoughts?
Witherden B.E of 2
(E. V-W B.E is 43)
Not a crazy trade at all. It betters your cash generation & points.
